00:00:00
[Music] prosecutors began laying out the state's case this morning this case of course
00:00:10
gained International attention when it happened the interest in this story was immediate it was intense and it was
00:00:18
sustained it occurred to me what this case is really about it is about a mother's worst nightmare State Police
00:00:27
were desperate to find missing mother of five Jennifer Doos I'm Tony iello I'm a
00:00:32
reporter with CBS News New York it was May 24th 2019 Jennifer Farber doulos disappeared from her home in new Canan
00:00:41
Connecticut every script has three acts doesn't it the First Act was the premeditation and killing of Jennifer
00:00:50
Duos was there a particular area of the house that you focused on the garage was
00:00:54
of uh importance blood likee substance blood spatter throughout the garage there's
00:01:00
some back here too where is Jennifer doulos to this day that question can't be answered you know
00:01:10
then obviously you learn that she's going through a contentious Divorce fotus dulos by all accounts very
00:01:16
Charming athletic I mean they made a beautiful couple she told me he is having an affair and I have proof where
00:01:23
is she where is she investigators taking a close look at her estranged husband fotus doulos
00:01:31
in January of 2020 he's charged with murder Lotus what do you have to say to this murder charge at exactly the time
00:01:40
fotus doulos was due in court officers were seen running into his Connecticut reportedly attempted suicide by carbon
00:01:47
monoxide poisoning fotus duus was declared dead tonight the investigation did not die
00:01:55
with photoos police believe Michelle tronus helped her boy friend fotus duus get rid of his wife she's now charged
00:02:03
with conspiracy in the murder of Jennifer doulos you're going to do the right thing Michelle and help the cops
00:02:10
the second act was the cover up through the destruction of evidence and the defendants lies why did you tell us
00:02:16
things that you knew were false I was in shock I was nervous they threatened her
00:02:23
they scared her they lied to her prosecutors say they'll prove Michelle draconus conspired in the crime and
00:02:30
helped fodis dulos dispose of evidence the evening that his estranged wife Jennifer disappeared you see photus
00:02:38
dulos putting black garbage bags into the trash can Michelle did not know what photus duus was up to she was in love
00:02:50
because at the beginning he was this amazing guy but it turns out he was this monster never been on a jury didn't know
00:02:57
what to expect and when I saw Jennifer his bloody shirt they've really had an impact this defendant hated Jennifer
00:03:07
Doos I know that everyone wants answers but my sister's not the right answer she's another victim of photus
00:03:15
doulos and now we've reached the third act she doesn't know anything but she's innocent except she doesn't get to write
00:03:24
it you write the third Act of this script with your verdict what's the ending going to
00:03:36
[Music] be [Music] [Music] it was one of the most anticipated trials in recent memory the state of
00:04:23
Connecticut versus Michelle tronus a case that has haunted the family and friends of Jennifer dulos for nearly 5
00:04:32
years I wanted to be there every day because Jennifer couldn't be there and I wanted to be there for her to Bear
00:04:41
witness longtime friend Carrie Luft was in court every day as prosecutor sha mcginness and Michelle Manning presented
00:04:50
their case blood soed shirt that Michelle draconus conspired with her boyfriend fotus dulos to murder his
00:04:57
estranged wife and then helped to cover up the crime this defendant was undoubtedly
00:05:04
part of this plan to kill Jen fulos there's no if ANS or buts about it as the defendant listened in Spanish
00:05:13
her first language her attorney John shorn described her as just another victim of fotus dlos there is nothing to
00:05:21
suggest that Michelle had any clue about what was going to happen in new Canan on
00:05:27
May 24th 2019 Michelle simply did not know May 24th 2019 started like any other day for Jennifer Farber dulos with
00:05:42
the usual organized chaos of getting her five children 13 and under dressed and off to
00:05:50
school but shortly after 8:05 a.m. Jennifer vanished she was scheduled for a dentist
00:06:00
appointment uh later that morning in uh New York City she never made it to her dentist appointment then Connecticut
00:06:07
State Police Sergeant Kenneth vent tresca would become one of the lead investigators people couldn't get a hold
00:06:14
of her on the stand the children's Nanny Lauren Almeida recalled her gwing sense
00:06:21
of dread the second I called Jennifer it's like my stomach just sank cuz she never not answered her
00:06:30
Lauren took the children to wait at the home of their maternal grandmother Gloria Farber in New York City the
00:06:37
88-year-old Mrs Farber says she waited for her daughter to come get them did Jennifer show up at your apartment that
00:06:44
day no have you seen your daughter Jennifer since she failed to meet you at your
00:06:50
apartment in New York City on May 24th 2019 no by 700 p.m. all out Panic set in Lauren called the police we told the
00:07:03
police that a mother of five was missing and that she was in a very contentious divorce officers quickly discovered
00:07:13
Jennifer's abandoned Suburban SUV in nearby weny park the tailgate was was backed up
00:07:22
against this tree the Suburban was not running keys were not in the ignition you could see the cleanup of the
00:07:28
blood-like substance all over over the passenger side under a flashlight police are not sharing much
00:07:34
information as they search new Canan police launched a massive search all I want to say is Jennifer we love you and
00:07:42
we are doing everything we can to bring you home Sergeant ventresca says the one
00:07:47
person who didn't seem worried about Jennifer was the father of her five children her estranged husband fotus
00:07:55
dulos did he help it all in the search no no did he seem concerned about his wife as time went on no never seemed
00:08:03
concerned about his wife it wasn't always that way they met in college Jennifer a writer and playwright from a
00:08:12
wealthy New York family and fotus an international water scheme Champion raised in Greece both students at Brown
00:08:21
University it turned romantic some 17 years later after a chance meeting at the Aspen Airport what did she like
00:08:30
about him eventually love about him well you know he was a really Charming person
00:08:37
he was very handsome he was smart and funny and an ambitious real estate developer and builder of luxury homes hi
00:08:47
I'm foris stos and I'm the owner of for group we're custom Builders working primarily in the Harford and Fairfield
00:08:55
counties fotus and Jennifer married in 2004 four soon there were five children two sets of twins and then a little
00:09:04
daughter Lauren says Jennifer loved being a mother she would sing to them and laugh at them and she never raised
00:09:12
her voice she was just like incredibly nurturing the growing family moved into one of fotus opulent homes in Farmington
00:09:21
Connecticut a suburb of Heartford they had all the advantages money affords and an emphasis on sport
00:09:30
especially water skiing but the marriage was increasingly Rocky says Lauren so I was in one of the kids'
00:09:39
rooms and we started to hear screaming and Jennifer ran through the bedroom door votus was yelling and she closed
00:09:46
the door behind her and pushed her body up against the door and he was trying to
00:09:50
get in and I mean her face was just she was terrified by 2016 fotus was away and as
00:09:59
many as 10 days a month often chasing the latest water skiing competition on a trip to Miami he met
00:10:07
Michelle draconus the Venezuelan raised single mother was photos's type she rode
00:10:17
horses reported for ESPN in South America on snow skiing and even more to photos's liking she was a competitive
00:10:26
water skier Michelle's sister Claudia marmo he was charismatic he was into sports just like she was he was a loving
00:10:36
father soon fotus and Michelle began an affair it didn't take long for Jennifer to put two and two
00:10:45
together through email and receipts she found out that he went on a trip to Utah
00:10:51
with Michelle and a friend of his and his girlfriend Jennifer later told Lauren she confronted fotus and he ad
00:10:59
commed to having the affair that was it she devised a secret plan to take the kids and move out with Lauren's help she
00:11:08
was afraid of what fotus would do to her or with the kids if she filed for a divorce while they were living under the
00:11:16
same roof but Jennifer did file for divorce took the kids and moved into a rental home in new
00:11:23
Canan Michelle and her young daughter moved into fotus house in Farmington she fell in love with him and they had a
00:11:31
very amazing relationship it would turn out to be one of the biggest mistakes of Michelle
00:11:38
tronus life where is she where is [Music] [Music] she they showed up every day friends of
00:12:03
Jennifer somber and respectful we did need to just bring her her presence the love for her into the
00:12:13
courtroom for Jennifer's loved ones there has been no body to mourn No Grave to visit her remains have never been
00:12:22
found for prosecutors it added another set of challenges to an already difficult case
00:12:29
to prove Beyond a reasonable doubt that Michelle draconus conspired with fotus dulos to commit murder they first had to
00:12:38
prove there was a murder and then that it was fotus who murdered her but 8 months after Jennifer vanished
00:12:47
and long before a trial would begin fotus dulos took his own life I always thought this trial was against a ghost
00:12:57
prosecutors essentially brought fotus back to life by focusing on the day Jennifer went
00:13:03
missing they presented what investigators had found at her home when they go to the house they go
00:13:11
in the garage they notice blood likee substance there some back here too sergeant ventresca and detective
00:13:21
John Kimble of the state's major crime Squad were summoned to the scene there was evidence that someone
00:13:28
had attempted to clean up blood there what appear to be swirl marks on the sides of the
00:13:34
vehicles a serious violence Soul occurred in that garage I mean there's definitely some sort of file play
00:13:41
involved within hours of searching the house up here too investigators learned fotus had a possible motive that
00:13:50
contentious divorce Something Jennifer expressed in court documents he is dangerous and ruthless when he believes
00:13:58
he's been wrong wronged he must always win at all costs and there was little doubt that fotus was losing he had spent
00:14:06
thousands of dollars in legal fees and core costs his business was floundering and worse he lost shared physical
00:14:14
custody of his children I don't think fotus like to lose in any aspect of his life and I don't think that he liked to
00:14:20
be losing in court at the hands of his wife the day after the mother of his children disappeared fotus was summon to
00:14:29
the new Kanan police station did he agree to sit down and talk no but they got something more important than an
00:14:36
interview police took fotus his phone they tracked it to Albany Avenue in Harford around 700 p.m. the evening of
00:14:45
May 24th roughly the same time Jennifer was reported missing it turns out there were security cameras all along fotus
00:14:56
Route new Kanan police officer Thomas Patton couldn't believe his eyes what do you see well as he was driving around he
00:15:03
would be he was depositing black garbage bags in various reticles and is he alone no in in one of
00:15:11
those pictures you can see a female that's leaning outside of the passenger side of the truck turns out that the
00:15:17
female reaching for the sidewalk was Michelle tronus within days a team of detectives
00:15:25
was dispatched to go digging through the trash some of the things retrieved were
00:15:30
used zip ties with uh human blood and DNA of Jennifer doulos on them um female undergarments a Vineyard Vine shirt in
00:15:39
the size that Jennifer wore at trial for the first time they showed those bloody
00:15:49
clothes I think it was really important that they did that we had seen photographs of that
00:15:57
evidence so I knew what it looked like but being in the same space the same space and time
00:16:06
as Jennifer's clothes just really drove home that she's not here on June 1 2019 8 days after
00:16:17
Jennifer vanished both photus dulos and Michelle tronus were arrested for tampering with or fabricating physical
00:16:26
evidence and first deegree hindering prosecution they still did not have enough for a murder
00:16:33
charge fotus refused to talk to the police but Michelle gave the first of three interviews what's the red stuff officers
00:16:42
made it clear Jennifer was not just missing she was murdered basically here's a fact fotus
00:16:50
killed Jennifer okay this is a fact we know this we we need to find Jennifer officers were trying to figure
00:17:04
out if she knew where Jennifer's Body was if you had to get rid of a body which was no longer one piece mhm where
00:17:12
would you go me or where do you think fotus might go okay I'm not saying you where would fotus have gone to take
00:17:21
either Jennifer or parts of Jennifer to get rid of her don't know Michelle insisted she did know know anything
00:17:29
about a body she also gave photus an alibi she told them he was with her at home that morning at for Jefferson
00:17:37
Crossing for this WS up too we when I go to the bathroom I brush my teeth I get into the shower mhm put his Jones into
00:17:46
the shower with me mhm and prob a 5 minute shower that statement would come back to
00:17:57
Haunter both photo fotus and Michelle were released on Bond and ordered not to communicate with one another fotus
00:18:04
stayed in his glittering Mansion at Fort Jefferson Crossing Michelle moved into her own apartment and would forever be
00:18:13
branded as the other woman I'll be honest with you you're probably one of the most hated woman in
00:18:20
par right now 10 days after Jennifer disappeared investigators found papers at fotus
00:18:42
Michelle's home that they came to believe were actually Alibi scripts a timeline say prosecutors that photo
00:18:51
dulos and Michelle created to keep their stor straight 6:40 wake up alarm and then took shower together that timeline
00:19:01
became Central to the state's case not only for what was in it but for what wasn't the cops asked her why wasn't
00:19:09
Harford in your timeline oh I was going to write that but I got interrupted isn't that coincidence isn't
00:19:15
that convenient prosecutors set out to show what they say is the real timeline starting in the early hours of May 24th
00:19:25
the day Jennifer vanished surveillance footage show shows a truck leaving an empty house that fotus had renovated for
00:19:33
sale a red pickup truck was seen um leaving that residence headed towards Route 4 at approximately 530 535
00:19:42
hours Sergeant Kenneth vesa who thinks fotus was driving tracked the pickup truck heading towards new Kanan where
00:19:50
Jennifer lived we eventually located a red Toyota Tacoma pickup truck driving southbound the Tacoma was spotted 2 and
00:19:59
1/2 hours later shortly before 8:00 a.m. in new Kanan near waveny Park this is where he had parked it investigators
00:20:08
believe fotus had brought a bicycle with him and that's him biking the last three
00:20:14
miles to Jennifer's house he came over in the back road over there he waited for her to drop the kids
00:20:23
off at school she came home in the morning she enters the garage now that's where the violent
00:20:29
assault occurred in the house prosecutors say that while fotus was killing Jennifer Michelle was back
00:20:36
at their house providing an alibi fotus had left his phone at home and pre-arranged a call with a friend from
00:20:45
Greece prosecutors believe Michelle picked up the call to make it appear that fotus was
00:20:51
home make no mistake she knew exactly what she was doing when she answered that phone prosecutors claim Michelle
00:20:59
then moved it around locking it and unlocking it to continue to show activity now the only person who could
00:21:06
have reasonably manipulated photos's phone that morning is Michelle tronus this is the conspiracy during the time
00:21:15
prosecutors say Michelle was manipulating the phone Sergeant vent tresca believes fotus was cleaning up
00:21:22
the crime scene yeah didn't me especially cuz like it's like a pattern here here and then put Jennifer's dead
00:21:31
or unconscious body in the back of her suburban and drove it away and then her vehicle was left about 3 and2 miles away
00:21:39
down on lapam Road near Wy Park just 100 ft from where police say he had parked the Tacoma there's storm drains down
00:21:47
here investigators could not account for the next 40 minutes we search all all this whole area it's possible fotus used
00:21:55
that time to get rid of Jennifer's Body but they think it's more likely that he was transferring incriminating materials
00:22:03
from the Suburban to the Tacoma if he had things to move like a lot of bloody clothing could have taken 40 minutes
00:22:12
what happened to Jennifer they don't know what we do know is that the Tacoma returned to the empty house at 12:22
00:22:22
p.m. after that fotus met Michelle for lunch I don't you ask him where was that morning and that's because prosecutors
00:22:33
say she already knew that afternoon Michelle brought cleaning supplies and garbage bags to
00:22:42
that empty house for sale 80 Mountain Spring Road Michelle says she and fotus were preparing for a showing the next
00:22:51
day so what do you think was happening that afternoon at 0 mountain spring I think that the evidence that was found
00:23:00
in Harford was being bagged up the prosecution showed Michelle driving back and forth to the house
00:23:10
where she lived with photus prosecutors believe she was burning evidence and there appears to be smoke coming out of
00:23:18
the East chimney who's lighting a fire on Memorial Day Weekend better question who's lighting Three
00:23:27
Fires on the Friday before Memorial Day weekend on a day like that the surveillance shows her going back and
00:23:35
forth repeatedly 5 minutes at a time 9 Minutes at a time fire fire please state your name and spell it
00:23:48
for the record follow if the prosecution had a star witness it was fotus Employee
00:23:55
Pavo gumani who turns out to be the the owner of that red Tacoma good morning Mr
00:24:01
gini he described a conversation he had with Michelle a month before Jennifer went missing Michelle was upset when she
00:24:10
learned Jennifer would not let the children say goodbye to the family dog before photus had him put to sleep what
00:24:18
exactly did she say um can I use bad words yes she said DAV it should be buried right next to
00:24:27
this door but perhaps Pav's most damaging testimony concerned his pickup truck that Tacoma which he says fotus
00:24:36
took without permission he says he showed up at the house where Michelle and fotus were cleaning he wanted his
00:24:43
truck back but the keys were gone what did Mr D say to you he says that Michelle has a key Michelle had already
00:24:53
left the premises with the keys she takes the keys to the Toyota Tacoma to prevent Pavel from taking the car for
00:25:03
the weekend after all they need more time they haven't gone to the car wash yet Michelle returned with the keys and
00:25:11
Pavo took his truck home but 5 days after Jennifer disappeared fotus finally took the old beat up Tacoma to the car
00:25:20
wash Michelle met him there you can eat off the floorboards in this truck that's
00:25:25
how clean it was by the time we got it but photus made one major miscalculation he asked pavle to remove
00:25:32
the two front seats of the Tacoma and find replacements he was growing angry and
00:25:38
and and he keep on saying like you got to do it you you you can you do it pavl who
00:25:46
was later given immunity did remove the seeds but he handed them over to the police and sure enough on the passenger
00:25:56
seat there was a blood like stain on the the fabric of the seat and this general
00:26:01
error which was cut out tested at the lab and it came back to Jennifer dulos's DNA blood and that
00:26:07
was Paramount for this investigation they finally had enough evidence to arrest photus dulos for the murder of
00:26:14
his wife Michelle tronus was arrested for helping him plan the murder the two would never see or speak
00:26:23
to each other again what do you think is the most damaging evidence against Michelle
00:26:30
tronus for a closer look at the case go to 48 [Music] hours.com day after day Michelle sat in
00:26:43
the courtroom with her family behind her she showed little emotion other than a few tears let me
00:26:51
say something about not showing emotion if we Smile as we're coming into the court everything things she does
00:26:59
someone's going to comment on that Michelle out on bail left court quietly each day but her family was outspoken
00:27:08
she's a mother a daughter a sister and just an amazing human being and we know that the truth will prevail her father
00:27:16
cardiovascular surgeon Dr Carlos draconus and sisters Claudia and Daniela spoke to 48 hours in
00:27:24
2020 then as now they refused to believe that Michelle could have been involved in Jennifer's
00:27:32
disappearance what makes you believe that your sister had absolutely nothing to do with this how we were brought up
00:27:39
our principles just that she's never been a violent person she wouldn't harm anybody Sometimes women do ridiculous
00:27:48
things for love sister that's not Mich other women but not my sister Michelle will never harm anyone anyone Michelle's
00:27:54
Attorney John shorn says she was fooled by photus dulos photus dulos lied to Michelle it appears that he did on more
00:28:04
than one occasion according to Michelle fotus told her he believed his wife had run away something he claimed she had
00:28:12
done in the past I said what what do you mean that she disappeared and he said don't don't worry she started in the
00:28:21
past she went to atin and she changed her name 20 years ago tell you what shorn says photus was also lying to her
00:28:32
that night he was dumping bloody evidence on Albany Avenue in Harford and you're saying she had no idea what was
00:28:41
in those bags that photus was getting rid of she not only did not know what was in those bags she had no idea what
00:28:47
he was actually doing he had invited her to go out to Starbucks practically the entire time she's on either WhatsApp
00:28:55
texting or making phone calls during that whole time did you know it was in the bag no no in my mind it's always
00:29:01
like construction things even maybe I don't know the cleaning from the house I don't know like Claudia speaking on
00:29:07
behalf of her sister after the trial says it wasn't unusual for photos to dumb construction debris in public trash
00:29:16
cans instead of paying for a dumpster I had gone in 2018 and he had done it in my presentence so it was very common for
00:29:24
for him to do that but prosecutors portrayed that footage of Michelle leaning out of the truck as something
00:29:31
nefarious they told the jury she was purposely giving cover to fotus while he dumped two altered license plates down
00:29:39
the sewer while they opened the door at the exact same time conveniently at the right time to block the view from the
00:29:48
tan car Michelle says it was an innocent gesture but you're actually leaning out
00:29:54
at one point of the car no I told him I I mean I had a chewing G I took it I spit it I spit it okay and my hand got
00:30:04
sticky and I went like this and like this to c okay the state's case was built on speculation not facts
00:30:14
says shorn take that smoke rising from the fireplace she would have fires going in the fireplace all the time remember
00:30:22
my sister lived in Argentina before so it's very common to put the fireplace on and to just sit around have your wine
00:30:30
and my sister would do it and in fact says shorn the police brought in kadav dogs but they never found any trace of
00:30:38
evidence in the fireplace what was she burning in that fireplace firewood as for those missing keys to the Tacoma
00:30:47
Claudia says Michelle told her that the keys had been left out in the open sticking out of the door of the truck
00:30:55
culturally we don't trust we always always lock doors we always lock houses everything so she told me she took them
00:31:02
because of how we are that she's just not going to leave keys hanging from the door shorn says that not only is there
00:31:09
an innocent explanation for every one of the state's accusations but his client's
00:31:15
willingness to help speaks volumes about her involvement or lack of it she not only gave three interviews she walked
00:31:24
the police around the grounds near photos's house to help them look for Jennifer's Body we think you have
00:31:32
information I can walk the whole world with you you want do whatever you want but I didn't do if in fact your sister
00:31:41
knew where Jennifer's Body was wouldn't she have tried to make a deal with that information of course my sister is not
00:31:49
the person that the media has portrayed that the police and the state have wanted to portray my sister would have
00:31:55
said it she would have stood up in the and shorn says her good intentions to help police worked against her it was
00:32:04
Michelle's apparent contradictions in those three interviews that seemed to incriminate her at the time Michelle had
00:32:12
a different lawyer do you wish she had never talked to the police let let's put it this way I would
00:32:21
never have put my client in that situation when she was under arrest F this J with a shower with me remember in
00:32:29
the first interview she said she and votas took a shower together the morning Jennifer disappeared but she changed
00:32:36
that story in the second interview she told officers she didn't see photos at home that morning they say you told us
00:32:44
that you were in the house and woke up you took a shower with photus now you didn't take a shower with photus so this
00:32:49
is all going to come out and it makes you look like you're going tell me the truth this is how she later explained it
00:32:56
why did you tell us things that you knew or false okay I was in shock I was nervous police and the prosecution were
00:33:04
convinced Michelle had helped plan an alibi including that call Michelle picked up on photos's phone but Claudia
00:33:12
says there's an innocent explanation for that too it turns out that photos's friend attorney Kent mwin was at
00:33:21
photos's home office at 8:26 a.m. when photos's phone rang she was with Kent moeni in the office and Kent was
00:33:31
actually the one that signaled to her aren't you going to answer the phone so then she did but why didn't Michelle
00:33:37
mention that phone call to investigators she never mentioned that phone call in the first two interviews she never
00:33:44
mentions it until the third time why not was she trying to keep that from investigators no because again I don't
00:33:51
remember verbatim every single thing that I did so our memory can fool us and just because she didn't mention it
00:33:59
doesn't mean that she was hiding it shorn called to the stand a memory expert psychologist Elizabeth Loftus to
00:34:07
explain the changing stories people with a lot of Life stress are not going to be
00:34:14
their memory is not going to be operating optim optimally next he called via Marion a professor who specializes
00:34:22
in the relationship between language and memory she testified that Michelle who who you'll remember listened to the
00:34:29
trial in Spanish had only medium Proficiency in English does that play a role when you're asked to retrieve or
00:34:38
recite something that you had encoded in your memory it can after three days the
00:34:44
defense rested Michelle never took the stand it was time for the attorneys to present their closing arguments to the
00:34:53
jury in my mind I thought is there an innocent explanation cuz you want to get it right I don't want an innocent person
00:34:59
to go to jail go behind the scenes with the 48 Hours postmortem [Music] podcast when jury selection began in the
00:35:21
trial of Michelle tronus Jennifer Farber dulos have been missing for 1 , 594 days for Carri Lu the courtroom became a
00:35:35
place to pay homage to a friend whose absence has left an unbearable silence I was there to be a presence for
00:35:54
Jennifer after 6 weeks of testimony it was finally time for the attorneys to sum up their cases in a narrative a
00:36:03
story no longer than an hour their chance to put all the pieces together we met up with John shorn as he
00:36:12
put the finishing touches on his closing arguments I feel apprehensive but I feel
00:36:19
that we have a good shot the following morning Jennifer's five children now 17 15 and 13 and
00:36:29
living with their grandmother sat in the gallery as the closing arguments began all
00:36:36
right they wanted to support their mom they wanted to support their grandmother and they wanted to know what happened
00:36:44
are the parties ready to proceed yes sir prosecutor Michelle Manning was the first stop this trial is very simple
00:36:53
it's about a conspiracy and about a cover up it's about Michelle K's actions and about how she and photo dulos
00:37:00
conspired together to murder the woman who was standing in their way it is and I will say this multiple times
00:37:08
speculation it's conjecture it's guesswork which is not the standard of evidence in a criminal case here
00:37:18
prosecutor sha mcginness delivered a powerful finish using one simple word coincidence I want to just pose these
00:37:26
questions to you as you head into your deliberations is it really just a bunch of coincidences is it just a coincidence
00:37:34
that the defendant answered D's phone at for Jefferson Crossing when he was murdering his wife and mu canum is it
00:37:40
just a coincidence that D's phone is being moved and manipulated from one only the defendant is home is it just
00:37:46
the coincidence that the defendant travels with Duos to Harford as he disposes of the evidence on the same
00:37:52
day is it just a coincidence that the defendant Rock black garbage back S mountain and Jennifer Shir and braw were
00:37:58
found inside black trash bags for alternate jur Patrick who wanted us to only use his first name
00:38:06
mother being taken away from her children the prosecution's closing put weeks of testimony into perspective
00:38:14
where it all came together really was in closing arguments that's when it all made sense to me and really up to that
00:38:19
point I had entertained both sides of my head as an alternate juror Patrick was released before deliberation thank
00:38:29
you after a little more than two days the jury has reached their unanimous verdict the jury sent word to
00:38:37
the judge will the defendant please rise state of Connecticut versus Michelle tronis what say you Mr forers
00:38:47
guilty guilty guilty what did that feel like karing guilty well I held her arm arm and I
00:38:58
could just feel the energy leave her body everything was dead silent everything just stopped at that moment
00:39:08
yes and it was really stunning and I guess I mean that in the physical sense of being stunned and just
00:39:17
sort of hanging on every word Patrick says he agreed with the verdict including the most ser serous
00:39:28
charge conspiracy to commit murder what makes you believe that she helped plan it I think the totality of the evidence
00:39:38
not only what I thought she was deceptive in her interviews but even just absent of that the moving around of
00:39:44
vce's phone in the morning the answering the phone call covering for him even if
00:39:48
there was an explanation for it that certainly shows that you had some reason to do
00:39:54
that the chonus family spoke to the Press after the verdict and we continue standing here because we too care to
00:40:03
know the truth of what happened to Jennifer but we don't know what happened to Jennifer and choosing and putting my
00:40:11
sister as the guilty person is not the right thing to do because she's innocent thank
00:40:23
you for Jennifer Farber dulos's family and friends and it was the verdict they had hoped
00:40:32
for but it did little to ease the anguish they feel every day that she remains [Music]
00:40:40
missing and that's what's the most painful we don't know we don't know where she is do you think you ever
00:40:49
will I don't know we'd like to find her and bring her home if that doesn't happen doesn't
00:40:57
change our love for her she's in each of our hearts she's in our five children you see her face and
00:41:05
glorious so you know Jennifer's still here in so many ways but I think it would bring some
00:41:13
peace to be able to let her rest in peace [Music] an allout search by family friends and
00:41:37
police they said that there was no sign of her there's no sign of a struggle urgent please for help on Tik Tok my
00:41:42
sister is still missing who could have taken a loving mother away from her children people just don't vanish 48
00:41:48
hours Saturday on CBS streaming on Paramount Plus