
This episode discusses the disappearance of Don Lewis, former husband of Carole Baskin, and theories surrounding his case. Former New York City prosecutor Alex Spiro suggests focusing on the hours before Lewis vanished. Carole Baskin shares her account of the events leading up to his disappearance, including her late-night errand on August 18, 1997.
Baskin details her last moments with Lewis, stating she left him at home to run to a supermarket, which was closed. After her car broke down, she walked home and returned at 4 AM. Shortly after, Lewis left the house, marking the last time she saw him.
The episode also touches on various theories about Lewis's fate, including the more fantastical ideas involving animals and airplanes. Spiro emphasizes that simpler explanations are often overlooked in high-profile cases.
Baskin maintains her innocence regarding Lewis's disappearance, asserting she did not kill him. The conversation raises questions about the investigation and the challenges of going missing in modern times.
Carole Baskin recounts the night Don Lewis disappeared, while Alex Spiro suggests focusing on the hours before his vanishing.

I didn't kill Don.What happened the night Don Lewis went missing?