Search Captions & Ask AI

Serial killer identified through DNA as suspect in 1991 Austin yogurt shop murders

September 30, 2025 / 04:19

This episode covers the 1991 yogurt shop murders in Austin, Texas, the identification of a suspect through DNA, and the emotional impact on victims' families. Erin Morardi discusses the case's history and the recent breakthrough involving serial killer Robert Eugene Brashier.

The episode highlights the tragic events of December 6, 1991, when four teenage girls were murdered in a yogurt shop. The case remained unsolved for over 30 years until DNA evidence linked the crime to Brashier, who had a history of violence.

Retired investigator John Jones reflects on the emotional toll the case took on him and the families involved. He recalls the shock of the murders and his commitment to finding justice for the victims.

Sonora Thomas, sister of victim Eliza, shares her grief and the lasting impact of the tragedy on her family. The episode emphasizes the long struggle for answers and closure for the victims' families.

Erin Morardi provides context on the difficulties faced in solving the case, including the destruction of evidence when the yogurt shop was set on fire. The episode concludes with anticipation for a news conference revealing more details about the suspect.

TLDR

DNA links the 1991 yogurt shop murders to serial killer Robert Eugene Brashier, bringing closure to victims' families after decades of uncertainty.

Episode

4:19
00:00:00
And now to a stunning twist in a murder case that is haunted that has haunted rather Austin, Texas for more than 30
00:00:06
years. Happened back in 1991. Four teenage girls were found shot and killed in a yogurt shop. For years, the
00:00:14
question swirled about who was responsible for this horrible crime until now. 48 Hours correspondent Erin
00:00:20
Morardi has covered this story for decades and she was first to report that police have now identified a suspect
00:00:26
through DNA and he is a serial killer. Using advanced technology, a DNA match was just discovered in the long unsolved
00:00:37
1991 yogurt shop murders. Many, including the retired original investigator John Jones, wondered if the
00:00:46
killings of the four teenage girls would ever be solved. And then Jones received
00:00:52
a call from a current detective. >> It was kind of one surprise after another, but it all made sense. And when
00:00:59
he got to the part about the DNA, I didn't quite know what to say. Jones told us that DNA found on one of
00:01:08
the teenagers bodies, including under her fingernails matched that of the deceased serial killer, Robert Eugene
00:01:16
Brashier. Brashier had been connected to three other murders in South Carolina and Missouri. In 1999,
00:01:25
after a standoff with police, Brashier shot and killed himself. The case may now be solved, but the images of
00:01:33
December 6th, 1991 will always remain with Jones. >> I can definitely still see it.
00:01:41
>> Eliza Thomas, Jennifer and Sarah Harbison, and Amy Ays have been tied up and shot in the head. And then the
00:01:50
yogurt shop was set on fire. A task force worked for years to find the killers. Billboards asked for help as the
00:01:58
victim's families and the city of Austin grieved. >> I remember the shock. >> Sonora Thomas was 13 years old when her
00:02:07
only sibling, Eliza, was murdered. >> You just hold on to anything you can to get through these moments that are so
00:02:16
impossible. >> Police. Over the decades, there were arrests, even convictions. But those
00:02:24
convictions were overturned. It left Jones and the families in emotional turmoil. Jones long ago made a pledge to
00:02:33
the families involving the shirt he wore on the night of the murders. >> The next time they saw me with that
00:02:39
green and white shirt on, that was a signal to them that, you know, we knew who did it. And now, 33 years later,
00:02:48
that shirt he saved all those years can finally be worn. But what do you want for the families?
00:02:56
>> I want them to know who actually killed her girls. Answer the question on the billboard.
00:03:03
Who killed these girls? He did. >> Boy, he did. Arian Mory, Erin Morardi joins us now from Austin where there
00:03:12
will be a news conference later this morning to give us the rest of the details. But Erin, I've been watching
00:03:17
this series on the HBO um on the HBO uh streaming service. So, I've been very fascinated by this case from the very
00:03:25
beginning. What can you tell us about this suspect and why has it been so difficult to solve this case after all
00:03:30
these years? >> You know, Gail, I hope they really have it. Um, this guy is a bad guy. Buriers
00:03:39
is a serial killer, rapist, and a pedophile, but most of his crimes happened after the yogurt shop. It
00:03:47
wasn't until after he shot himself that he was connected to the other murders. And then add to that that there was
00:03:54
whoever did kill these girls set the yogurt shop on fire. That destroyed so much of the evidence. Luckily, the
00:04:02
initial detectives hung on to some forensic evidence and preserved it, but then it was only a uh just a
00:04:11
semi-profile. So, those are some of the problems they've had in this case. All right, Erin, thank you very

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 90
    Most shocking
  • 90
    Most heartbreaking
  • 90
    Biggest twist
  • 85
    Most emotional

Episode Highlights

  • Murder Case Twist
    A DNA match reveals a suspect in the 1991 yogurt shop murders, a serial killer.
    “The case may now be solved, but the images of December 6th, 1991 will always remain with Jones.”
    @ 01m 31s
    September 30, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • It was kind of one surprise after another, but it all made sense.
    Serial killer identified through DNA as suspect in 1991 Austin yogurt shop murders
  • I want them to know who actually killed her girls.
    Serial killer identified through DNA as suspect in 1991 Austin yogurt shop murders
  • This guy is a bad guy. Brashier is a serial killer, rapist, and a pedophile.
    Serial killer identified through DNA as suspect in 1991 Austin yogurt shop murders

Key Moments

  • DNA Match00:31
  • Emotional Turmoil02:24
  • Long-Awaited Answers02:48
  • Bad Guy Revealed03:34

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown