
This episode of 48 Hours covers the case of Mark Twitchell, known as the Dexter Killer, who was convicted of murdering Johnny Altinger in 2008. The episode features letters written by Twitchell while in prison, revealing his fascination with the fictional character Dexter Morgan from the TV series Dexter. Investigative journalist Steve Lillibun discusses his correspondence with Twitchell, who wrote around 350 pages detailing his thoughts and motivations.
Twitchell posed as a woman on a dating website to lure Altinger to a garage where he killed him. Lillibun notes that Twitchell appeared to be an average person with aspirations of filmmaking, lacking any obvious red flags. Retired FBI criminal profiler Julia Kelly analyzes Twitchell's writings, suggesting he identified with Dexter but targeted innocent victims.
The episode highlights Twitchell's meticulous planning, including a kill room set up with plastic sheeting, similar to scenes from Dexter. As Twitchell becomes eligible for early parole in 2023, experts express skepticism about his potential rehabilitation, emphasizing his lack of remorse.
Troy Roberts, a contributor to 48 Hours, discusses the chilling nature of Twitchell's case and the disturbing contrast between his outward appearance and his violent fantasies. The episode concludes with a preview of Roberts' report on the case.
Mark Twitchell, the Dexter Killer, wrote letters revealing his fascination with murder and his lack of remorse for killing Johnny Altinger.

This episode stands out for the following:
Looks can be deceiving."The Dexter Killer"'s letters revealed for the first time on television
Normal, manipulative, charming guy trying to win you over."The Dexter Killer"'s letters revealed for the first time on television