
This episode covers the brutal murder of Rita Pulley, the investigation into her son Michael Pulley, and the ensuing trial. Key discussions include the crime scene details, Michael's arrest at age 14, and the lack of evidence against him.
Michael Pulley recounts the traumatic night of December 4, 1998, when he discovered his mother on fire. He describes his last interaction with her and the horror of finding her body.
The investigation focused on Michael as a suspect due to his past behavior and the circumstances surrounding the murder. Despite no physical evidence linking him to the crime, he was convicted of second-degree murder.
Michael maintains his innocence throughout the episode, questioning how a 14-year-old could commit such a violent act without leaving evidence. He points to another individual who had a motive to harm his mother.
The episode highlights the emotional impact of the case on Michael and the community, as Rita was well-known and loved by many.
Michael Pulley recalls discovering his mother's brutal murder and his wrongful conviction at age 14.

This episode stands out for the following:
I received a call from the sheriff's department that there had been a homicide.The Case Against Michael Politte | Sneak peek
I was scared to death I didn't know what to do.The Case Against Michael Politte | Sneak peek
Michael did you kill your mom? No.The Case Against Michael Politte | Sneak peek