Search Captions & Ask AI

Forensics aim to prove how Phillip Peatross was shot

April 06, 2014 / 03:53

This episode covers firearm testing, suspect ammunition, laboratory ammunition, and residue analysis. It features discussions on the importance of reproducibility in forensic tests.

The episode begins with a detailed explanation of the test firing process, where a suspect firearm is fired using both suspect and laboratory ammunition. The speaker clarifies the difference between the two types of ammunition, emphasizing the need for reproducibility in results.

Key points include the use of a firearms reference collection and the significance of limiting variabilities in testing. The speaker mentions that the revolver used in the tests was not the one collected as evidence but from the laboratory's collection.

Further discussions focus on the testing distances and the patterns observed in the residues left on different materials, such as skin and twill. The speaker explains the methodology accepted by scientific working groups for estimating ranges in forensic analysis.

The episode concludes with a reminder that while the tests provide useful data, they are tools rather than definitive answers in forensic investigations.

TLDR

This episode discusses firearm testing methods and the importance of reproducibility in forensic analysis.

Episode

3:53
00:00:01
this is where we are going to do the test firing um to get our distance tests where we're we're going to fire our
00:00:10
suspect firearm um using both suspect ammunition and laboratory ammunition for comparison and we're going to fire into
00:00:19
our test fabric at known distances what's the difference between suspect ammunition and lab ammunition there was
00:00:27
ammunition that was emitted with the suspect revolver um so this is ammunition that was actually uh removed
00:00:36
from the cylinder of the revolver at the time we need to test fire laboratory ammunition along with the suspect
00:00:44
ammunition because the ammunition that's used has a great effect on the residues
00:00:50
that are left on the surface so it's a reproducibility we don't have a lot of ammunition from the scene we have a lot
00:00:58
of lab ammunition so we want to make sure although we've gotten the same type of ammunition we want to look at the
00:01:03
reproducibility of our ammunition uh to the suspects this particular revolver is
00:01:09
not the one that was collected for evidence when we did the actual testing it was indeed the revolver that was uh
00:01:18
submitted by the law enforcement agency that was collected at the time this is actually a firearm from our laboratory
00:01:25
collection we keep a Firearms reference collection and where they're from is they're actually from actual cases
00:01:32
through throughout many years once the the the criminal case has been finished um many of those Firearms will actually
00:01:41
end up being destroyed you really want to try to limit your variabilities that's why you want to make sure that
00:01:46
there is reproducibility between uh the same ammo uh that we're using and that the suspect has that's why we use the
00:01:54
same gun the what we can't reproduce is skin so there's clear variability between twill and Skin So
00:02:04
you want to reduce every other variability so you'll be firing into the twi how far away at the time that we did
00:02:11
the test we used the actual evidence revolver and we used both evidence ammunition which we had a limited supply
00:02:20
of and we fired tests at 1 in 3 in 6 in 12 in and 18 in you shoot you look at the pattern and
00:02:33
you want to get the two brackets so it's definitely greater than and the larger one out definitely less than and uh
00:02:41
that's what we looked for first so the 1 in and 18in it was definitely within those
00:03:15
we don't know exactly um how skin reacts compared to the white cotton twill so therefore we're we're developing a
00:03:23
conservative bracket and we're looking for those end brackets that are obviously different than what the
00:03:29
pattern was in the skin how accurate is this test I think it's has a range it's not going to be one to one it helps you
00:03:37
it's a tool just like anything else it's a tool it's not an answer uh per se that's why we have to give a bracket uh
00:03:44
it is accepted uh scientific working group accepted this methodology for giving a rough um Range

Episode Highlights

  • Testing Firearms for Evidence
    Conducting tests on suspect and laboratory ammunition to analyze residue patterns.
    “We want to look at the reproducibility of our ammunition.”
    @ 01m 01s
    April 06, 2014

Episode Quotes

  • It's a tool, not an answer.
    Forensics aim to prove how Phillip Peatross was shot

Key Moments

  • Test Firing00:04
  • Ammunition Comparison00:42
  • Evidence Collection01:22
  • Reproducibility01:46
  • Accuracy of Tests03:32

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown