
This episode discusses the 35-year-old cold case of Janelle Matthews, her disappearance in 1984, and the recent discovery of her remains.
The episode begins with a recounting of the events surrounding Janelle's disappearance on December 20, 1984. Her friends and family describe her as a sweet and bubbly girl who was last seen after a basketball game.
As the years passed, the police continued to investigate the case, but it remained unsolved for decades. The emotional weight of the case is highlighted by the impact on Janelle's family and the community.
In a significant turn, Janelle's remains were discovered by a bulldozer operator over 20 miles from her home. The episode introduces Steve Pankey, a person of interest in the case, who claims he has no connection to Janelle.
The discussion includes the ongoing investigation and the implications of the recent findings, leaving listeners with questions about justice and closure for Janelle's family.
The episode covers Janelle Matthews' 1984 disappearance and recent discovery of her remains, highlighting ongoing investigations and emotional impacts.

This episode stands out for the following:
I just had a sick feeling to my stomach.Sneak peek: The Kidnapping of Jonelle Matthews
Janelle was finally found... I didn't want that to be Janelle.Sneak peek: The Kidnapping of Jonelle Matthews
He’s a talkative guy, I voluntarily gave my DNA, but he's not a murderer.Sneak peek: The Kidnapping of Jonelle Matthews