00:00:00
foreign [Music] and I have a series of texts from my brother-in-law Harold henthorne
00:00:34
regarding my sister Tony hinthorne this is Barry urgent Tony is injured to fall from Rock
00:00:43
she has been in a critical accident falls off of a ledge 140 feet and she does die there on the mountain
00:00:54
that night being the big brother and supposed to take care of your sister you can't do it
00:01:03
it's a bad feeling I need to be there for my sister and I couldn't Tony henthorne died in Rocky Mountain
00:01:11
National Park in 2012 in a fall it's not that unusual at all that people die in falls in the Rocky Mountains
00:01:21
I'm now at 9 354 feet and Counting take a look at this talk about rugged terrain
00:01:31
this is crazy since we first brought you this story new evidence some right here on the
00:01:38
mountain and that's just the beginning what's unusual is that in this case it happened with a guy whose first wife
00:01:46
died in such a freak accident 17 years earlier her name is Lynn hanthorne [Music]
00:01:55
I thought Harold was a great guy well very Charming I thought this is good my sister needs a good man like this
00:02:03
[Music] Lynn and Harold they've been on a drive late at night they had stopped to fix a
00:02:12
soft tire not even a flat tire and what were you told how had your sister died you had she'd been crushed under a car
00:02:20
changing a tire we all were shocked at the bizarreness but the police ruled it an accident
00:02:29
there are so many similarities in these two deaths both occurred in very remote locations
00:02:36
in Colorado in both cases Harold henthorne is the only Witness this is either the unluckiest guy in the
00:02:46
world whose two wives have died under freakish unusual circumstances or it could be murder
00:02:57
[Music] 48 Hours The Accidental husband continues in 90 seconds [Music] Rocky Mountain National Park is a place
00:03:37
known for its soaring Beauty Majestic wildlife inspiring serenity but in September of 2012 it was a site
00:03:54
of heartbreak we've hiked up to the 10 000 foot level in the Rocky Mountain National Park to a
00:04:03
place where either a tragic accident occurred or did Harold henthorne push his wife to her death
00:04:11
[Music] of how love might have gone murderously wrong begins with a joyful time I was extraordinarily happy for my
00:04:27
sister it appeared that she found her true love and if she was happy I was happy Tony a sophisticated southern
00:04:34
belle met Harold in 1999. Tony's brother Barry was pleased his 37 year old sister
00:04:42
had found the kind of man she was looking for she experimented with Christian matchmakers and she met this
00:04:51
guy named Harold hinthorne her comments were that he was very kind he was very romantic he was very smart
00:04:58
both had lost their first spouse under dramatically different circumstances Tony's marriage had ended in divorce
00:05:06
while Harold's first wife died in a tragic incident what did you know about Harold's first wife Lynn when we had
00:05:17
asked Harold about that the only response that we had was that she died in a car accident
00:05:23
Barry's wife Paula not wanting to upset Harold didn't want to pry I thought it was just a bad car wreck when she died
00:05:31
also we you know didn't want to ask him to elaborate we just took it for face value he seemed like a good match for
00:05:38
Tony Tony's parents Bob and Yvonne had a good feeling when they first met Harold
00:05:43
you said I was just smitten by Tony it was easy to be taken with Tony she was attractive and successful a
00:05:54
prominent eye doctor and surgeon in Jackson Mississippi that looks very pretty on you
00:06:00
oh thank you mostly though Tony was known for her caring nature she loved people and if she could make
00:06:09
somebody feel better she would and this started early in her life the middle child with two brothers
00:06:17
Tony was a standout in school did you compete academically oh yeah and she smoked me
00:06:24
she's probably the smartest lady I've ever met no small praise coming from Barry
00:06:30
himself a prominent cardiologist and Harold seemed accomplished as well really nice describing himself as a
00:06:40
fundraising consultant with his own company I work with nonprofits let me churches schools or hospitals I thought
00:06:47
that was a interesting but an odd business at that time too a year after meeting the couple got
00:06:54
married in Mississippi they soon moved to the Denver Colorado area where Harold previously lived and
00:07:04
said he had business contacts Tony joined a local Ophthalmology practice but Tony's strong family ties
00:07:12
there's Tony and Harold would often bring the loving couple back to Mississippi for holidays
00:07:21
[Music] come out visit in Denver one thing was missing from their life a child and in 2005 Tony and Harold
00:07:31
celebrated the birth of their daughter Haley I have Daddy Mommy trainer he had his daughter he had his wife he had his
00:07:41
nice life Daniel Jarvis was a long time family friend of Heralds he seemed like a good
00:07:47
husband it seemed like he provided he's a very good father when Daniel decided to move to Colorado
00:07:54
Harold and Tony let him stay with them for several months and what was it like inside the henthorne household Tony went
00:08:02
to work in the you know most mornings Harold he worked down in his basement he would say that he was meeting with a
00:08:09
client going to lunch or he was traveling Christmas newsletters painted a picture
00:08:14
of a happy family with successful careers for both Tony and Harold but in 2006 their lives took a terrifying turn
00:08:25
while Barry was demonstrating his new cat scan machine he discovered that Harold's arteries were dangerously
00:08:32
clogged Harold is in the throes of the beginnings of a heart attack Harold was rushed into surgery do you believe that
00:08:41
you saved Harold's life I know that I did and Harold would confirm that Tony had her own brush with death in
00:08:48
2011. she was injured in an unusual accident at their mountain cabin when a heavy wooden beam fell on her
00:08:57
she said I saw something on the floor and if I had not picked it up it would have killed me instantly but it hit the
00:09:07
back of my neck and fractured a vertebra and with that she did lose some sensation in her hands when I would call
00:09:14
Harold it was like oh it's no big deal I didn't learn about this until much later
00:09:19
and I said why didn't somebody call me and she said Harold didn't call you and I said No by this time Tony's Family
00:09:28
says Harold had become a demanding and controlling husband even talking with Tony on the phone seemed impossible
00:09:37
Harold would always answer see he had the house phone hooked to his cell phone the only one-on-one
00:09:46
conversation I ever had was with Harold if I tried to talk to Tony or a Haley it
00:09:52
was always on speakerphone why do you think he did this I think that he likes to control everything
00:10:00
that was also the impression of workers in Tony's eye practice Drewes noticed Harold wanted to be
00:10:07
involved in everything when our doctors would have meetings Harold had to be part of it he had to know everything she
00:10:14
was doing while the staff adored Tony office manager Tammy abruscado says their feelings for Harold were quite
00:10:23
different he made us uncomfortable he was kind of um kind of there was something creepy about
00:10:31
him she was not able to schedule anything outside of her normal schedule without
00:10:36
first Consulting with Harold so it was a pleasant surprise when in September of 2012 Harold asked Tammy to
00:10:45
help plan a 12th wedding anniversary surprise trip to Rocky Mountain National Park
00:10:52
she gladly obliged secretly clearing Tony's schedule so she could leave early the
00:11:00
to him and if he was going to it was good it's kind of exciting you know maybe for just a moment I thought
00:11:06
oh it's kind of cool maybe he's not so bad the entire office got involved Christy
00:11:13
took out her cell phone to record the surprise it's the last image it's the last time
00:11:20
anybody who was close to her saw her alive on September 29th 2012 on a beautiful
00:11:42
day like this Harold and Tony set out on this Trail in the Rocky Mountain National Park on their anniversary hike
00:11:50
about two miles up Harold LED them off Trail into rough Terrain she had bad knees so she was not a well
00:12:02
person to go hiking particularly in a rugged terrain these photos were taken on that
00:12:11
anniversary hike a hike that went terribly wrong as Barry learned through those text messages from Harold
00:12:20
this is Barry urgent Tony is injured critical requested flight for life and then he texts me back saying that
00:12:31
she's gone nearly 140 feet toward death Barry had to break the news to his parents that his 50-year-old sister had
00:12:42
died and Barry said she's gone it's the worst two words I've ever heard in my life
00:12:53
it was like no this didn't happen and for Tony's Family what happened here wasn't adding up from Tony with her bad
00:13:05
knees taking a strenuous hike to Harold texting Barry during the accident to the
00:13:11
multiple explanations Harold gave about how Tony died the story is is that he notices that she
00:13:19
was lagging behind and he can't find her so he starts looking over edges and and then he sees
00:13:27
that she's down at the bottom then says Barry that story quickly changed he tells me then that he got a text message
00:13:36
and so he has his head down looking at that phone text and he sees it there's like a little Flash
00:13:44
and then Tony's not there and does that story change that story changes by the next day
00:13:51
Tony now is taking a picture of Harold and Tony has presumably while setting up a shot of him
00:13:58
falling backwards off of a cliff and so here are three stories and basically less than 48 hours and
00:14:09
what are you thinking morning buzzers are gone off what about the notion that maybe he was
00:14:19
suffering post-traumatic stress and those crazy versions of stories was all a result of shock I think that you're
00:14:27
going to take all of that in context if he does have this rational emotional Behavior how does he have it together so
00:14:34
well to plan her funeral not even 48 hours after his wife has died he's got a video made he's got the
00:14:44
songs picked out he's already contacted the people that are going to sing the songs it's too well planned
00:14:52
five days after Tony's death hundreds gathered at a memorial service our purpose today is to honor and to
00:15:00
remember Tony hinthorne by then Harold had already cremated Tony a decision which added to the list of red flags for
00:15:10
the Birdo lays we did not want Tony cremated and Harold insisted we wanted to bring
00:15:19
her home and bury her I think he was trying to hide evidence I think that Harold henthorne pushed my sister off
00:15:27
the mountain here you are grieving her death which you now believed may have been a murder
00:15:39
and if that's the case the murderer is sitting right next to you right that's correct
00:15:44
law enforcement as it does with all deadly Falls was immediately investigating and discovered something
00:15:51
that raised suspicions they found this map inside Harold's Jeep with a hand-drawn X on the spot where Tony fell
00:16:01
after the service he came up to me and his first thing was they found a map they found a map he didn't come up and
00:16:07
give you a hug and say what a tragedy I'm so glad you're here no first words out of his mouth is they found a map
00:16:12
yeah did you have any idea what he was talking about no clue no idea but a few weeks later Harold brought it up again
00:16:21
explaining to Daniel the map was meant for him to highlight a nice Trail Harold also told Daniel he could never hurt
00:16:31
Tony he's saying you lived with us you know that there was nothing wrong in our marriage you know that I could never do
00:16:38
this and what did you say I said yes I agree I don't believe you could ever do this
00:16:44
The Herald that you knew is HE capable of murder not the herald I knew I knew he did it
00:16:52
co-workers and close friends kind of privately were talking and saying you know I really feel bad to say this but I
00:16:59
think that Harold did this in fact many tips were coming into law enforcement 16 calls and
00:17:08
letters all requesting Tony's death be further investigated with fingers pointing at Harold
00:17:16
and then there was a tip received by Brian Moss Denver's cbs4 investigative reporter and 48 Hours consultant
00:17:26
it changed everything and it just said his first wife died in a freak accident as well so it was right up about up here
00:17:35
Brian began investigating both deaths and was shocked by what he found in both cases the accidents are freakish
00:17:43
or bizarre extremely unusual he tells lots of different stories both wives had a lot of insurance money
00:17:54
on them he was the one who was going to benefit from that real Harold henthorne find out now on
00:18:07
Facebook at 48 hours [Music] Tony you say something Tony henthorne had a lot of friends she
00:18:27
had a lot of people who loved her and right from the start wanted to see Justice
00:18:35
they didn't feel good about what happened with questions being raised about how Tony henthorne fell to her death in
00:18:43
Rocky Mountain National Park investigators seen here were retracing her last steps now focusing on the only
00:18:52
witness her husband Harold remember his first wife Lynn had also died in unusual
00:18:59
circumstances in 1995 crushed under their Jeep she was a great woman she was awesome in heart and soul
00:19:14
it's so hard to convey the beauty of anyone's Spirit but Lynn was truly she was the real thing Lynn's siblings Kevin
00:19:24
Lee son and Eric were delighted when their loving sister a social worker found Harold to share her life with he
00:19:33
was Charming he was a a fun guy to be around she adored him Grace Rochelle Lynn's
00:19:41
sister-in-law remembers how happy Lynn seemed during her 12-year marriage to Harold she looked at him with very
00:19:49
loving adoring eyes it was a feeling Grace could understand he began to be like this wonderful big
00:19:59
brother to me would you say a loving personality oh incredibly there are a lot of times
00:20:04
as my family began to grow of watching Harold relate to my girls and how engaging he was with them he and Lynn
00:20:13
never forgot a birthday Christmas it just you couldn't ask for you know more loving family
00:20:21
but on May 6 1995 tragedy struck [Music] we got a call from a paramedic letting us know that there had been an
00:20:32
accident and she was gone and it is horrible pain it was like we all came as quick as we could
00:20:49
to be there and a comfort Harold and what did you know about the circumstances of Lynn's death what were
00:21:00
you told oh it was just a freak accident Harold told law enforcement he and Lynn
00:21:11
had gone out for dinner and a drive in this remote area called Sedalia while driving Harold thought he was
00:21:19
getting a flat tire he pulled off the highway here onto the shoulder you see right behind me in the
00:21:27
dark to change the tire Lenny said was helping out holding the tires lug nuts as he removed them
00:21:35
Harold says she dropped one and it went under the vehicle and at the same time that Lynn went under to retrieve it
00:21:41
Harold says he threw the flat tire in the back knocking the Jeep off of its Jack and onto Lynn
00:21:49
the Lynn that you knew so well was she the kind of woman who would crawl under a car was that her nature no that wasn't
00:21:59
at all that's why it did seem odd Lynn's siblings also thought the accident bizarre but they too couldn't
00:22:08
imagine Harold was involved there's a man that we vacationed with and spent hundreds of hours with and
00:22:17
um we just didn't allow ourselves to go there [Music] the Douglas County Sheriff's Department
00:22:28
responded to the accident and started investigating and just like in Tony henthorne's case
00:22:36
17 years later Harold told a number of conflicting stories Reports say Harold told one Deputy they
00:22:45
were driving back from dinner told another they were going to dinner according to one report Harold said Lynn
00:22:52
called out his name after the Jeep fell on her but he told another investigator that Lynn said I think something's on me
00:23:00
Harold told one Deputy he pulled Lynn out from underneath that jeep he later said that people who stopped to help
00:23:07
pulled her out the Sheriff's Office investigated Lynn's death for six days then closed the case
00:23:17
calling it an accident as did the coroner at the time in the following years investigators say
00:23:25
Harold continued telling various versions of what happened the day Lynn died one bewildering contradiction
00:23:34
after another CPR people or the people the EMTs didn't know what they were doing and they
00:23:40
actually crushed her that she was killed in an automobile accident a head-on automobile accident
00:23:49
not under the car no no there were lots of conflicts Laura Thomas became the Douglas County
00:23:56
coroner in 2011. 16 years after Lynn's death a Colorado State Trooper for decades she
00:24:05
hadn't known about Lynn's accident until she heard about Tony's tragic fall and learned both women had been married to
00:24:14
the same man and you hear this story what are you thinking well I'm thinking that I need to go into
00:24:21
investigator mode there were lots of things in this story that don't make any sense to me at all if Lynn henthorne's
00:24:29
accident had been properly investigated Tony henthorne you alive today you know Peter you
00:24:43
you question that I have asked myself for over two years Can't Get Enough NCIS walk the streets
00:24:57
with real agents it's a Race Against Time and you know you're running out of it missing or murdered in a harsh
00:25:03
expansive desert it's like finding a needle in a thousand Haystacks there was some information about Abandoned mines
00:25:07
being involved in the search she has to be in that Canyon this is not a number this is a human being Tuesday
00:25:21
[Music] so if I let the air out what really happened in 1995 the night Lynn henthorne Herald's first wife was
00:25:36
crushed under their Jeep asked Arnold wheat a nationally recognized accident reconstruction
00:25:44
specialist to review Lynn's case that's right uh 15 to 16 pounds right there [Music]
00:25:52
using a seller make and model as the henththorne's Jeep Cherokee wheat of 48 Hours consultant deflated the tire to
00:26:00
the pressure that Harold claimed forced him to pull over on that remote darkened
00:26:06
Highway this doesn't look flat no is this undrivable in your opinion no in most people's mind a flat tire is flat
00:26:15
with the rim on the ground I've driven on a rim this is anywhere close to being on the rim no it's not
00:26:25
then there's an unusual kind of Jack that wheat thinks was similar to this that Herald in one report told
00:26:33
investigators he used to change the tire is this a bit precarious to be putting up a 4 000 pound Jeep Cherokee
00:26:41
absolutely Harold told investigators he had to use an unconventional Jack because the one that came with the Jeep
00:26:49
didn't work acclaimed wheat finds suspicious how often have you heard a jack like this failing never
00:26:58
never what's worse says coroner Laura Thomas is it seems investigators just took
00:27:08
Harold's word that the Jack was defective there's no indication that the sheriff's department tested that Jack
00:27:15
they never tested it not in the information that I've read another issue one of the tires lug nuts
00:27:25
this is a lug nut it has flat surfaces Harold says Lynn dropped a lug nut that somehow rolled all the way under the
00:27:33
Jeep causing Lynn to go retrieve it they're on a gravel surface lug nuts don't move very far when you drop them
00:27:40
on a gravel surface how that lug nut got underneath there just doesn't make sense
00:27:52
that certainly is suspicious to me do you believe as you sit across from me right now that Harold henthorne
00:28:00
has gotten away with murder in Lynn's case I think there is a very good chance that
00:28:05
he has in December 2014 shortly before her term as coroner ended Laura's suspicions led
00:28:15
her to make a dramatic decision I don't believe that Lynn henthorne got Justice she changed the manner of death in Lynn
00:28:24
henthorne's case from accident to undetermined [Music] the Douglas County Sheriff's Department
00:28:35
also reopened Lynn's case but has not charged Harold henthorne with any crime you say something into the camera
00:28:47
meanwhile Federal investigators looking into the 2012 fatal fall of Harold's second wife Tony we're zeroing in on him
00:28:57
they interviewed Daniel Jarvis the friend who briefly lived in the henthorne house
00:29:04
she asked me what Harold had told me about his job and I gave her the details of he said he was a fundraising
00:29:11
consultant for non-profits the investigator listened to Daniel's story and then presented some jaw-dropping
00:29:18
news she said let me go ahead and tell you something Harold has not worked in 20 years
00:29:25
and it's kind of like a bomb exploded Federal investigators have come out and proven he had no income at all that he
00:29:35
wasn't raising any money but he was telling everybody that he was this incredibly successful entrepreneur and
00:29:41
businessman who is Raising all this money for various organizations Harold reportedly told others that Tony knew he
00:29:48
wasn't working Acclaim Tony's Family says is untrue as Harold controlled the finances
00:29:56
law enforcement also thinks the time when Tony was accidentally struck in the head at the family's cabin may have
00:30:04
actually been the first time Harold tried to kill her everyone wanted answers from Harold
00:30:13
Mr henthorne here is he here and he wasn't talking is there a time when we could get together with you I
00:30:20
want to give you another opportunity to explain what's going on I just want to give you a chance to it's my turning I
00:30:25
really don't appreciate being my property like this Federal authorities do not believe that Harold henthorne is
00:30:30
any kind of a hard luck husband who's just a victim of circumstance they think he is a killer a killer they believe
00:30:38
with a motive and a bizarre business model collecting life insurance proceeds worth millions nearly 645 thousand
00:30:49
dollars on Lynn and potentially Millions on Tony do authorities believe that Harold had
00:30:56
basically started up a cottage industry here marry someone get life insurance and off the wife they've connected the
00:31:04
dots that way [Music] and Grace Rochelle Harold's ex-s sister-in-law thinks she could have been
00:31:17
part of that industry something she learned when the FBI told her about a secret four hundred thousand dollar life
00:31:25
insurance policy Harold had taken out on her Grace says Harold forged her signature
00:31:33
making himself the sole beneficiary that was his doing I did not authorize that policy you die he profits he profits
00:31:44
what do you think he was up to I think it's logical to conclude that he was planning on taking my life at some
00:31:52
point you potentially were going to be victim number three he's a dangerous man he needs to be
00:32:00
behind bars did you kill both of your wives finally in November of 2014 how did Tony die
00:32:09
Harold henthorne was arrested and charged by federal authorities with the first degree murder of Tony
00:32:17
and justice for Tony could bring Justice for Lynn henthorne she didn't deserve to
00:32:23
be crushed under a Jeep out here as a judge ruled the circumstances surrounding Lynn's death can be
00:32:30
presented at his trial for Tony's murder it will strengthen the case enormously for Tony to have Lynn's case added in
00:32:40
and in September 2015 three years after Tony's death Harold hemphorn's trial for
00:32:47
her murder began going into this trial I'm really thinking this is a toss-up you have no
00:32:53
eyewitnesses there's no confession so you're wondering if there's one hold out juror if one person doesn't buy
00:33:01
circumstantial evidence can the government really sell this case I'm going to step off here show you the
00:33:23
scene in front of the federal courthouse right now national and local media Gathering they're waiting for the
00:33:28
families there's a lot of interest in Denver and frankly around the world in this trial
00:33:35
because the circumstances are so unusual a husband whose two wives die in these freak accidents
00:33:43
the federal judge in the case told prospective jurors this trial quote will be a doozy did you kill both of your
00:33:49
wives the murder trial of Harold henthorne where cameras were not allowed begins with the prosecution laying out
00:33:56
its circumstantial case they portray Harold henthorne as an abject liar who's lied about everything in his life
00:34:06
they say that he stood to make about 4.7 million dollars in life insurance if Tony henthorne died so your mom's doing
00:34:15
okay henthorne's defense attorney stands up and says my client's a very unusual quirky guy and he has lied but that
00:34:27
doesn't necessarily make him a killer I just remember the defense attorney Roberts the
00:34:37
proof the prosecution set out to do just that using Drone footage video and photographs documenting the
00:34:48
couple's Ascent along the mountain trail they believe became a murder scene they
00:34:54
were able to establish a pattern of him visiting that same area because his phone when he would text or call was
00:34:59
hitting the same exact Tower juror Mark CC Miller Zahn says the FBI presented evidence using henthorne's cell phone
00:35:07
records to show he made repeated scouting trips and how many times did he visit that area nine times what does
00:35:15
that tell you it tells me he's planning also compelling to jurors was that 9-1-1
00:35:24
call [Music] evidence didn't seem to support the efforts Harold claims he made after
00:35:39
climbing down the mountain to revive Tony including mouth-to-mouth resuscitation and her lipstick was still
00:35:47
on so you'd know that would be impossible and there was the testimony of Barry bertile Tony's brother who is a doctor
00:35:56
about the text he received from Harold at one point she's slow heart rate at another point she's fast heart rate well
00:36:05
which is it there was also this powerful piece of evidence that map taken from Harold's
00:36:12
Jeep where he had drawn an X at the very spot where Tony had fallen to her death
00:36:21
long time friend Daniel Jarvis testified how Harold told him at Tony's funeral that the map had been made for him
00:36:32
it wasn't made for me I believe it was made for that time and he put an x on there so
00:36:39
so what do you think this all adds up to I think he planned to go out there and have nobody around
00:36:50
and do what and push Tony off a cliff it was like okay he's trying to hide something juror
00:36:58
Jerry tabota and trying to get Mr Jarvis to be on his side of the story another point of drama came when the
00:37:07
prosecution presented evidence that Harold may have stolen a precious item from his dead wife's body
00:37:18
after Tony henthorne's fall they find her wedding ring on her finger her hand not severely damaged but the
00:37:28
diamond is missing from the wedding ring and it's worth about thirty thousand dollars according to Harold and that
00:37:35
area was scoured scoured investigators combed through that area and so it was a real mystery where did
00:37:43
the diamond go but eight months later an investigator returning to the scene suddenly found
00:37:50
the diamond suspiciously sitting on the ground in plain sight during the investigation Harold
00:37:58
henthorne got a lot of pressure from the FBI about that diamond and it got to him
00:38:03
the prosecution believes Harold henthorne put the diamond back and there was that information allowed about the
00:38:11
unusual way Harold's first wife Lynn died crushed under that jeep once we learn more about Lynn's death and the
00:38:20
circumstances of her death then it started coming together for me that there were very many similarities in the
00:38:27
two cases pattern of behavior pattern of behavior there was only one person these jurors
00:38:33
now wanted to hear from someone they felt had some explaining to do I wanted to hear from Harold I would have loved
00:38:40
to see him get on the stand and give another account to the jury of what happened that night
00:38:47
and it didn't happen in fact Harold's defense attorney rested his case without calling a single
00:38:55
witness confident jurors would see Tony's death as an accident Tony's brother Barry looked over at Harold
00:39:04
what did you see on his face it was a defiant look it is like it was one of these come and
00:39:10
get me and I hope we did the jury began its deliberation we're all somewhat anxious and waiting
00:39:20
the decision if there's a hung jury gather together for the weight is not just Tony's family but Lynn's as well we
00:39:29
hope to be able to have a celebratory dinner tonight together so we're just praying that the jury will
00:39:35
come back and get a quick verdict after 10 hours of deliberation the jury took a vote our four-person said who's
00:39:46
for guilty and every hand in the room went up every half every hand quickly Harold henthorne was convicted
00:39:57
of first-degree murder after the trial officially ended in all the years I've been doing this
00:40:04
I've never seen that before what happens I went and hugged Yvonne the mother of Tony and just whispered
00:40:13
into ear and no Mom should ever go through what you've gone through she just said as one mom to another
00:40:20
feel your pain while the verdict means Justice for the fertilized Barry's mind still wanders
00:40:30
back to that time he saved Harold from a certain heart attack the man he now knows went on to kill his sister
00:40:40
you know I think as a physician you know you have this oath and this obligation to do that
00:40:55
but I'd like to add my sister back Barry is not alone in regrets Lin's family has its own we grieve for the
00:41:06
bird lays because had we come forward at that time with uh with more suspicions then maybe Tony
00:41:16
would be alive today one tragic connection they share is the fact that Harold spread Tony and Lynn's
00:41:25
ashes 17 years apart at this same spot yeah I'm glad that we're here with you little girl no
00:41:34
now young Haley henthorne is the focus of attention she is slowly learning details about her mother's death
00:41:43
your mama was about my height what she yeah she was about 5'4 people in Mississippi don't get to see mountains
00:41:49
that much Barry and Paulo worked through the courts to bring Haley as their award to
00:41:55
Mississippi the place her mother considered home where might she end up hopefully right there
00:42:10
I'll say right there you'd like to adopt her absolutely we're excited about you coming in that
00:42:18
she can be in a place where she's loved by family and grow up in an environment where everybody knew her mom as
00:42:28
intelligent smart is a hero I want her to know who her mom really was [Music] wow that's awesome
00:42:40
[Music] stole my heart the minute I saw her 1978 Barbara nante and Jamal decided to
00:43:17
go on a camping trip to the beach and it was some time after they had fallen asleep that they were attacked
00:43:26
I was knocked unconscious I couldn't protect her dad looked at me and said your sister
00:43:31
has been murdered who would want to kill her and why six years later another young woman was
00:43:39
found murdered nearly The Identical location there really was no big break until 2012
00:43:46
there are multiple suspects a variety of motives yeah my husband didn't do it I knew they were wrong as a murder
00:43:57
mystery this has everything you would want CBS News originally [Music]