Search Captions & Ask AI

Sneak peek: Murder at the Mall: The Michelle Martinko Case

November 05, 2020 / 03:08

This episode covers the 1979 murder of Michelle Martinko, the investigation, and the eventual breakthrough in 2005. Key discussions include the details of the crime, the suspects involved, and the role of DNA evidence in solving the case.

Michelle Martinko, an 18-year-old high school senior, was murdered in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, after attending a choir banquet and visiting a mall. She was attacked in her car, suffering 29 stab wounds, suggesting a personal motive.

The investigation initially focused on her boyfriend, Andy Seidel, who was described as possessive. However, doubts about his involvement arose as the police explored other leads.

After years of stalled progress, the case went cold until a significant DNA breakthrough occurred in 2005. Investigators collected DNA from 161 individuals, leading to the identification of a suspect after 13 years.

The episode highlights the persistence of law enforcement and the impact of modern forensic science in solving cold cases.

TLDR

The episode details Michelle Martinko's 1979 murder and the DNA breakthrough that solved the case in 2005.

Episode

3:08
00:00:03
on december 19th 1979 michelle martinko was a 18 year old high school senior she was impossible to miss she had the
00:00:13
big blonde hair [Music] she was that striking she was striking just a smart kind nice person
00:00:25
she was a member of the concert choir they had a banquet which she attended afterwards michelle ended up going to
00:00:33
the mall so did a bunch of her friends from the choir the mall had just opened it was two
00:00:39
months old it was the place to be in cedar rapids at the time so she would have been parked right in
00:00:46
this area yeah she would have been parked facing this direction she left the mall
00:00:52
shortly before it closed to close to 10 pm that night you're talking december in iowa it's
00:00:57
very dark it's very dark michelle walks out and gets in her car this person snuck up on michelle opened
00:01:07
the door and climbed in she was stabbed and cut a total of 29 times this was a real fight it
00:01:19
looks personal it's a lot of stab wounds it's overkill it's always the boyfriend
00:01:25
the girlfriend the husband someone really really close to the person did either of you know
00:01:32
andy seidel i knew andy through michelle that was her boyfriend i took an instant dislike to andy he was
00:01:41
very possessive of michelle i believed andy did it i did not see anything from the men in her life that would give
00:01:49
any of them motive to do something like this i definitely didn't see that from andy
00:01:54
seidel the entire police force dedicated time and energy to try to find answers to
00:02:00
what happened to michelle after a couple of years the leads were starting to dry up
00:02:07
the case then goes cold yeah we really had given up hope we truly had these guys never gave up
00:02:14
the investigation never really stopped i've been through every piece of paper in here
00:02:21
probably close to 8 000 pages of reports here the biggest break came in 2005. the dna was the key we collected dna
00:02:33
from 161 people we were looking for a needle in a haystack we just need to get lucky it took us 13
00:02:42
years until we had a suspect we immediately call up the lab is this our guy what was the answer
00:02:48
yes what are you doing in that moment i don't know what i was doing i was speechless
00:02:56
so do you think he just all these years thought he got away with it well yeah cause he did
00:03:07
you

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 85
    Most intense
  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 80
    Most surprising
  • 75
    Most heartbreaking

Episode Highlights

  • The Tragic Night
    On December 19, 1979, Michelle Martinko was brutally attacked in her car after a choir banquet.
    “She was stabbed and cut a total of 29 times.”
    @ 01m 10s
    November 05, 2020
  • A Cold Case
    After years of investigation, the case went cold, leaving many without answers.
    “We truly had given up hope.”
    @ 02m 09s
    November 05, 2020
  • DNA Breakthrough
    In 2005, DNA evidence provided a significant breakthrough in the long-unsolved case.
    “It took us 13 years until we had a suspect.”
    @ 02m 42s
    November 05, 2020

Episode Quotes

  • She was impossible to miss.
    Sneak peek: Murder at the Mall: The Michelle Martinko Case
  • This was a real fight; it looks personal.
    Sneak peek: Murder at the Mall: The Michelle Martinko Case
  • We truly had given up hope.
    Sneak peek: Murder at the Mall: The Michelle Martinko Case
  • I was speechless.
    Sneak peek: Murder at the Mall: The Michelle Martinko Case

Key Moments

  • Michelle's Life00:06
  • The Attack01:07
  • Cold Case02:07
  • DNA Evidence02:25
  • The Breakthrough02:42

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown