00:00:00
on Halloween 2020 19-year-old Libby Lewis was found shot dead in her car on the side of the road her ex-boyfriend
00:00:08
was discovered nearby bloodied and disoriented he said he had no memory of what happened 48 Hours correspondent
00:00:14
Peter vant looks at how authorities piece together the events of that night where's my kid I don't care
00:00:22
where's my kid on October 31st 2020 in the Tiny Town of hemp Hill Texas Darcy Bass was captured on police body cam
00:00:32
pleading for answers about her 19-year-old daughter Livy Lewis who had been shot in her car on the side of this
00:00:40
road will y'all tell me something well where's my kid where is she at I didn't know anything I just
00:00:50
wanted her to be okay where is my child I told you where your child in this car what car she's in this girl right
00:00:59
here behind me Livy did not survive also at the scene was Livy's ex-boyfriend then 24-year-old
00:01:11
Matthew Edgar he was found in the fetal position behind that vehicle that Levy was found in when was the last time you
00:01:17
saw liby Sabine County Sheriff's investigator JP McDon interviewed Edgar at the hospital where he laid blooded
00:01:27
but uninjured how'd you get all the blood over your face don't know Edgar claimed to have no
00:01:34
memory of what had landed him in the hospital you don't know how you ended up on the ground behind the car Sir with
00:01:42
the dead girl in have a clue what are you thinking I'm thinking that he's not telling me the
00:01:49
truth he's just basically telling you a Texas fairy tale right correct McDonna saw Edgar as a murder suspect and
00:01:56
arrested him but Shawn Dunn believes that his friend Matthew Edgar is not a killer but a victim do you believe that
00:02:04
someone else pulled that trigger I do I believe it was someone that was close to Matthew someone that
00:02:12
was involved in events of that evening Peter vanan joins us now uh so blood on them disoriented but what
00:02:21
evidence did they find on Matthew Edgar that shows he shot her well the evidence
00:02:26
that they have is he was found on the ground behind Livy's car she's in the car she's been shot uh and killed his
00:02:34
rifle was at the scene okay and also the on the night of the murder his ex-wife who was a friend of liy texted him and
00:02:42
she was very concerned about Libby because she she'd heard them arguing and and heard this this verbal threat made
00:02:48
she said where is she and he answered back with one word dead and investigators say at that time they
00:02:54
believe only the killer would have known that so what did his defense argue they
00:02:59
argue with that they should have pursued other suspects because there was DNA found both on Matthew and on Livy that
00:03:07
was never identified it was not their DNA and part of that was blood evidence and so they're suggesting well there may
00:03:14
have been another as salent also that rifle was never checked for fingerprints or DNA and so it's a very bizarre thing
00:03:21
and as you you saw in that video Matthew's face is covered in blood it's not his blood it's not Livy's blood and
00:03:29
to this day is a mystery of where that came from wow oh man Peter vant thank you so much we're going to have to tune
00:03:34
in for this you can watch Peter's 48 Hours report the blackout murder of Livy Lewis tomorrow night at 109 Central
00:03:42
right here on cbsn streaming on Paramount Plus