00:00:05
[music] >> On January 12th, 2020, when police responded to a report of a man down in a
00:00:11
Jay County, Indiana roadway, they found 31-year-old Shay Bryer clinging to life.
00:00:18
Lead detective Ben Schwartz. It was at the hospital where they ended up finding the bullet wound in his back. There was
00:00:25
no exit wound. It was actually in his heart. He passed away. An investigation was launched and Shay's
00:00:32
family soon pointed police in the direction of a local high school softball coach, E.J. Stephen. She was
00:00:39
Shay's ex-fiancee and the mother of his child. I learned they had a rocky relationship. Shay and E.J. had been
00:00:46
battling over Shay's access to the child. Police questioned E.J. twice. And ultimately, she admitted that she
00:00:55
and one of her 18-year-old former players, Shelby Heaston, picked Shay up that night and that Shelby shot him. Why
00:01:04
did Shelby shoot him? He told me about it and he told me that I didn't think that he was going to die.
00:01:12
E.J. and Shelby were arrested and charged with murder. But at trial, E.J. took the stand and placed all the blame
00:01:20
on Shelby. Wes Shimanek was one of the prosecutors on the That she was essentially shocked and
00:01:29
surprised that Shelby did this. Prosecutors rejected that. This was all for her benefit.
00:01:36
But would a jury buy E.J.'s version of events? Shay's aunt, Tiffany McLaughlin, was worried. I felt like going into it
00:01:44
that she's going to be found guilty and then [music] I'm like, wait a second. What's happening here?