Search Captions & Ask AI

Sneak peek: Playing by the Rules?

March 10, 2016 / 03:12

This episode covers the David Temple murder case, featuring discussions on his conviction, trial, and new developments. Kelly Sigler, a former Harris County prosecutor, reflects on the case and its implications.

David Temple was convicted of murdering his wife, Belinda Temple, and their unborn child. Sigler discusses the trial's fairness and the evidence presented, highlighting the emotional toll on Temple's family.

New attorneys have emerged with fresh evidence, including a complete investigative report that was previously suppressed. Sigler argues that Temple did not receive a fair trial and calls for the case to be reopened.

Throughout the episode, various perspectives on the trial and its aftermath are shared, emphasizing the complexities of the legal process and the pursuit of justice.

TLDR

David Temple's murder conviction is questioned as new evidence emerges, prompting calls for a retrial and highlighting issues of fairness in the legal process.

Episode

3:12
00:00:01
We the jury find the defendant David Mark Temple guilty of murder as charged in the
00:00:09
indictment. David Temple was convicted after a six-week trial by a fair and impartial jury for executing his wife
00:00:17
and unborn child. He was given a life sentence. He's sitting behind bars and that's where he deserves to be. My name
00:00:24
is Kelly Sigler. I was a Harris County prosecutor for 21 years. You have the right to expect us to tell you the
00:00:31
truth. The last murder case I handled here in Harris County was the David Temple case. David Temple was in Katy
00:00:39
High School a big man on campus because he was a big football star out there. Belinda Temple, the kind of girl that
00:00:46
nobody could say anything ugly or bad about. They had a son named Evan and the facts of the case were just so different
00:00:55
and horrible. We've been covering the case of David Temple for eight years, and he has always maintained his
00:01:01
innocence. Now, dramatic new developments may give him a shot at freedom. I've known it from day one that
00:01:09
this day would come, and um we're getting close to the end. I know this has been a 16-year journey for
00:01:20
David and our family. And we are here today to say again, David is innocent. I do not believe David Temple got a fair
00:01:32
trial. No person with eyes and ears and half a brain can say David Temple got a fair trial. Mr. Darren made the argument
00:01:38
that there were more than one burglar. Dick Darren was the trial lawyer for David Temple. Dick did the best that he
00:01:44
could with what he had. We objected and asked that she stay in the record. There are new attorneys with new
00:01:52
ammunition. On my left is the complete investigative report. This was never seen. This is what was suppressed.
00:02:02
[Music] Did you turn over the 1400 pages of police reports? No. Every single thing
00:02:10
under the law Mr. Degaran was entitled to was turned over to him. I care about what I do. I care
00:02:20
about the process. And this process shook me. Kids in Katie, lots of them got shotguns. There were alternate
00:02:29
suspects in this case. What in the world do they have to do with who killed Belinda Temple? Nothing. She lied. She
00:02:36
cheated. and she broke the rules. That's not That's not Now the former prosecutor is on the defensive.
00:02:46
Eventually, everybody's going to understand that the truth is what happened in that courtroom and it's all
00:02:52
going to finally be over with. We call upon the Harris County District Attorney to immediately reopen the case. If David
00:02:59
Temple doesn't get a new trial and due process is dead in Texas and we should all just go home.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most heartbreaking
  • 80
    Most controversial
  • 75
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Most surprising

Episode Highlights

  • David Temple Convicted
    David Temple was convicted of murdering his wife and unborn child after a six-week trial.
    “He was given a life sentence.”
    @ 00m 17s
    March 10, 2016
  • Call for Justice
    Kelly Sigler demands the reopening of David Temple's case, arguing for a new trial.
    “If David Temple doesn't get a new trial, due process is dead in Texas.”
    @ 03m 01s
    March 10, 2016

Episode Quotes

  • David is innocent.
    Sneak peek: Playing by the Rules?
  • This process shook me.
    Sneak peek: Playing by the Rules?

Key Moments

  • Guilty Verdict00:04
  • Life Sentence00:17
  • Claims of Innocence01:26
  • Trial Fairness Questioned01:32
  • Reopen the Case02:56

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown