Search Captions & Ask AI

Reporter's notebook: Addiction and domestic violence

November 27, 2014 / 02:23

This episode covers the issues surrounding women who drink, domestic violence, and the role of Alcoholics Anonymous in the judicial system. It highlights the case of Carla Mendes Brada, discussing the stigma and accountability related to alcohol use and violent crime.

The conversation focuses on the lack of oversight in Alcoholics Anonymous, which has been used by courts as a sentencing tool for offenders. The episode raises questions about the safety of individuals attending AA meetings alongside those with violent criminal backgrounds.

Listeners are encouraged to consider whether the protection of anonymity for offenders is more important than the safety of potential victims. The episode invites audience participation through social media during and after the show.

TLDR

The episode discusses Alcoholics Anonymous, domestic violence, and the safety of women in support groups.

Episode

2:23
00:00:01
this is the home where Carla Mendes brada lived and died it serves as sort of a ground zero for all the very
00:00:09
important issues that this week's show addresses with the case that we focus in on women who drink women who are bravely
00:00:16
coming out of the Shadows looking for help with that problem domestic violence the shame and the blame behind it and
00:00:23
the fact that many of our courts in this country use support groups like Alcoholics Anonymous as a sentencing
00:00:29
tool in instead of holding violent criminal offenders accountable for their actions even and regardless if they were
00:00:35
drunk when they committed the offense one of the groups as I mentioned that we often see trying to help in all these
00:00:41
situations is alcoholic synonymous it was founded in the 1930s and millions and millions of people across the entire
00:00:49
planet have been helped to get sober by AA but AA is not a reabilitation group it is a support group in fact it says
00:00:57
right here on their website that it is a Fellowship that it is a nonprofessional
00:01:02
self-supporting group and what we found out really means is there is a dramatic lack of oversight it is self-supporting
00:01:10
and many of those who voluntarily go to AA are all too often sitting alongside a
00:01:16
predator somebody who has been mandated to go there by the courts or somebody who has a violent criminal past now to
00:01:23
me there seems like there's a pretty easy solution to that why not separate the groups why can't you have two
00:01:30
meetings instead of one well AA says that that violates the very Spirit of anonymity perhaps but it begs a very
00:01:40
important question is it more important to protect the identity of a predator or
00:01:45
to protect the innocent person and potential victim that is sitting next to them we tried to pose that question to
00:01:53
Alcoholics Anonymous tune in for this week's show to see what their comment on that was I know this is a fairly cont
00:01:59
controversial topic because it is very important to get help especially if your time has come that you really want that
00:02:06
help you need to seek it but you also need to find out who you're going to be doing and getting that help with and
00:02:11
from if you want to join the conversation or you have a comment I strongly encourage you to join us live
00:02:17
during and after the show on Twitter and Facebook

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 60
    Most shocking
  • 60
    Most controversial

Episode Highlights

  • The Role of Alcoholics Anonymous
    AA has helped millions but lacks oversight, raising concerns about safety in support groups.
    “AA is not a rehabilitation group; it is a support group.”
    @ 00m 55s
    November 27, 2014
  • Controversial Questions
    Is it more important to protect the identity of a predator or the innocent?
    “It begs a very important question.”
    @ 01m 36s
    November 27, 2014

Episode Quotes

  • Is it more important to protect the identity of a predator?
    Reporter's notebook: Addiction and domestic violence
  • You need to find out who you're going to be getting help with.
    Reporter's notebook: Addiction and domestic violence

Key Moments

  • Ground Zero for Issues00:06
  • Domestic Violence Discussion00:18
  • Support Group Concerns00:44
  • Anonymity vs. Safety01:36
  • Join the Conversation02:15

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown