Search Captions & Ask AI

Does a Massachusetts wife's hair holds clues in ex-detective's murder trial?

May 03, 2024 / 03:42

This episode of 48 Hours covers the suspicious death of Amy Fion, the investigation into her husband Detective Brian Fion, and the implications of gunshot residue evidence. Key discussions include the timeline of events on May 8, 2018, the argument between the couple, and the analysis of gunshot residue.

Detective Brian Fion reported his wife's death as a self-inflicted gunshot wound, but investigators questioned his account. Nikki Battiste reports on the arrival of Massachusetts state police detectives Brendan O'Tou and Mike Blanchet, who found Amy dead on the dining room floor.

The episode highlights the significance of gunshot residue patterns and the defense's argument regarding Amy's hair potentially blocking residue. Crime scene analyst Alexander Jason demonstrates this theory at a gun range.

Investigators found partial fingerprints on Brian's gun, but they could not identify them. Both Brian and Amy had gunshot residue on their hands, raising questions about the circumstances surrounding her death.

The prosecution suggested that Brian's motive was tied to a relationship with another woman, fearing a divorce would damage his reputation in their community.

TLDR

Detective Brian Fion becomes a suspect in his wife's suspicious death, raising questions about gunshot residue and potential motives.

Episode

3:42
00:00:00
this week's 48 Hours involves a highly respected police detective who became a prime suspect in his wife's death Amy
00:00:06
fan was found dead in her massachusett home in May 2018 her husband detective Brian fion told police it was a
00:00:12
self-inflicted gunshot wound but investigators did not believe his story as Nikki batist reports for 48 hours
00:00:19
gunshot residue May hold the answers it was 12:06 p.m. on May 8th 2018 when detective Brian fan dialed 911
00:00:29
my wife just shot herself can you send me some help when Massachusetts state police detectives Brendan otou and Mike
00:00:36
Blanchet arrived they found 51-year-old Amy fion lying dead on the dining room floor according to Brian the couple had
00:00:43
been arguing about his retirement plans and at some point Amy picked up his service weapon I just saw the gun in her
00:00:50
hand and her hand going up and towards her head yeah but investigators did not believe Brian's story I mean there's no
00:00:57
doubt she get was shot but the question is from what distance it was right freaking there I'm
00:01:06
telling you distance mattered because in self-inflicted gunshot wounds gunshot residue is expelled from the firearm
00:01:14
leaving a distinct pattern called stippling on the wound there's none honor Brian there's none honor there has
00:01:21
to be cuz the gun was there right freaking there fion was later arrested and charged with murder but at trial
00:01:28
Alexander Jason AC crime scene analysts called by the defense testify that the lack of gunshot residue was not due to
00:01:35
distance but rather Amy's Hair Amy fion had very dense thick hair that will block The Gunshot residue Amy's Hair was
00:01:45
not tested by crime scene analysts to support his theory he met us at a gun range using a 45 caliber gun and
00:01:53
ammunition identical to what was found at the scene Jason fired a single round into a mound of hair by a ballistic skin
00:02:01
simulant so you just shot a 45 caliber gun 3 in away through hair yes for comparison Jason positioned the gun at
00:02:09
the same distance using identical ammunition and fired into the skin simulant without
00:02:16
hair and I pull this away wow you can see there's a big difference that's incredible all from the hair all from
00:02:24
the hair the hair acted as a filter pretty fascinating and Nikki joins us now Nikki
00:02:31
that is incredibly fascinating uh so were there any fingerprints found on Brian's gun and what about that gunshot
00:02:37
residue so there were partial prints found on the gun but detectives weren't able to identify them however both Brian
00:02:45
and Amy had gunshot residue on their hands but at the crime scene Brian was found holding his wife's hand so it's
00:02:52
you know it could be transferred what do prosecutor say the motive was it's a big
00:02:56
question jica so Brian had a relationship ship with a woman he met on a church mission trip he was very
00:03:02
involved in the church as was she the prosecution says he didn't want to get a divorce because it would have reflected
00:03:08
poorly they were big in the community they've been referred to as the kennedies of this area and she said it
00:03:13
just would have looked too bad but this is a real I don't know I've never seen anything like that so I'm really looking
00:03:20
forward to it's incredible the ballistics in the story is fascinating yeah just in those last 30 seconds my
00:03:24
mind went back and forth he literally said wait I'm confused I thought I had to figure it out tune in Saturday
00:03:30
Saturday night great tease Nikki thank you very much as always you can watch Nikki's full report the detective's wife
00:03:35
on 48 hours tomorrow night at 109 Central right here on CBS and streaming on Paramount Plus

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Most intense
  • 75
    Biggest twist
  • 70
    Most dramatic

Episode Highlights

  • The Detective's Wife
    A respected police detective becomes a prime suspect in his wife's death. What really happened?
    “My wife just shot herself, can you send some help?”
    @ 00m 29s
    May 03, 2024
  • Ballistics and Hair Evidence
    A crime scene analyst demonstrates how hair can block gunshot residue, complicating the case.
    “You can see there's a big difference, that's incredible!”
    @ 02m 19s
    May 03, 2024

Episode Quotes

  • I just saw the gun in her hand.
    Does a Massachusetts wife's hair holds clues in ex-detective's murder trial?
  • The hair acted as a filter, pretty fascinating.
    Does a Massachusetts wife's hair holds clues in ex-detective's murder trial?

Key Moments

  • Mysterious Death00:03
  • 911 Call00:29
  • Ballistics Test01:50
  • Community Pressure03:10
  • Tease for More03:30

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown