Search Captions & Ask AI

Notebook: The possibility of parole

January 05, 2017 / 01:30

This episode of 48 Hours covers the complexities of parole in a murder case, featuring victim's daughters, a convicted murderer, and the parole board's decision-making process.

Tracy Smith discusses the emotional toll on the victim's daughters, who oppose the parole of the man convicted of their mother's murder. They express that attending parole hearings feels like reliving their trauma.

The convicted murderer argues for his release after serving over 20 years, claiming he has been a model prisoner and deserves a second chance.

The episode raises questions about justice, punishment, and the impact of parole decisions on victims' families.

Viewers are invited to consider the difficult balance between justice for victims and the rights of those who have served their time.

TLDR

Victim's daughters fight against parole for their mother's murderer after 20 years in prison.

Episode

1:30
00:00:01
I'm Tracy Smith in a rainy California you might be able to hear the rain on the roof hopefully you can still hear me
00:00:07
so if you're a regular viewer of 48 Hours you know that we usually end our shows with the verdict and the family's
00:00:12
reaction but this time we're going to try something a little different we're going to show you what happens long
00:00:17
after the jurors have gone home we're going to talk about Parole in this case a man was convicted of murder and
00:00:23
sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole and now more than 20 years have passed and he's up for
00:00:29
parole so the question is should it be granted well here you have the victim's daughters who say absolutely not this
00:00:37
guy should stay in prison and they're doing everything in their power to keep him there but for them that means going
00:00:42
to parole hearings and they say it's like reliving their mother's murder over and over again every time they have to
00:00:49
go to one of these hearings in a sense they say it's like they're serving a life sentence because they can never get
00:00:55
Beyond this case they feel like it certainly wasn't over with the conviction this is still haunting them
00:01:00
more than 20 years later on the other side you have a Man Behind Bars who we've spoken to who says listen parole
00:01:07
is the law and not only that he's been a model prisoner and he says it's his time
00:01:12
to get out that he served more than 20 years and now he deserves to be released so the question is when is enough
00:01:19
punishment enough and how does the parole board decide it's a fascinating subject that we rarely look into and
00:01:26
we're going to this week we hope you'll join us

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most heartbreaking
  • 70
    Most emotional
  • 65
    Most intense
  • 60
    Most dramatic

Episode Highlights

  • Parole After 20 Years
    A man convicted of murder is up for parole after over two decades. The victim's daughters fight to keep him in prison, feeling haunted by their mother's murder.
    “This guy should stay in prison!”
    @ 00m 35s
    January 05, 2017

Episode Quotes

  • It's like reliving their mother's murder over and over again.
    Notebook: The possibility of parole
  • When is enough punishment enough?
    Notebook: The possibility of parole

Key Moments

  • Family Struggles00:39
  • Haunting Memories00:46
  • Parole Debate01:17