00:00:00
[Music] [Applause] it's August 1st 2018 I get a call from one of my investigators said we had a
00:00:13
shooting victim on Sunny book drive and it didn't look good SP County 911 where's your
00:00:20
emergency um yes ma'am I AC my gun was chambered and I'm so sorry I like to St my boyfriend in the neck I'm so sorry
00:00:30
[Music] we actually had uh the perpetrator admitting to shooting the victim on the
00:00:39
911 call before we even arrived at the scene and told us she did [Music] it the way look at me Zep look at me look at me
00:00:57
Zep I'm Lieutenant Chris Wilson I was the first investigator to R seene what kind of gun was it it was a GL 43 I
00:01:06
was just grabing it I did not know there was one gra to bring it to oured basically
00:01:13
we had a a a young man down uh not responsive and also a young woman who was Fran frantic very emotional she was
00:01:23
just pleading for help I cannot lose him I cannot lose him I cannot lose him come
00:01:28
on look calm down for me calm down calm back I want to know how this happened I don't even understand enough the gun
00:01:40
going off I don't even see how like it even got him because I wasn't even like really pointing it directly at him in
00:01:45
the first place I was able to look over any type of evidence any type of forensics that that could have been
00:01:52
involved trying to make sense of what might have happened in that living room that night like been fighting here
00:02:01
want I knew then that we we could be possibly looking at a homicide you had the right
00:02:14
from the confessions on this video and we can't hear it there's no sound there there's sound but it's just a a noise
00:02:23
constant noise all way through it ladies and Gentlemen please rise this is malice murder this is felony
00:02:33
murder this gun did not discharge on its own Mary Katherine Higden was angry she lost
00:02:42
control and she pulled the trigger I didn't even know it was chambered I never wanted to hurt him I
00:02:53
never wanted anything like that there may be people watching this who find it hard to believe what what
00:02:59
you're saying right now mhm what would you say to them all I know is what's in my heart
00:03:07
and I know what happened that night I loved Steven and I would never ever do anything to hurt
00:03:22
him 56 at this time [Music] Henry [Music] we about [Music] two police body cameras captured the chaotic
00:04:08
scene the night Steven Freeman was shot and killed by his girlfriend of seven years Mary Katherine hickon inside the
00:04:16
home they shared now he still got a post okay let work on him okay Mary Katherine
00:04:23
Higden is in the living room and so is Steven Freeman he's laying right here on a mattress Mary Cath is hovering over
00:04:30
him and he's literally dying in front of her I'm sorry calm down okay calm Down's
00:04:41
alive Mary Katherine told the police that her gun went off accident that she was handing it to
00:04:48
Steven who like to keep it on the side of the bed at night for protection none of our guns that we've had around our
00:04:54
house were ever you know chambered there was never a bullet in the chamber was never my intention to
00:05:01
ever injure him or kill him those words ring Hollow to Steven's grieving mother Jennifer Freeman have you spoken to Mary
00:05:11
Katherine Higden since this all happened I have not she will never give me an answer that's going to be good enough
00:05:16
for me because this should never have happened Steven was 23 years old everybody just loved Steven because he
00:05:25
was just sweet you know just a good kid Steven's heart was huge he was a devoted
00:05:34
son to the most wonderful woman in the world Jennifer Treasures the note he wrote her after she had gone back to
00:05:42
school and completed her college degree and know that if you put your mind to it
00:05:47
you could accomplish all of your hopes and dreams and more I'll love you to the moon and back
00:05:53
Steven and that was our thing it was either I love you more or I love you to moon in back that was our little thing
00:06:03
what's up Stephen Steven had a happy childhood growing up in the town of Griffin Georgia always had a smile on
00:06:10
his face always and that was from the time that he was a little bitty baby through
00:06:16
adulthood he loved the outdoors loved it that was probably his passion above all
00:06:21
else was to be outside duck hunting deer hunting fishing camping that was where he found his peace and his comforts
00:06:30
Mary Katherine's Father Tom hickton and older sister Sarah say she too was a happy child then here's your host Mary
00:06:39
Catherine who like to put on a show bye she always was the entertainment in the room no matter what age she's just
00:06:49
funloving remember one time she had a pet frog that she used to walk around the neighborhood with a Sho string so um
00:06:57
we would say our life would be boring without her Steven and Mary Katherine began dating in high school the romance
00:07:05
quickly became pretty serious and they moved in together after graduating Steven worked at repairing roofs Mary
00:07:12
Katherine was a preschool teacher Aid did you like Mary Catherine I did I did I loved her she would eat at our house
00:07:20
on Sunday night with my parents and our extended family and we certainly considered Mary Katherine like a
00:07:28
daughter he was just you know he's just like my best friend that loved me and that was
00:07:37
there for me and just listen to me and we just really hit it off great we were just I guess You' say like two peas in a
00:07:45
Pie Mary Katherine shared Steven's passion for the outdoors before long she won over his
00:07:51
closest friends Thomas Skinner Andrew McCree and Chase puit what did you like about her that she made my friend Happy
00:07:59
happy I mean most girls won't even get in the woods for 30 minutes if she'll go fish with you for 4 hours or go deer
00:08:04
hunt with you then that's awesome man I'm glad you found somebody that makes you happy the couple also shared a
00:08:10
passion for guns how many guns did Steven own um he had I say couple shotguns uh somewhere around 10 maybe no
00:08:22
I probably had yeah probably around that yeah she would brag about how she would
00:08:26
she knew more about guns than that is because Mary Catherine landed a job selling guns at a local sporting
00:08:34
goods store where Thomas Skinner also worked before you're able to sell a gun you're trained and taught how to handle
00:08:43
it you know like how to hand somebody a gun do you believe her when she says I just held it up and it went off no no
00:08:50
not for a second yet that was the first story Mary Katherine told police when they arrived
00:08:56
at the house that night this is a Glock model 380 to detective Adam traml it also seemed like
00:09:04
an unlikely story is it possible for this gun to just go off accidentally not from my experience the
00:09:11
trigger would have to be pulled this is this is not the weapon that was used that's correct it's just the type of gun
00:09:18
the type of gun can you show us the process of loading the weapon and firing it yes I
00:09:23
can first you would load your ammunition you would insert the magazine wreck the
00:09:34
slide and fire the weapon police were also suspicious for another reason she claiming it was
00:09:46
accidental discharge uh but based on some of the evidence we've seen in the house while we were in there attending
00:09:52
to him uh it looked like they've been fighting Lieutenant Chris Wilson saw the evidence
00:10:00
firsthand now of course there are new homeowners here and everything here is it looks very nice and well kept that
00:10:07
wasn't the case that night there was food slung everywhere on the camps and the on the floor uh food thrown there I
00:10:16
guess it looked like they had been throwing it at each other it looked like there had been some some food tossed
00:10:21
around here as Mary Katherine Higden was taken in for questioning police knew there had to be much more to this story
00:10:33
[Music] Steven was the calm in the [Music] storm we used to laugh and say he would
00:10:52
outlive everybody because he didn't stress out about anything Jennifer Freeman struggles to understand how her
00:10:59
son's life could have ended so violently at the hands of a woman he loved Mary Katherine Higden listen to me we're
00:11:07
going to work through this okay we're going to work through it we're going to work through it all right okay just's
00:11:12
come with us come on get they took you to the police station they didn't take you in handcuffs they
00:11:20
just wanted to ask you some questions you agreed to cooperate oh yeah most definitely first one says you had the
00:11:27
right for Sal but did detectives Adam traml and Chris Wilson found the story that Mary Katherine told them in the
00:11:34
interrogation room hard to believe Mary Katherine told the police that Steven asked for the gun so she claims she
00:11:42
tossed it to him now he's in the living room on a mattress right there and she says when she tossed it the gun went
00:11:48
off when she said she tossed the gun that didn't match what I would think a normal person would do it also didn't
00:11:59
match what she told the investigators at the scene she told them she was simply handing the gun to Steven not tossing it
00:12:07
and that's when she accidentally shot him below the neck Lieutenant Wilson decided to
00:12:14
confront her do not over me it's my to talk I I you CH you kind of lost your cool on her not
00:12:28
really that's the tactic at that point we weren't buying the story so we SLA my hands I tell say
00:12:38
stop lying to me tell me the truth right now last time what did she do she said I
00:12:45
did it out of anger yeah just like that believing that they had an ironclad confession on tape
00:12:54
they arrested Mary Katherine Higden for murder but there was a big problem I the
00:13:02
only thing it [Applause] was there was nothing but feedback on most of the recording and it couldn't be fixed oh no
00:13:15
what can we do so at this point all you've got to say what she said was what you two remember that's
00:13:25
correct but they still had the forensic evidence that convince them Steven shooting was no accident so her story
00:13:32
was I don't keep around in the chamber correct okay what did you find on the weapon that said to you I don't know if
00:13:39
I believe that looks like she loaded it that night there was cooking grease on the magazine there was also grease on
00:13:44
the slide of the gun which tells me that the magazine had to be out at one point Browns loaded slid back into the
00:13:54
gun and wacked Mary Catherine had told told police she was cooking dinner for Steven
00:14:01
that night the same dinner they found thrown on the kitchen floor she's just very loud very very
00:14:08
dramatic very always over the top looking to go start an issue as investigators began to question the
00:14:14
couple's friends they discovered this Teenage Love Affair had turned toxic and most of the blame was being
00:14:22
placed on Mary Catherine eight seven times out of 10 Che yell she was bitching at Steven for
00:14:30
something Steven would often walk out during an argument and block Mary Katherine's number from his phone that's
00:14:36
because she would call him obsessively according to his coworker Elijah verella some mornings several different
00:14:43
occasions he would get to work and before we even got to the first job he'd have 30 Miss calls from her like she was
00:14:50
just blowing him off the line like his friends also told detectives Steven feared she was unstable and dangerous I
00:15:01
I know that she's pulled a g on him before Oh has she oh I know that I know that he's told me I mean I know I mean I
00:15:07
know she's done it three or four times like at least each one of you was told by Steven mhm that Mary Katherine
00:15:15
pointed a gun at him is that correct yes yes as soon as they said he was shot I knew what happened I knew Mary Katherine
00:15:22
did it on April 21st 2018 3 months before he was killed Steven texted his friend
00:15:31
Andrew MK is running around screaming at the top of her lungs outside and now she's trying to shoot me and
00:15:39
herself as alarming as that sounds it was another alleged incident the following month that left Steven badly
00:15:48
shaken he said you know she's pointed a guns at me multiple times he goes but uh
00:15:53
this time was the only time I saw a look in her eyes and I was actually scared that she might shoot me so she came up
00:15:58
my house that night did Steven ever report that to the police to my knowledge no I think he thought he could
00:16:04
handle it or I don't know he said he cares for her he doesn't want her to go to jail the relationship was on again
00:16:10
off again and it was a roller coaster ride right up to the end on July 30th 2018 2 days before Steven's death he
00:16:21
texted good morning beautiful Mary Katherine have a great day Steven you too love
00:16:30
you but by the next day I said are you Mary Catherine arguing and he said yes ma'am I'm not going back there tonight
00:16:37
and he said I'm running from Satan Steven slept at a friend's house ignoring Mary Katherine's calls and text
00:16:46
messages the next evening she had prepared dinner and stevenh was again Mia you called him a lot on that date 910 912
00:16:56
9117 923 929 9 9:38 mhm why why so many times I guess cuz it is like irritating I need to know if I
00:17:05
need to just you know make me a dinner I'm trying to wait to eat with you it's just one answer are you coming home yes
00:17:12
or no she found out through Steven's mother that he was still at his friend's house so once you told her where he was
00:17:20
she went after him yes of course I didn't realize that it was going to escalate and I was going to escalate as
00:17:26
it did and I have guilt to this day because I I responded cuz I didn't want to lie to her Steven was already driving
00:17:34
home with Thomas Skinner she comes out of nowhere riding our tail like right on our bumper and she pulled up beside my
00:17:44
truck like right beside Sten rolled her window down and she started yelling at him she said are you coming home now and
00:17:50
he said yes calm down I'm coming home but she was like screaming at the top of at the top of her
00:17:56
lungs less than two 2 hours later Steven Freeman was dead while police believe it is an open
00:18:05
and shut case of murder fueled by Mary Katherine's anger her defense attorneys say not so fast they claimed there was a
00:18:14
side to Steven Freeman that no one knew if Steven Freeman truly feared that Mary
00:18:34
Katherine might shoot him why didn't he leave the relationship for [Music] good I played that over my head a
00:18:44
million times why I couldn't finally walk away hindsight's 2020 maybe we should have done more maybe we could
00:18:49
have done more but Mary Katherine denies she ever pointed a gun at Steven that is until the night she
00:18:58
killed him well let me let me just read a text and and I want to be specific here uh Stephen text you this I know you
00:19:06
pointed a gun at me a bunch of times but the last time you did it scared the bleep out of me
00:19:12
mhm did you point a gun at him no no like I didn't because when he was saying that I had pulled a gun to kill myself I
00:19:20
was thinking about hurting myself if true it wasn't the first time Mary Katherine's father told
00:19:28
detectives both he and Steven were concerned about her suicide threats and I didn't realize until after he died
00:19:37
that she would tell him that if he didn't come home that she was going to kill herself um I think that's why he
00:19:45
stayed but by July of 2018 Steven had had enough he made plans to move to another
00:19:52
town with his friend Thomas and not tell Mary Katherine according to prosecutor Kate Leonard all of the signs were that
00:20:00
she was unraveling he was planning on moving while she was at work he never got the
00:20:08
chance Mary Katherine shot him 2 days before he was supposed to leave did it seem like a pretty straightforward case
00:20:16
yes yes there was never really any question that that she shot him she was the only one in the house besides him
00:20:22
she confessed to doing it what we're looking at is uh what we call the murder board the prosecution claims it
00:20:32
discovered Mary Katherine had revised or added details to her story 10 different
00:20:38
times the 911 dispatcher asks her um what happened and she says that she was just grabbing the gun to bring it to bed
00:20:47
remember Mary Katherine said she didn't know the gun was loaded then once officers arrive on scene then um she
00:20:56
starts telling the officers that that uh that she was handing Steven the gun and
00:21:01
then it accidentally went off according to detectives she told them in the interrogation room the gun went off when
00:21:08
she tossed it to Steven the story you first told them was not true yes I knew that obviously it was a Al but I
00:21:20
just I guess I was just scared then police say she admitted shooting him in anger
00:21:28
but she told her father and her sister that she and Steven had been arguing and that she shot him in self-defense he
00:21:35
just threw every everything that I made in my face and I just picked up the gun just to to scare him just to get him out
00:21:43
of the house cuz I was scared when you raised the gun at him did you say anything to him I just said get that
00:21:50
blank out of my house and what did he do I I remember I remember him leaning down and then he just it
00:22:07
just happened all so fast and then he laned down and then he lunched at me and I got scared and I kind of reared back
00:22:13
and then just the next thing I know he was just sorry um and then he was just bleeding she never tells the police that
00:22:22
he launched at her she has every opportunity to tell the police that he launched at her but she doesn't do that
00:22:28
Mary Katherine says she was embarrassed to tell police that Steven had a history
00:22:34
of violence towards her did Steph ever hit you yes not so much like where it was
00:22:42
like physical like punches or anything just like grabs there there was one time where you know he smacked me across the
00:22:49
face a lot of times um he just kind of you know like like pop me on the back of my head but Steven's friends insist
00:22:58
she was the violent one in the relationship you saw Mary Katherine hit Steven yes I multiple times chest
00:23:06
shoulders everything one time um she slapped him and he kind of grabbed her like she slapped him hard and he kind of
00:23:13
like grabbed her was like don't hit me but Sarah hiden believes her sister she says she saw bruising on Mary
00:23:19
Katherine's arm two weeks before the shooting and I wish that I would have taken a picture of it and she wouldn't
00:23:26
tell me at first but eventually I pulled her off to the side and I was like what is that and she
00:23:34
was like well Steven just grabbed me a little bit too hard I was like what are you talking about but investigators
00:23:41
believe the forensic evidence shows that far from defending herself Mary Katherine shot Steven In Cold Blood
00:23:50
while he was simply sitting on their bed there's very little blood anywhere except for right here on this corner
00:23:58
it's all in one area cuz Steven didn't move it tells me that this story of him lunging at her doesn't really add up the
00:24:08
thought being if he had gotten up and started to make his way toward her there would have been some blood that moved
00:24:14
beyond the bed correct everyone made a rush to judgment Mary Katherine's attorneys public defenders George
00:24:21
carbajal and Michael Grams insist Steven could have started to get up and go after her and they say she had good
00:24:29
reason to be afraid because of his alleged history of abuse what kind of abuse was Mary
00:24:36
Katherine subjected to um pretty much every kind telling her that um she needed to be a certain way
00:24:46
was showing where all the money's going uh every moment of the day um making her
00:24:52
let him know where she's going to be every moment of the day and what physical assaulting I think that he hit
00:24:57
her on the back of the head and he literally kicked her out of the bed with such force that she flew and hit her
00:25:03
head on the on the door frame did Mary Katherine ever called 911 to report any of this
00:25:09
abuse no she always thought that it was her and that she needed to do something better and it was her fault that she was
00:25:16
making Steven angry you know some of Steven's friends say that she was the abusive one mm verbally pointed a gun at
00:25:23
him more than once nobody ever saw that all of that came from Steven [Music] the defense team claims it uncovered
00:25:31
evidence of Steven's Jackel and Hyde personality and an angry tiate of text messages that Steven sent to Mary
00:25:38
Katherine a year prior the 63 Pages or whatever of hateful horrible threatening text
00:25:47
messages that was what really really corroborated it these texts are from an old phone of Mary Catherine's the
00:25:55
prosecutors didn't even know existed Steve had discovered that Mary Katherine slept with a friend of his while they
00:26:01
were broken up the language is so ugly we can't repeat most of it but there was also a photo of him holding up a dead
00:26:08
fish with the caption this is you [ __ ] as well as a threat I'm going to effing
00:26:15
wreck you for Wrecking me did you know he was talking to her like that I didn't but I do know that he was a human being
00:26:25
and he was hurt he was angry and I don't condone the language I don't condone what he
00:26:31
did the defense claims this is just the tip of the iceberg as Mary Katherine takes the
00:26:37
stand at her trial her testimony takes the courtroom by surprise what is the Red
00:26:45
Room um it's like one of those I guess sex rooms off of 50 Shades of Gray [Music]
00:27:02
Balon County Superior Court is now in session The Honorable Scott Hill balard is Judge presiding thank you y'all be
00:27:08
seated please on June 17th 2019 almost a year after Steven Freeman's death 24-year-old Mary Katherine Higden goes
00:27:16
on trial for murder what do you think is your strongest evidence it's a physical
00:27:21
evidence the grease on the gun that there was no other person present that all of the blood is in one area there's
00:27:30
nothing that shows that he was moving or coming at her at the time that he was shot the text messages of her trying to
00:27:39
get him to come home calling over and over and over prosecutor Kate Leonard says the
00:27:45
physical evidence supports her theory that Mary Katherine shot Steven in Anger after he hadn't come home for dinner and
00:27:53
ignored her calls and text messages but there were still some hurdles to overcome kind if you want to tell me
00:28:00
what what went on tonight you know in the very beginning I the think it was that is your confession sure and
00:28:10
it's pretty much inaudible yes how do you mess up the confession um especially when it's such
00:28:18
a powerful confession was this gun is in an Evidence bag cuz we secured it when we
00:28:26
made entry first responders moov the gun found next to Steven Freeman claiming they feared that Mary Catherine was
00:28:33
reaching for it we didn't take pictures of it before we removed it before we mov
00:28:38
it all right as a prosecutor when you heard the cops say we move the gun we moved it for safety reasons why did that
00:28:46
bother you because you could just as easily have moved her for safety reasons leave the gun where it is that's rule
00:28:53
number one you don't mess with the murder weapon you're under the defense called Mary Catherine hion now facing
00:29:00
the possibility of life in prison Mary Katherine Higden made the risky [Music] decision to take the stand the whole
00:29:10
truth so God yes when it was good it was good but when it was bad it was bad Mary
00:29:17
Katherine tearfully paints a portrait of Steven as an abusive and controlling boyfriend I he'd expect you know his
00:29:25
clothes all ready and fold it in his shoes where it needed to be he'd want me to make sure his shower was started for
00:29:32
him while he often seemed to have one foot out the door Mary Katherine says Steven would angrily accuse her of
00:29:39
cheating on him and I was like Steven you saw that we were just in there talking and he just said no I know you
00:29:47
you know you're just a [ __ ] the defense introduces those ugly threatening messages that Steven said
00:29:54
after finding out Mary Catherine had slept with of his at least now I know what you once again were what everyone
00:30:03
told me not to get with when I picked your scrub ass up out of the mud and made you [ __ ] Mary Katherine claims his
00:30:11
text frightened her because the relationship had become violent he said The more you talk the more you get
00:30:18
punished when I get home how did you understand the threat of being punished when you would get home he you know
00:30:26
smack me around sometimes he would grab me and shake me and say you know why can't you just do better and be better
00:30:34
and just do what I tell you to do the details are graphic okay but they are just the beginning he
00:30:41
said I miss you too much I'm coming home to you and you're about to get it bad you're going to the Red Room
00:30:50
tonight what is the Red Room um it's like one of those I guess sex rooms off at 50 Shades of Gray I
00:30:59
don't want out I just I'm not exactly jumping at the opportunity to get whipped and tortured in your Red Room of
00:31:04
pain it wasn't any specific room but it was just when like we would bring out like these certain things that we had
00:31:12
bought what would happen in the Red Room um he'd just tie me up and hit me Mary Catherine tells the court that on two
00:31:20
occasions the rough sex turned into rape one time she says it was just after the
00:31:25
couple had returned from a trip to world he started hurting me really really bad I said Sten please
00:31:34
stop and he said he said that say he spends so much money at me at Disney I need to give him
00:31:46
what he deserves to get up there and call a dead man a rapist that's disgusting she had never
00:31:54
told anyone that before how convenient to wait until you're sitting on The Stand Accused of his
00:32:01
murder and he can't defend himself but Mary Catherine insists that's why she was so afraid of Steven the night she
00:32:08
shot him and she adds a new detail claiming Steven became angry after finding out she wanted to end the
00:32:16
relationship so he started throwing things started you know pushing me around and that's when I got
00:32:24
scared and I just wanted him out of the house and then that's the next thing I remember is him lunging at me and then
00:32:32
the next thing that I remember them is him standing there saying call 911 what she leaves out of her testimony
00:32:41
is the moment she pulled the trigger I never wanted to hurt him I never wanted anything like that I didn't even know it
00:32:49
was chambered him Kate Leonard isn't buying any of it in her cross-examination she confronts
00:32:56
Mary Catherine for never having complained about Steven's alleged abuse can I give you a minute to show me in
00:33:03
those text messages between you and he and you and every other person that was in your cell phone where you talk about
00:33:08
him being physically violent I never talked about it only with friends I never text it
00:33:15
out then the prosecutor has her own surprise for the court hours before killing Steven Mary Katherine was
00:33:23
searching violent internet pornography sites while at a babysit job all of those and many more you looked up when
00:33:30
Steven was not with you but it was him that liked the Red Room is that your testimony yes I looked at things for
00:33:37
ideas cuz obviously he's gone I wanted to please him the woman who just told you that she was
00:33:44
raped looks at gang rape porn bondage porn why would you relive that trauma now Mary Katherine Higman is
00:33:56
about to find out if the jury believes [Music] her Mary Katherine Higden spared no
00:34:11
detail in her emotional testimony about alleged abuse by Steven Freeman so when anytime i' would stand up for myself or
00:34:19
you know kind of retaliate he said don't don't hit me cuz if you hit me I'm would
00:34:24
to hit you 10 times harder you make thank you now it's the prosecution's last chance to argue that none of it is
00:34:32
true this is not a case of self-defense this is a case of manipulation in closing arguments Kate
00:34:39
Leonard reminds the jury of the different stories Mary Katherine told the police the gun was tampered it was
00:34:46
an accident I tossed it I don't know what happened I was scared I was angry but she did not tell them that she was
00:34:56
abused abused and the prosecutor does not believe she was when your abuser is out of the house and you are
00:35:04
safe are you as a victim of domestic violence going to track down your abuser where he is with his friends are you
00:35:12
going to go and track him down does that make sense the prosecutor says Mary Catherine's rage boiled over on the
00:35:23
night of August 1st 2018 after Steven finally came home and then refused to eat the dinner that she
00:35:30
had prepared look at me Steven look at me Steven and when he doesn't he is shot in the left side of the neck where you
00:35:37
know that he's not facing her he never sees it coming in his closing argument defense attorney
00:35:45
Michael Grams focuses on Steven's alleged history of abuse those were his words the more you do this the more
00:35:56
you're get going to get punished grams brings up those ugly texts that Steven sent Mary Katherine a year prior that
00:36:03
torrent of demeaning hatred texts is probably the worst Ty ra that I've ever seen and I'm a criminal
00:36:13
defense lawyer then he recounts Mary Katherine's most serious allegation that Steven raped her and she's crying and
00:36:21
she's telling him it hurts stepen stop stepen you're hurting me his answer well I spent money on you at Disney so I'm
00:36:28
entitled to this he insists Mary Katherine saw the same frightening look in Steven's eyes just before she shot
00:36:36
him Mary Catherine hion knew exactly what was [Music] coming grams demonstrates his point with
00:36:44
an unusual prop as a metaphor does anybody have any doubt about what's going to happen
00:36:55
next you may now retire to the jury r as the case heads to the jury the drama is far
00:37:02
from over I just knew it was a major responsibility two of the jurors Victor and Chris were feeling the weight of
00:37:10
their burden and I knew pretty much no matter what you vote one family gets hurt you destroy one side of that
00:37:17
courtroom no matter what you vote within minutes of getting the case the jury took its first
00:37:23
vote 10-2 guilty but then and I knew that I was about to be the one to upset that apple cart so I
00:37:31
went ahead and did that both Chris and Victor told their fellow jurors that they shared the defense's concerns about
00:37:38
the investigation starting with that lost confession the very beginning I the only thing it
00:37:48
was inside I was like are you kidding me I mean I know this isn't a major city but it's audio equipment she's still in
00:37:57
custody why are you not going to bring her back in to at least speak with her again but Mary Catherine had already
00:38:04
obtained a lawyer where's he going and they question why the police moved the gun that was used to shoot
00:38:12
Steven it's ludicrous to argue that it's easier to move the gun than it was to move her what also troubled them
00:38:22
prosecutors had cracked open Mary Katherine's cell phone for texts social media and search histories but they
00:38:28
decided not to spend another $1,800 to unlock Steven's phone it was too expensive to pay another two grand
00:38:36
to crack his phone open and let's see what kind of person he was to try to you know dispute the rape and abuse
00:38:43
allegations or back them up they didn't do that but you could already get those messages on Mary Katherine's phone no we
00:38:48
get the message between them two we don't get what he was talking about with his homeboys or what he was looking up
00:38:53
online and all Chris and Victor say they were left with serious STS about all of
00:38:59
the prosecution's evidence all of it's tainted from the way the cops handled the investigation well if you don't have
00:39:05
any evidence you don't have a case I didn't have any proof that she had done much anything except for lying and those
00:39:12
lies didn't seem to bother either juror if I was being arrested for potentially murdering somebody I would I probably
00:39:19
would get scared enough that I would just come up with whatever story I could but that almost seems like you're making
00:39:24
an excuse for her not making an excuse just I'm just empathizing with this the situation and in toxic relationships
00:39:31
there are mountains and mountains and mountains of Lies by the next afternoon it was clear
00:39:38
their arguments had made an impact and so the jury had a verdict we the jury find as follows count one
00:39:46
malice murder we find the defendant not guilty count two felony murder we find the defendant not guilty
00:39:59
not guilty of murder as well as the Lesser charges of assault and possession of a firearm during the commission of a
00:40:06
felony and I'm just sitting there and I'm thinking I have failed this family and that was hard we did good
00:40:14
work on this case say that you don't trust the police because of the the interview say you don't trust the
00:40:20
forensic evidence you still have the 911 tapes where she says I shot my boyfriend
00:40:27
two hours later Mary Katherine Higden was a free woman oh I cannot believe this is
00:40:36
happening right now as she watched the woman who killed her son walk free Jennifer Freeman could
00:40:43
barely contain her anger toward the jury Steven definitely got the short end of the stick because I don't believe that
00:40:49
they even listened Victor insists he was just following the law I think she killed him
00:40:57
and that's wrong but you voted not guilty because of the evidence am I understanding you
00:41:06
correctly to say that because the police screwed up she's not guilty I didn't say
00:41:12
she's not guilty she's not in prison the jury found you not guilty on all the charges do you feel any
00:41:22
guilt because I love stepen and I never meant that to ever happen to [Music] him 48 Hours don't miss an
00:41:50
[Music] episode [Music]