Search Captions & Ask AI

"The Dexter Killer"'s letters revealed for the first time on television

April 22, 2022 / 04:15

This episode of 48 Hours covers the case of Mark Twitchell, known as the Dexter Killer, who was convicted of murdering Johnny Altinger in 2008. The episode features letters written by Twitchell while in prison, revealing his fascination with the fictional character Dexter Morgan from the TV series Dexter. Investigative journalist Steve Lillibun discusses his correspondence with Twitchell, who wrote around 350 pages detailing his thoughts and motivations.

Twitchell posed as a woman on a dating website to lure Altinger to a garage where he killed him. Lillibun notes that Twitchell appeared to be an average person with aspirations of filmmaking, lacking any obvious red flags. Retired FBI criminal profiler Julia Kelly analyzes Twitchell's writings, suggesting he identified with Dexter but targeted innocent victims.

The episode highlights Twitchell's meticulous planning, including a kill room set up with plastic sheeting, similar to scenes from Dexter. As Twitchell becomes eligible for early parole in 2023, experts express skepticism about his potential rehabilitation, emphasizing his lack of remorse.

Troy Roberts, a contributor to 48 Hours, discusses the chilling nature of Twitchell's case and the disturbing contrast between his outward appearance and his violent fantasies. The episode concludes with a preview of Roberts' report on the case.

TLDR

Mark Twitchell, the Dexter Killer, wrote letters revealing his fascination with murder and his lack of remorse for killing Johnny Altinger.

Episode

4:15
00:00:00
for the first time on television 48 hours is revealing letters written by the so-called dexter killer police say
00:00:06
mark twitchell was fascinated with the fictional serial killer on the popular tv series dexter twitchell himself was
00:00:13
convicted in 2011 and while in prison he wrote dozens of detailed letters to an investigative journalist
00:00:20
48 hours contributor troy roberts spoke with that reporter and got a look at those letters
00:00:26
mark twitchell was an aspiring filmmaker husband and father when in 2008 he posed
00:00:32
as a woman on a dating website and lord johnny altinger a random stranger to a garage where he killed him
00:00:40
he was just a typical local guy who had dreams of making it big in hollywood action and really no red flags no
00:00:48
warning signs that something like this was on the horizon steve lillibun is an investigative
00:00:55
journalist and an author lil buen was stunned when he heard from mark twitchell as he began working on a book
00:01:01
about the case he wrote me probably 350 pages of letters the fact is society in general has a
00:01:09
deep and profound fascination with the dark side of human nature twitchell's fascination with the dark side seemed to
00:01:15
focus around the character dexter morgan from the showtime series mark twitchell
00:01:21
wrote to me quite extensively about his interest in dexter nobody would side with dexter morgan if you went around
00:01:27
slaughtering school teachers and mail carriers on a whim there's significant links to dexter
00:01:34
twitchell had a kill room set up with plastic sheeting he had a table set up for his victims he had
00:01:40
this kind of processing kit that was very similar to what dexter uses he's a depraved individual and he knows
00:01:46
that retired fbi criminal profiler julia kelly reviewed mark twitchell's writings
00:01:52
for 48 hours she thinks she knows what made twitchell tick i think he identified with dexter to
00:02:00
some degree i think he's different than dexter he's not killing bad guys he's killing very innocent good people living
00:02:07
productive lives cali believes twitchell took pleasure in planning and executing his crimes as if
00:02:14
they were romantic trysts he's targeting men that perhaps he would be interested in having a date with
00:02:23
it's a combination of a sexual motive and a thrill killing in 2023 twitchell will be eligible to
00:02:30
apply for early parole experts say it's a long shot mark twitchell cannot be rehabilitated this
00:02:38
is who he is and troy roberts is with us troy good morning wow this really is a look inside
00:02:43
the mind of a killer 350 letters and twitchell might be paroled is that true well uh he's going to apply um stranger
00:02:52
things have happened i can't imagine that they would grant him parole he hasn't expressed any remorse
00:02:59
for what he has done [Music] you know what was so remarkable about about this story is that he's
00:03:05
unremarkable an average guy he's kind of decent looking affable intelligent he's a
00:03:14
a husband a father and a guy you would chat to at a bar not knowing he harbors these sick
00:03:22
fantasies so you know looks can be deceiving you didn't meet him but the investigative reporter you spoke with
00:03:28
did what was her what was her impression that his impression was what i just just said i mean normal manipulative
00:03:36
uh charming guy um trying to win you over um uh but no hint of the dark side and
00:03:45
that's scary because you know you don't you know he's not frothing at the mouth his eyes
00:03:51
aren't spinning in his head right but and uh but he was able to do just so much harm there's no signs
00:03:58
no signal oh boy those images is the kill room with the trash bags haunting stuff uh troy thank
00:04:05
you very much can't wait to watch you can see troy's report the dexter killer on 48 hours tomorrow night at 10
00:04:10
9 central right here on cbs and on our streaming service paramount plus

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Biggest twist
  • 65
    Most intense
  • 60
    Most heartbreaking

Episode Highlights

  • The Dexter Killer
    Mark Twitchell, inspired by the fictional Dexter, committed horrific crimes in 2008.
    “He posed as a woman on a dating website and killed a random stranger.”
    @ 00m 29s
    April 22, 2022
  • Letters from a Killer
    Twitchell wrote 350 pages of letters while in prison, revealing his dark fascination.
    “The fact is society has a deep fascination with the dark side of human nature.”
    @ 01m 09s
    April 22, 2022
  • Parole Possibility
    In 2023, Twitchell will be eligible for early parole, despite experts' doubts about his rehabilitation.
    “Experts say it's a long shot; Twitchell cannot be rehabilitated.”
    @ 02m 30s
    April 22, 2022

Episode Quotes

  • Looks can be deceiving.
    "The Dexter Killer"'s letters revealed for the first time on television
  • Normal, manipulative, charming guy trying to win you over.
    "The Dexter Killer"'s letters revealed for the first time on television

Key Moments

  • Fascination with Dexter01:13
  • Unremarkable Killer03:05
  • Kill Room Discovery04:00

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown