
This episode covers the controversial life of Catherine Shelton, a Texas woman accused of multiple crimes including fraud, homicide, and elder abuse. Journalist Jenna Jackson discusses Shelton's history of relationships with men who have died under suspicious circumstances.
Jackson recounts several incidents involving Shelton, including an ex-boyfriend found beaten to death and another who was shot by Shelton, which she claims was self-defense. The episode highlights the odd circumstances surrounding these cases and the ongoing speculation about Shelton's involvement.
Listeners learn about a young man discovered hanging in a house owned by Shelton, whose death was ruled an accident, and another man found dead in her home. Despite these incidents, Shelton has never been charged with murder.
The episode raises questions about whether Shelton is truly unlucky or if she has managed to evade justice. Jackson expresses her obsession with uncovering the truth behind Shelton's story.
Catherine Shelton's life is filled with suspicious deaths and accusations of crime, raising questions about her innocence or bad luck.

This episode stands out for the following:
It was the loudest sound I'd ever heard.Sneak peek: Chasing Catherine Shelton (Part 2)
I have done a few things, yes.Sneak peek: Chasing Catherine Shelton (Part 2)
Maybe she's just really unlucky.Sneak peek: Chasing Catherine Shelton (Part 2)