00:00:00
[Music] it's a Heartland of America small community Farm Town everybody knows everybody everyone knew Amy Mullis you
00:00:24
know she was very bubbly outgoing all of a sudden one day she's dead 91 the address of
00:00:34
your everyone wanted to know what happened to Amy Mullis did you do anything she's just there nothing okay
00:00:41
what is your name sir Todd mull Todd was straight shooter tough man hard worker farmer there's no he calls 911 he's
00:00:52
telling them that somehow some sort of accident happened to his wife I don't know if she I don't know she was halfway
00:00:59
out the door I sent my son over to cheuck on her he yelled at me and I ran over there and
00:01:05
she's am's body is face down sticking out of her back is a corn rake she fell in a fork and P a goddamn Fork out of
00:01:14
her corn rake is a very sharp heavy duty Farm tool nothing like a rake for leaves
00:01:20
it has four prongs sticking out of it and they're typically very sharp I just grabed her the truck the
00:01:27
sun C okay you're headed to the hospital and she is in your vehicle yeah Amy is sitting on her son Tristan's lap and
00:01:34
Todd is in route to the hospital you feel anything Amy Amy Amy she's not resp responding the dispatcher says can you
00:01:47
pull over and so he pulls over on the side of the road sir do you feel comfortable doing
00:01:54
DPR I can try I'll try anything okay he attempts to lay her down flat on the seat and he's pumping her chest hoping
00:02:02
to get her responsive want to want to come on just Spa she's cold come on come on am we never regain
00:02:26
Consciousness it was a a death in a small town Community it shocked everyone this is something that they
00:02:35
were not prepared for and then it doesn't happen [Music] there Todd's story was that he didn't
00:02:44
know what happened so he assumed that she fell on the corn rake and it was an accident you don't fall on a rake that
00:02:53
has four times and suffers six puncture wounds it's hard to believe that it's accidental rumors swirl that wait a
00:03:03
second this wasn't an accident they were having marital problems you would think
00:03:07
that in a case like this there wouldn't be a lot of unanswered questions but here we are questioning exactly what
00:03:14
happened and why this happened by the authority of the state of Iowa accus Todd Mullis of murder first degree
00:03:23
[Music] [Music] [Music] Amy Mullis was a young and beautiful woman she was 39 years old
00:04:30
old she was a daughter a sister a friend and a mother to her three young children in September of 2019 almost a
00:04:43
year after Amy's murder family and friends packed the debut County Courthouse as lead prosecutor Meen
00:04:50
Hughes described what she says happened to the woman they knew so well Amy had so much life left to live but then that
00:04:59
life was viciously taken from her on November 10th 2018 taken at the hands of this
00:05:08
defendant Amy's husband Todd Mullis the hardworking farmer who many Saw as a devoted father to Tristan Taylor and
00:05:16
Wyatt was on trial for first-degree murder this brutal senseless murder happened in a town called
00:05:27
erville Amy was found in this Red Shed on the Family's hog farm by her 13-year-old son Tristan she was faced
00:05:36
down with a corn rake sticking out of her back Amy mullus was viciously and deliberately murdered from the start of
00:05:45
the trial covered by Court TV Todd mullis's attorney Gerald firel agreed with prosecutors that Amy had been
00:05:53
murdered but argued it wasn't Todd who killed her I believe that you will find that there's a reasonable doubt out
00:05:59
about Mr mullis's guilt there's no way that Todd could have killed Amy he did not have the opportunity to do this 48
00:06:08
Hours hired legal experts Daniel and Dina nwat to look at the evidence from the defense point of view and Matthew
00:06:15
Triana to look at it from the prosecution's perspective this is not a random third party this is not a
00:06:22
longdistance gunshot this is up close and personal as serious and brutal and violent as as it
00:06:30
[Music] comes doctor did you know Amy Mullis I knew her as a nurse in the emergency
00:06:41
department Dr Craig Thompson was on duty the day Amy was rushed to the hospital in Manchester Iowa where she once worked
00:06:48
as a nurse shortly after arrival at the hospital I uh understood that Amy mlles had been pronounced dead the first thing
00:06:57
that Thompson the medical director of emergency Services was told Amy's death was a freak accident Amy had been
00:07:05
injured falling on a on a corn rake that was upended Thompson is also a medical examiner and he needed to make sure her
00:07:14
injuries match that story did you notice any or observe any injuries on Amy well
00:07:20
notably she had six puncture wounds across the back I found it very difficult to see how four times could
00:07:27
cause six holes in a single impact fact literally the math doesn't add up yeah it's it's basic math we have a problem
00:07:36
here Dr Cruz did you perform an autopsy on Amy Mullis I did Thompson contacted Dr Kelly Cruz a forensic pathologist for
00:07:46
the State medical examiner's office so she has a small abrasion or a scrape in the middle of her upper lip Cruz found
00:07:53
blunt force injuries to Amy's face hands and knees possible evidence of a struggle this is a photograph of the
00:08:03
Corn rake that was brought to the autopsy Suite there were two different directions of the six puncture wounds
00:08:14
and what do those different directions indicate to you to me they indicate that she would have to be impaled with the
00:08:20
rake at least twice possibly three times which meant the Delaware County Sheriff's office now had a murder to
00:08:28
solve I went immediately to the The Red Shed it was dark by the time Deputy Travis hemath arrived at the farm there
00:08:38
was a couple drops of Blood on the floor and that's where it was described to me
00:08:41
that that's where she was positioned I looked on all the equipment in there for any other indication such as uh blood
00:08:49
markings that would indicate an injury where she had had fallen anywhere else but where she was located and Did You
00:08:55
observe anything I did not he noticed a few drops of blood and with his own eyes
00:09:00
couldn't notice anything else and had concluded the investigation at The Red Shed Daniel Anda nesat wonder whether
00:09:08
Amy's death was even a murder if this was a murder and somebody is stabbing Amy not one not two but three times
00:09:16
you're going to see blood drops on the chemical totes on the shed walls on a suspect you're going to see it on
00:09:23
Amy the Delaware County Sheriff's Department doesn't investigate many homicides Amy was only the fourth in the
00:09:30
last 10 years so they asked for help from Iowa's division of criminal investigation when deputies began
00:09:38
digging into the mullis's marriage they discovered Amy had cheated on Todd 5 years earlier Amy crushed the foundation
00:09:46
of their marriage the trust of their marriage by having an affair Amy and Todd decided to try to work it out they
00:09:53
went to counseling Amy quit her job at the hospital to work on the farm Todd said she wanted to spend more time with
00:10:00
her family but Amy told friends she had no choice she left because it was kind of a deal she made with her husband
00:10:09
after the terms of the deal is that Amy you're done in the hospital you're back on the farm I'm keeping my eye on you
00:10:16
yeah and Todd's position is she signed up for that right we agreed that this was going to be the way it was going to
00:10:23
go it took Todd a very long time I don't think he ever really trusted Amy again in fact she told Terry stainer she felt
00:10:32
like a prisoner it was very regulated who she could do things with it was kind of a joke the approved friend list um
00:10:41
that could actually do things with Amy she was timed when she left home and when she got back there was a line that
00:10:49
was used that she was a prisoner of Todd so this is pretty intense stuff it's controlling Behavior by 2018 Amy was
00:10:57
confiding in friends like Patricia sters that things were not going well she wasn't happy um in her marriage and she
00:11:05
hadn't been happy for many years were you a loving husband would you say you were kind to your wife
00:11:13
anybody H yeah but Todd told a very different story to John turbet a special agent assisting with the investigation
00:11:21
how would you describe your marriage to me pretty TI actually yeah communication
00:11:27
was great and we were're together all the time you know and we yeah between us it was good it just
00:11:40
wasn't the whole truth in July of 2018 5 years after Amy's Affair Todd had noticed a change in her his Radar's up
00:11:49
his Radar's up hey wait a minute I've seen this movie before yep and that raises a red
00:11:55
flag going over phone records Todd discovered his wife had had been communicating with another man Jerry
00:12:02
Frasier a field manager for the Mullis Farm Todd couldn't see there 128 texts but Matt Triano says when Todd
00:12:11
confronted Frasier he was told nothing going on this is business stuff we're talking about kids activities nothing
00:12:20
scandalous all those texts they were all about kids activities and the pig farm correct that's the story Todd had even
00:12:29
called Frasier's wife Jerry's wife convinces him everything is fine they have a happy marriage and and she has no
00:12:36
concerns about her husband and that puts his mind to rest but as investigators quickly
00:12:45
discovered Amy and Jerry Frasier were having an affair and that provided what they
00:12:52
needed a motive for Todd to kill her the the obvious choice always is the husband but Todd also had an airtight
00:13:06
Alibi his son Tristan which means as his father is tried for the murder of his mother Tristan will be the most
00:13:13
important witness for both the prosecution and the defense everyone was on the edge of their seats of what's the
00:13:20
Sun going to say no trist I'd like to direct your attention to November 10th 2018 do you remember that day yes
00:13:32
how do you think Amy Mullis died could it have been an accident see more photos from the case on Facebook at 48
00:13:42
[Music] hours please be seated everyone one of the most anticipated Witnesses at Todd
00:13:53
mullis's murder trial was Todd and Amy's 14-year-old son Tristan we've chosen not
00:13:59
to show his face he testified via closed circuit TV do you swear that the testimony you give here today will be
00:14:06
the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes your honor everyone knew the stakes from the first moments
00:14:13
of the investigation Tristan had provided an alibi for his father legal expert Matthew Trana says Tristan told
00:14:22
police I'm with my dad right we I didn't I didn't lose sight of him I'm with my dad the whole time he may not know it
00:14:28
but he alibiing his father if they are together the whole time then he can't be assaulting his wife and killing his
00:14:36
wife with the monitor facing the jury Tristan spoke of the close Bond he shared with his Dad we would go hunting
00:14:45
fishing um going a forther ride we Farm together obviously the two often work together on
00:14:53
the farm on the day Amy died the two younger kids stayed in the house while Amy joined to and Tristan in one of
00:15:00
their large hog barns it's kind of an open Barn about about 100 about a football field
00:15:07
long Tristan described the division of labor he was setting up portable heaters anticipating a delivery of piglets to
00:15:15
the farm Todd was setting up equipment that provided water to the pens Amy was cleaning the lights so she would get on
00:15:23
a bucket a 5 gallon bucket and then she would reach up to these uh the light bulbs in the ceiling so she would clean
00:15:29
those out everything seemed fine until Tristan noticed something was off with his mom she said she was getting dizzy
00:15:37
she uh kind of like had to like when she got in a bucket she had to hold herself
00:15:41
from falling off and she got down in her legs she was kind of shaky Tristan was worried 4 days earlier Amy had undergone
00:15:49
an outpatient medical procedure this was her first time out of the house I think
00:15:55
I remember saying you know are you all right do you need help cleaning them and then Dad kind of asked the same thing
00:16:02
she just said no like I'm fine but a little while later Amy suffered another dizzy spell according to Tristan Todd
00:16:10
became concerned he said I really don't think it's wise for you to stay out here cuz
00:16:16
you know I don't want you falling off and getting hurt Tristan testified that Todd wanted Amy to go into the house and
00:16:23
rest but asked if on her way she could grab a pet carrier out of The Red Shed some 30 yards away from the front of the
00:16:30
barn Todd told her he would need it later to round up a litter of kittens to protect them from some heavy machinery
00:16:38
he planned to use he said if you can get it to the shop that would help but if you just can't get it then just leave it
00:16:45
we'll get it Amy left Tristan said he and his dad continued working together for about
00:16:52
another hour and a half in the barn then headed to an office at the front that's
00:16:57
when Todd looked out the window and saw the pet carrier was not where he had asked Amy to put it so he just told
00:17:03
me to get it myself he asked you to go to The Red Shed to check on your mom he asked to go check on her cuz like maybe
00:17:13
we thought that she was still struggling to get it out to get the pet cage or maybe she just went in the house so he
00:17:19
just said go check on Mom but he didn't he told you to go to The Red Shed yes when Tristan got to The Red Shed he made
00:17:28
the horrifying Discovery she was kind of on her hands and knees face down did you see anything
00:17:38
that was protruding or sticking out of your mom's body yes what did you see uh corn rake what did you do um I checked
00:17:47
for a pulse on her um neck and her arm I uh just kind of freaked out my anxiety level was 0 to 100 and about a split
00:17:57
second Tristan screamed for his dad Todd arrived saw Amy and told Tristan to go get the family truck and what was your
00:18:06
dad doing that he was helping Mom out of the barn because the opening inside the
00:18:11
shed was so narrow Todd would later tell police he had to remove the corn rake from Amy's back in order to get her out
00:18:19
Todd then picked her up and carried her to the truck Tristan gets into the passenger seat Todd puts Amy essentially
00:18:27
on top of Tristan and drives can you imagine the trauma Tristan must be feeling his mother on top of him as
00:18:36
they're driving away with these serious injuries yeah massive bleeding yeah it's it's terrible right
00:18:45
it's terrible Tristan described to the jury that as they raced towards the hospital
00:18:51
Todd dialed 911 I'm I'm headed there I'm about to okay so you're headed to where
00:18:58
okay went the hospital I I oh I just sced her I thre in the truck he's frantic he's excited when he's on the
00:19:06
phone with 911 the dispatcher says can you pull over and so he pulls over on the side of the road do you swear and
00:19:12
affirm that the testimony you give in this matter will be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes I do
00:19:17
go ahead and have a seat there first to arrive at the scene was Deputy Luke Thompson I saw a young man looked like
00:19:26
he had blood on his coat flagging me down as I pulled up Thompson rushed to help Amy she was unresponsive and not
00:19:35
breathing no pulse she had quite a bit of blood on her on her on her clothes we put her on the ground and I started
00:19:41
doing chest compressions while Deputy Thompson worked on Amy he asked Todd what had happened Todd told him he
00:19:47
wasn't sure but that day Todd also said he suspected Amy had become dizzy and accidentally fell on the rake while
00:19:55
trying to get the pet carrier as for Tristan well Tristan tells the police what his
00:20:04
dad was with him the whole time he was with his dad working in the hog farm the entire
00:20:10
time so if Todd didn't kill Amy who did there was certainly somebody else who had access to that farm and that person
00:20:19
also had a relationship with the mlles and a relationship with Amy Mullis that man Amy was having an affair with Jerry
00:20:28
Frasier may have had his own reasons for wanting Amy out of the picture Jerry Frasier had motive to kill Amy he had a
00:20:37
wife he had children he didn't want to leave his [Music] family why do you think Todd waited to
00:20:44
call 911 until he was on the road hear more of Todd's 911 call at 48 hours.com [Music]
00:21:05
Amy often complain that Todd works too much he preferred to stay home when she preferred to go out you know at some
00:21:15
point those opposites didn't attract anymore and Amy sought attention elsewhere the attention came from this
00:21:24
man state your name and spell it for the record please Jerry Frasier Jerry Frasier the married father of two
00:21:32
managed the mullis's Hog operation and it's in that capacity that he meets Amy since she was the Farm's bookkeeper
00:21:39
Matthew Triano says it was normal for them to be in contact and then it morphs into a personal romantic sexual
00:21:47
relationship their Affair began in late May of 2018 how often would you and Amy meet
00:21:55
for this physical relationship it just depended I mean it was everything was very short it was maybe once a week
00:22:03
maybe more depending on just how it worked out they would meet in secret on the farm on back roads and occasionally
00:22:15
motel rooms well I think it was strictly or more sexual for Jerry than it was for
00:22:22
Amy it seemed like Amy had very strong feelings for Jerry and Patricia Christopherson told jurors Amy
00:22:32
envisioned a future with him he made her happy she had talked about wanting to get married eventually with him but
00:22:39
after Todd discovered those phone records and began asking questions Frasier got nervous yeah I I told her
00:22:48
that we needed to slow down were you afraid about Todd finding out about your Affair yes why oh why wouldn't you be
00:22:55
but they kept seeing each other by late sum 2018 word was out about Amy's latest
00:23:02
infidelity her friend Terry stainer says Amy was worried she said I'm going to tell Todd that there's rumors out there
00:23:12
to stop this so if he hears it he'll think it's just the rumor mill going around Dina nwat says Jerry Frasier was
00:23:21
also feeling pressure he had a wife he had children he didn't want to leave his family she is a threat of Jerry and his
00:23:29
family so when Amy was murdered just 2 months later Jerry Frasier immediately became a person of interest he had
00:23:37
motive he had means he is on that farm all the time he had just as much motive as Todd
00:23:45
did special agent John turban interviewed Frasier he sat next to me in my unmarked police vehicle and we talked
00:23:52
for an hour and a half Frasier readily admitted to the affair but insisted he couldn't have killed Amy he was home in
00:24:00
Anamosa 45 minutes away and just like Todd Mullis his son was his Alibi his college age son had excellent recall and
00:24:10
so they had gotten up and spent all Saturday morning doing work and then they watched college football
00:24:16
investigators went through Frasier's cell phone records at the time Amy was murdered we could see that Jerry
00:24:23
Frasier's cell phone had cell phone activity around 10:45 11:45 12:45 all of that down in Anamosa but Daniel mwat
00:24:31
says if someone wanted to commit murder today's day and age no don't bring your cell phone with you leave it at home the
00:24:37
cell phone pinging only means that's where the cell phone was correct does it mean where Jerry was investigators
00:24:44
concluded Jerry Frasier wasn't involved and they turned their attention back to Todd Mullis in spite of his Alibi word
00:24:52
was Amy wanted a divorce that's motivation because if she leaves and they get divorced he loses
00:25:01
the farm loses half at least pays her alimony child support splits probably his life in half so he needs things to
00:25:12
be together investigators were especially interested in what Amy told her friends that Todd might do to her I
00:25:19
asked her why she stayed and she said she was scared of Todd and if he found out about wanting a divorce or an Affair
00:25:29
that he would kill her one time she did say that if he ever found out she would disappear she even told Terry stainer
00:25:37
where to search for her on the mullus property she said Tera if I ever come up missing have him look in our new
00:25:45
Timber stainer worried Amy's affair would provoke Todd I told her you know Amy you're putting yourself in a really
00:25:54
dangerous situation and I said at that time he is going to kill you and why did you say that
00:26:02
because Todd is just a the person you don't mess with as they built their case investigators began focusing on Todd's
00:26:14
actions the day Amy died like sending trist to The Red Shed long after Amy had gone to get the pet carrier why would
00:26:24
she still be in The Red Shed So an instruction would be wider than just the Red Shed absolutely go find Mom search
00:26:34
the farm so why would Todd pick Red Shed of all the possibilities the prosecution
00:26:42
would want you to believe that he wants Tristan to find mom he needs Amy to be located by somebody other than
00:26:51
him and they actually conver and then there was Todd's police interview when John turbet accused him of murdering his
00:26:59
wife we completed our investigation at this point and the case face clearly show you're responsible for for death at
00:27:07
this point I'm Matthew trano says Todd's reaction was ring if you get put into an
00:27:17
interrogation room and you had nothing to do with the death of your wife the death of anybody but you are accused
00:27:23
wrongly you are going to fight back you're going to scream you're going to yell and none of that from Todd no not
00:27:34
enough but Dina nesw disagrees how would you describe his reaction baffled what me I'm
00:27:44
responsible if somebody said you killed your spouse would you have an emotional reaction to that everybody reacts
00:27:53
differently to everything he tried to deny it several times and taught even said you want me to confess to something
00:27:59
I didn't do but what about Todd mullis's airtight Alibi it turns out there may be some
00:28:08
cracks in Tristan's story at some point did you lose sight of your dad yes Todd Mullis was the prime suspect in the
00:28:34
death of his wife Amy but he's always had a solid Alibi from his teenage son Tristan Tristan told authorities he was
00:28:42
with his father all morning how important was that for Todd crucial that was his Saving
00:28:49
Grace but everything changed just days before the trial when Tristan was reinterviewed and admitted he did not
00:28:57
have eyes on his father the whole time Tristan said he lost sight of Todd a couple of times when Tristan went to get
00:29:04
some water in the office at the front of the barn legal expert Matthew trano this
00:29:10
is not the situation that we had before where Tristan is saying I'm with him the
00:29:15
whole time I have eyes on my dad the entire time correct and once you don't have that game
00:29:22
changer in that interview Tristan estimated he was gone less than a minute each time but when he was questioned by
00:29:30
prosecutor maren Hughes at the trial do you know exactly how long your dad wasn't in your sight no Tristan would it
00:29:38
be accurate to say that you don't know how much time you were away from your dad when you were in when you were
00:29:43
working in the hog Barn yes and with Tristan's revised statement the prosecution insisted Todd had the
00:29:52
opportunity to kill Amy every statement that he's given has been worse and worse for his father
00:30:00
because the first one was pretty airtight what do you think's going on with Tristan I think he's like any other
00:30:06
13 or 14 or 15y old where there's probably I want to try to do the right thing I want to try to maybe help my mom
00:30:16
and help my dad and you know that's culminated and he has to testify against his father it's
00:30:23
awful but there was still room for doubt Tristan said he never saw blood on Todd
00:30:30
and that at no point while they were working together in the hog Barn did his demeanor change what's more Dena nwat
00:30:37
maintains that no matter how long it took Tristan to get those drinks of water in the office there was no way
00:30:44
Todd had enough time to get from the hog Barn to The Red Shed to expect him to stab his wife with a corn rig not once
00:30:52
not twice possibly three times wait for her to make sure she's dead and then come with no blood no torn clothes same
00:30:59
composure as if nothing happened it's not possible investigators didn't have any
00:31:04
physical evidence linking Todd to the scene but they did have Electronics from the mullus farm including a security
00:31:12
camera system there's two Vantage points for these cameras that look out over the
00:31:17
property one of which would have captured the area around the Red Shed not inside the Red Shed but Around The
00:31:24
Red Shed and when investigators searched for any footage from the day Amy died we
00:31:31
were unable to find any video but strangely one of the cameras had a recording from the next day well now
00:31:38
that doesn't seem to add up do you think he deleted the footage I think that the
00:31:43
reasonable explanation is that he deleted the footage to make matters worse for Todd
00:31:51
investigators found a series of disturbing internet searches on Todd's iPad including what happens to cheaters
00:31:59
in history Thrill of the kill and killing Unfaithful women if I'm investigating a
00:32:06
homicide and the guy I think committed the murder of his wife has been searching online about what happens to
00:32:15
cheating wives don't I have an open and shut case it doesn't look good with the prosecution's case laid
00:32:23
out all eyes turned to Todd who took the stand in his own defense were you surprised that Todd testified you know
00:32:33
his reactions and and his actions and what he does and doesn't do are made such an important part of the case that
00:32:40
the best person to explain that is Todd Mullis for about 3 hours Todd calmly addressed the many questions swirling
00:32:50
around him including why he didn't call 911 right away I I just wanted to help her I just want to let's let's go
00:33:00
to the hospital is there's something wrong I'm a doer I guess I just I want to help I was interaction mode I I
00:33:07
wanted to get her to the hospital Todd also told the jury why there was no security camera footage
00:33:15
from the day Amy died he said he believed his cats had accidentally knocked the antennas off the window
00:33:21
ledge while they were trying to find a warm spot to sit the colder it gets cats to heat and there's a heater right below
00:33:31
the window sun comes up in the morning they sit in the window in fact there were no recordings for nearly 2 weeks
00:33:38
leading up to Amy's death and the reason one of the cameras suddenly started working the following day it was the day
00:33:46
after I think after talking to family members and stuff they go do you have anything on the camera so I went out I
00:33:52
seen everything was knocked off hanging down by the floor I picked it all back up I did not know how long it had been
00:34:00
off or whatever as for those internet searches about cheating spouses when defense
00:34:06
attorney Gerald firel asked Todd if he had done them no I did not do you know who did I have no idea who looked that
00:34:15
up Todd said other family members use the iPad including Amy have you ever searched for wedding dresses I have
00:34:22
never searched for wedding dresses did you ever do a Pinterest search no do you know what Pinterest is I have no idea
00:34:29
what Pinterest is then came the question everyone wanted to know Todd did did you Ambush your wife Amy in that shed
00:34:41
that day and brutally beat her and chop Cho her up with that corn Fork no I did not do you know who did I have no idea
00:34:50
in closing statements the prosecutor left the jury with a final thought about Todd's motive why did he kill Amy
00:34:58
because he didn't want to lose his farm because she was cheating you might not like that Amy was having an affair but
00:35:04
that doesn't mean she deserved to die as for the defense the state has not proven a case against Todd Mullis Beyond
00:35:12
A Reasonable Doubt the dots don't even remotely connect here there was Zero physical evidence linking Todd to
00:35:20
anything that happened with the week-long trial complete the jury was excused to deliberate and decide Todd
00:35:28
mullis's [Music] [Music] fate after a week of testimony it was now up to the jury to decide if Todd
00:35:48
Mullis had murdered his wife Amy I think the question is this not so much is Todd
00:35:57
mullet innocent of doing this I think the more critical question is did the state prove
00:36:03
that he did it this woman who asked that we not use her name was an alternate juror who weighed all of the testimony
00:36:10
and evidence as she watched the trial from where you're sitting did the prosecution do a good job I personally
00:36:18
just wish that they would have been able to provide more forensics [Music] evidence and some of the 12 jurors who
00:36:27
went into the Jury Room to decide Todd mullis's fate felt much the same way this juror who also did not want to use
00:36:35
her name said the jury was split going into deliberations what was the initial field
00:36:42
there was probably half at least that Saidi was guilty and then the rest were undecided there were some that had
00:36:51
difficulty saying he was guilty when there was no Witnesses this was a big deal that you were basically sifting
00:36:58
through circumstantial evidence and there was no witness to the crime yes it was a serious a serious verdict to come
00:37:06
up with I am informed that the jury has reached a verdict after roughly 7 hours of deliberation a verdict we the jury
00:37:18
find the defendant Todd Michael Mullis guilty of the crime of Murder in the First Degree guilty
00:37:27
Amy mullis's family breathed a sigh of relief and Todd Mullis subtly shook his head before being let out of the
00:37:35
courtroom in Chains as this juror explained the jury reached a consensus by going back through all the evidence
00:37:44
we talked about all the different scenarios it could have been and it was we couldn't come up with a plausible
00:37:51
explanation but then we went back to Todd and all the points against him it was a ser of unfortunate events that
00:37:59
just didn't add up starting with Todd's decision to take the corn rake out of Amy's back and drive her away to get
00:38:06
help before calling 911 I didn't understand why he didn't call 911 and the fact that he chose not to was that a
00:38:14
big deal for you yes I think he wanted to get her away from the farm and she says Todd did not do
00:38:22
himself any favors by taking the stand to me he seemed cold he was a cold fish you know he was probably a man a
00:38:32
few words which a lot of farmers are but when you talk about things that they're
00:38:36
passionate about like their families or their Farms or their wives or they usually can muster up some
00:38:45
emotion then there were those internet searches we spent quite a bit of time going line by line and then looking at
00:38:52
the searches before looking at the searches after and we concluded that they it was him it wasn't just a crime
00:39:00
of passion he had premeditation after being found guilty Todd Mullis hired a new legal team and
00:39:09
submitted a motion for a new trial as he awaited sentencing so now the issue is going to become a legal issue of did he
00:39:16
get a fair trial was anything done wrong that shouldn't have happened Todd's motion claimed that
00:39:23
among other things Todd's trial lawyers blatantly disregarded his guidance to argue that Amy died from an accident
00:39:30
right from the start Amy Mullis was viciously and deliberately alert and when that happened Todd wrote on a sheet
00:39:38
of paper what the f was that the job of the defense lawyer is not to convince the jury that Todd is
00:39:48
innocent the job is to create Reasonable Doubt in the minds of the jury he should
00:39:54
never have closed that door he should have left it open for the jury to wonder well was it an accident or was it a
00:39:59
murder the judge ruled on the motion as to the defendant's motion for du trial and motion in arrest of judgment I will
00:40:09
deny those motions in their entirety we will go ahead and proceed with sentencing at this time before being
00:40:17
sentenced Todd Mullis took one last chance to address the court I did not do this uh this is supposed to be America
00:40:26
where you shouldn't have to prove your innocence I thought it was guilty until or not uh innocent until proven guilty I
00:40:33
feel this is the other way around and I was a faithful and loving [Music] husband Mr Mullis for the charge of
00:40:42
Murder in the First Degree you are sentenced to life in prison with no opportunity for
00:40:51
parole now as Todd Mullis is left to appeal his conviction from prison the ripples of Amy's death continue to be
00:40:58
felt by all who loved her this case is a tragedy all around you have three beautiful children that not only lost
00:41:08
their mother they lost their father at the same time What Todd Mullis did if he did do
00:41:15
this is he acted selfishly in his own best interest to remove a potential problem in his
00:41:25
life but he didn't think or think enough about his three kids and all of the other layers of trauma that would
00:41:34
result four victims not one yeah at least at [Music] least adopted and capable of Murder She
00:41:55
has thought about killing her brother she is a danger to our family The Lost Child that haunted us we cannot be her
00:42:02
parents anymore until we found her years later and heard her surprising story a new 48 Hours next on CBS