Search Captions & Ask AI

The Plot to Kill Dr. Sievers | Full Episode

January 03, 2023 / 43:06

This episode covers the murder of Dr. Teresa Sievers, the investigation that followed, and the eventual arrests of suspects Jimmy Ray Rogers and Curtis Wayne Wright. Key discussions include the timeline of events leading to her death, the role of technology in solving the case, and the relationships between the individuals involved.

Dr. Teresa Sievers was found dead in her Bonita Springs, Florida home on June 29, 2015. She had been brutally attacked with a hammer, leading to a complex investigation that spanned over a thousand miles. Her husband, Mark Sievers, was initially cooperative with investigators but later became a person of interest.

As the investigation unfolded, it was revealed that Mark's close friend, Curtis Wayne Wright, and his associate, Jimmy Ray Rogers, were implicated in the murder. The case took a shocking turn when it was discovered that Wright had a history with Mark and had even attended his wedding.

Evidence gathered from GPS data and cell phone records pointed to the suspects' presence in Florida at the time of the murder. The episode highlights how digital footprints played a crucial role in solving the case, leading to the eventual arrests of both men.

The episode concludes with the trials of Wright and Rogers, where Wright testified against Mark Sievers, claiming he was involved in the planning of the murder. The outcome resulted in significant legal repercussions for all involved, particularly for Mark, who was sentenced to death.

TLDR

Dr. Teresa Sievers was murdered in her home, leading to a complex investigation and shocking arrests involving her husband’s close friend.

Episode

43:06
00:00:01
[Music] Clark welcome to honor roll rise the case starts on Monday June 29th 2015. hi I'm Dr Teresa Sievers Dr Teresa
00:00:27
Sievers was due at work and she didn't arrive Teresa Seavers is found on her kitchen
00:00:36
floor dead a pool of blood surrounds her head she is cold to the touch this is Dr Teresa Sievers high-profile
00:00:57
doctor did a lot of holistic medicine and people uh you know said that she was just a little Spitfire just a short
00:01:04
little thing and always wearing you know four inch heels clocking around so let's
00:01:09
get started we got a lot of stuff to talk about ladies remember walking into a room meant turning heads
00:01:17
when I got into work that day we were getting word that this 46 year old doctor was dead
00:01:23
this beloved woman in our community had been brutally killed inside her own house
00:01:32
Mark and Teresa have been a couple since 2003 when they got married in a Beachside ceremony in St Petersburg she
00:01:39
was sort of the breadwinner and he was the office manager at her practice and he helped raise the kids
00:01:46
they had a trip planned to New York and Teresa would fly home that Sunday night to be at work Monday morning
00:01:54
so on Sunday night she comes back here to the Southwest Florida International Airport she calls Mark tells him she's
00:02:00
safe and then gets in her car and heads back to their house 9-1-1 when is your emergency
00:02:08
I'm at a friend's house Mark had a friend come and check up on her he's out of town
00:02:14
he's been on the floor and there's hammer Hammer ride and she's bashed in the back of the head it will
00:02:20
later be determined that there are 17 impact wounds to her skull who would possibly want this feisty Florida doctor
00:02:29
dead that question LED investigators on a wild chase that ended more than a thousand miles away with a shocking
00:02:39
arrest of three people a break and the case came from all places from the state of Missouri
00:02:49
or electronic Footprints when you step outside your Home Folks you're always being observed
00:02:57
once you started to unwrap it a little bit it was nutty it was weird and it was hard to keep track of it all this is a
00:03:04
case in which 21st century technology became vital I've been told we have a verdict
00:03:13
foreign [Music] [Music] foreign foreign [Music] I think anytime there is a beautiful
00:04:07
successful woman who was murdered that's sort of what Society pays attention to For Better or For Worse
00:04:23
thank you when you first start on this case would you have ever imagined it would
00:04:32
end up to where it is right now no member of Dr Teresa Sievers in Bonita Springs Florida was a huge story
00:04:43
especially for Jessica Lipscomb who covered crime for the Naples Daily News to think of this mother of two who was
00:04:52
killed brutally inside her home was horrifying to people the doctor had cut short a family
00:04:58
vacation in Upstate New York and had flown home alone on Sunday night June 28 2015. so she could see patients the next
00:05:08
morning do you kind of put yourself in her shoes rolling your suitcase through the door
00:05:14
and then to be attacked by someone from behind it's [Applause] it's hard to imagine
00:05:22
investigators believe that as soon as Dr Sievers walked into her kitchen she was
00:05:27
killed struck repeatedly with a hammer the next morning her office staff got in it's now nine o'clock
00:05:37
now it's 905. now it's 9 15. I said where's doctor Sandra Hoskins was Teresa seaver's
00:05:46
longtime medical assistant I was texting back and forth trying to see if you know where he at and no
00:05:55
response called no answer marks out of town he says I can't get a hold of her either how unusual was it for Dr severs
00:06:05
not to show up even if it was nine o'clock and three seconds after you would hear her heels coming in
00:06:15
it was just so unbelievable when Connie Reese heard the tragic news she contacted her stepbrother Mark sivers
00:06:24
the doctor's husband how did he react to the death of his wife he couldn't speak
00:06:31
he's not the kind of guy that has been a really emotional on the outside but he couldn't speak
00:06:39
Connie and Mark became family when her mother married his father I asked him what happened to Teresa and
00:06:48
what did he say no idea Mark met his future wife in 2003 when he was visiting Saint Petersburg Florida
00:07:00
pretty much love at first sight well I think by the time that he introduced her to mom I think he was pretty much done
00:07:09
he was off the market officially yeah really he was working as a nurse while she was a recently divorced physician
00:07:18
Teresa hung the moon she was a remarkable human being and very special and that's the way Mark treated it from
00:07:25
the beginning it just you could hear it in his voice they were married on the beach
00:07:30
surrounded by friends and family including stepmother Jenny weckelman was a sunset wedding and she had a
00:07:38
beautiful gown it was very nice was he happy on that day oh my gosh he was very happy
00:07:47
six months later their first daughter was born the Seavers built a large house in Bonita Springs and in 2007 welcomed
00:07:57
another daughter how did Mark feel about being a dad it was everything to him they were his
00:08:04
reason for being but he was also all about Teresa and her mission we talk about our physical health mental
00:08:12
health that mission was to open a holistic practice where she could heal patients by blending traditional and
00:08:20
alternative medicine she also spread her message in speeches and videos there's our spiritual and energetic Health we
00:08:28
would have patients from all over the world they would come to us after they failed everything else
00:08:34
she wouldn't take no for an answer talking about the doctor still makes Sandra emotional
00:08:43
and as a patient she wouldn't allow you to say I'm never going to get better while patients love the doctor Sandra
00:08:52
and her husband Frank pays who also worked at the practice admit it wasn't always easy working for Sievers she had
00:09:01
a short fuse I would hear Dr screaming and yelling in back office Dr severs would yell at the
00:09:08
Patients she was there to help you get better didn't have what they call the bedside manner would she yell at you
00:09:16
yes yeah a wrist is a problem she expected Perfection and if it wasn't perfect she would get upset because I need to
00:09:26
maintain my mental sharpness she was a big presence and sometimes that meant that she got really feisty with people
00:09:34
she was the biggest figure in the room while Teresa took care of her patients Mark managed her office and took care of
00:09:43
their daughters the girls were his pride and joy and according to her sister Annie Lisa Teresa was equally devoted to
00:09:52
Mark Theresa always said I'll never leave Mark and we'll ever do it to my girls nevertheless within weeks Mark sivers
00:10:00
became a person of interest did he cooperate initially oh yes I think he thought he was doing the right thing
00:10:08
Mark spoke to investigators without a lawyer present and even handed over his cell phone and allowed them to download
00:10:16
the contents was he worried he might be arrested he thought why would they what kind of evidence could they
00:10:24
possibly have because I didn't do anything in fact Mark sivers had an airtight alibi
00:10:31
at the time of Teresa's murder he and their two girls were with Teresa's family hundreds of miles away in New
00:10:39
York foreign [Music] was murdered friends and family came together for her funeral including
00:11:12
Mark's stepmother Jenny wackelman there were a lot of people yes yeah and and it
00:11:17
was sad of course almost all her patients were there I was numb Mark Sievers reportedly had a gun
00:11:27
strapped to his waist at his wife's funeral strange well perhaps but her killer hadn't yet been arrested and
00:11:35
according to stepsister Connie Reese Mark was on edge he was very much in protective mode when you say protective
00:11:43
mode what do you mean well I think you know he always keeps an eye in the ear to the ground so to speak and is aware
00:11:51
of his surroundings and you know he he was concerned for their their safety I think it was in the back
00:11:58
of his mind that that there might be some danger to his daughters because of what happened to their mother
00:12:03
it just didn't make any sense who would want the vibrant and dedicated Dr Theresa siever's dead and white killer
00:12:12
with such anger and force could have been anybody I really thought maybe it was just somebody that
00:12:21
was in the area and broken or something there were signs of a forced entry primarks on a side door but Mark's
00:12:30
extensive gun collection and forty thousand dollars in cash discovered inside the Seavers home hadn't been
00:12:37
touched so when this happened everyone wanted to know what happened with the alarm and as
00:12:44
it turns out it hadn't been activated while the family was on vacation Market asked his mother Bonnie Sievers to feed
00:12:52
the family pets she had trouble setting the alarm that Sunday and told detectives her son Mark said not to
00:12:59
worry about it Monday morning Dr severs was discovered dead on her kitchen floor
00:13:08
[Music] this is Mark's mother speaking to investigators so I really feel that it's my fault but
00:13:16
you can't you cannot blame yourself [Music] around the time of Dr seaver's murder
00:13:26
the internet was buzzing with reports about The suspicious deaths of other alternative doctors in the U.S
00:13:34
did Mark think that her death might be connected with that yes yes he did but with no real evidence to make that
00:13:41
connection investigators turned their attention to the people who might have had an ax to
00:13:46
Grime with the energetic often abrasive Dr Sievers I think the theory that I heard was that maybe it was a patient
00:13:55
obviously they were interviewing all of her friends and family members so it was pretty much like a wide open
00:14:01
field of suspects at that point then a surprising name emerged in her police interview Dr seaver's sister
00:14:09
Annie Lisa said she heard Sandra Hoskins was a disgruntled employee that's the same Sandra who seemed so upset by Dr
00:14:20
Sever's death but you may not like your boss but you don't bad-mouth them to patients that
00:14:26
are coming in the doors like Dr Sievers you know she's in the phone she's a well I'm like oh my God they think I did
00:14:33
it Sandra who claims she had been treated harshly by Dr severs in the past had planned to hand in a resignation
00:14:40
that very Monday the doctor was found dead according to Sandra the doctor told her she was bringing bad energy to the
00:14:49
office now I know why I was not received very well at her Memorial why would anyone think that you did this
00:15:00
that is shocking to me a lot of the patients did know the way she treated me and so people thought maybe you just
00:15:08
had enough yeah Sandra Hoskins was cleared when nearly two months after Dr severs was murdered
00:15:16
there was a stunning break in the case police made arrests and the suspects were not from Florida
00:15:28
so we showed up to a press conference I believe that August and the sheriff gets up there and tells us
00:15:36
simply the name of the first suspect Jimmy Rogers and he says he's from Missouri and he's
00:15:43
been booked for the murder of Teresa Sievers never heard of him because I thought oh well who is he and
00:15:50
what's he got to do with this and then about an hour later he calls us in again and says we've now picked up a second
00:15:55
suspect Curtis Wayne Wright also from Missouri it was so shocking to solve this murder investigators would
00:16:05
Travel More Than A Thousand Miles and they were in for a wild ride they would soon discover this case had as many
00:16:14
twists and turns as the Missouri River foreign [Music] hours will continue [Music]
00:16:46
Teresa Sievers was bludgeoned to death with a hammer neighbors are still waiting for answers said to my husband
00:16:53
today the two arrests for Teresa siever's murder made 1100 miles away in Missouri
00:17:00
seemed to come out of the blue Mark's stepmother Jenny weckelman why you know what's going on just seemed like such a
00:17:08
disconnect no one had ever heard of the suspect Jimmy Ray Rogers but it was the mug shot of the other suspect Wayne
00:17:16
Wright that struck everyone he had an uncanny resemblance to the victim's husband Mark Sievers they look alike
00:17:24
yeah at least in pictures they look like twins and that's and that's that's when
00:17:30
I've started to believe you know that definitely there is not something right with with Curtis Swain right
00:17:39
as it turns out Curtis Wayne Wright he goes by Wayne was no stranger to Mark's family it was Mark's very good friends
00:17:48
and ages and ages so I didn't believe it I didn't it just didn't make sense Wayne
00:17:56
and Mark had grown up together in Missouri Wayne was a Teresa's funeral he had celebrated Mark and Teresa's wedding
00:18:04
with them and just two months before the murder Mark had been Wayne's best man at
00:18:10
his wedding Wayne was also a familiar face around the office did you two know Wayne Wright how did
00:18:19
you know him hey who's the computer guy that was just like Mark Wayne would travel from Missouri to Florida to work
00:18:26
on the computers in Dr seaver's office how would you describe Wayne he was geeky all he wanted to do was get the
00:18:33
computers up and running Focus but to me he just seemed like a very geeky creepster did he make you nervous a
00:18:42
little bit I can't explain it it's just a woman's intuition how would you describe Mark and Wayne's relationship
00:18:49
they appear to be close friends yeah he always say he's my brother from another mother yeah that was his lingo
00:18:58
back in Hillsboro Missouri Greg Bolin knew both Mark and Wayne when they both had hair this here is Hillsboro
00:19:06
Elementary School this is where me and Wayne met for the very first time in third grade
00:19:12
and remembers his high school classmate Wayne as a tech whiz the kid voted most dependable and as a fun guy to hang
00:19:20
around with he actually ran for and became our class president smart very smart quite honestly he was one of the
00:19:28
smartest people with computers that I ever met but it wasn't long before Greg suspected Wayne Wright had a dark side
00:19:37
in 1996 Greg's brother Ronnie Bolin a preacher mysteriously disappeared his body has never been found and according
00:19:47
to police Ronnie was last seen with Wayne do you believe Wainwright killed your brother yes I do you have no
00:19:56
question about that I have no doubt in my mind Greg believes the motive was money that
00:20:03
Wayne owed Ronnie reporter Jessica Lipscomb they found his car with the car keys still in the ignition in a car wash
00:20:10
in St Louis Wayne has never been charged in Ronnie's disappearance but he is listed in a police report as a person of
00:20:19
interest and Wayne's no stranger to the criminal justice system in 2011 he was serving time for drug possession
00:20:28
when he befriended the other suspect and Dr Sever's murder a young inmate named Jimmy Ray Rogers who was doing time on a
00:20:38
weapons charge you can just tell he needed a job he wanted a job you know Jimmy was released from jail I'll show
00:20:45
you Tyler Juliet and Jeff Conway hired him to work at a Contracting Company he liked to tell a lot of stories a lot of
00:20:54
things he told at the time nobody really believed Jimmy he liked to brag a little
00:20:58
bit about the things he had done in the past a colorful criminal past he says Jimmy would brag about con jobs ranging
00:21:06
from stolen merchandise to counterfeit money I never felt Jimmy was dangerous guy I
00:21:13
just felt like he was blow hard honestly you know I really felt like he was just
00:21:16
a talker come recalls that he had asked Jimmy to work on Monday June 29th but Jimmy texted him back and said he
00:21:25
wasn't available all it said was I can't do that I'm still in Florida it was on June 29th the Dr Teresa
00:21:35
Sievers was discovered bludgeoned to death with a hammer inside her Florida home
00:21:43
and it didn't go unnoticed to investigators that Jimmy Ray Rogers had a unique nickname supposedly Jimmy
00:21:51
Rogers nickname was the hammer but I think that was more of like a self-given nickname if you talk to some of his
00:21:57
friends from high school they say nobody really called him that but I think maybe
00:22:01
going to jail for the first time you know trying to make a name for himself maybe that's something he sort of
00:22:08
assigned himself to fit in why was Jimmy the hammer Rogers in Florida that fateful weekend was Wainwright with him
00:22:17
and what led authorities to believe they were involved in a doctor's murder why would Wayne try to look like Mark
00:22:27
see more evidence from the case on Facebook at 48 hours tonight's 48 hours will continue
00:22:51
back in June 2015 practically everyone in Hillsboro Missouri knew that Wainwright was planning a weekend trip
00:22:59
out of town he let it slip to lots of people that he was going down to Florida told some
00:23:05
people he was even going to visit the seabirds and it wasn't long before police got a tip that Wayne had been in
00:23:12
Florida at the time of Dr Sever's murder and he hadn't gone there alone he went with his jailhouse pal Jimmy the hammer
00:23:21
Rogers Jimmy's boss Jeff Conway he told me a story that his brother had graduated
00:23:28
from law school and that he had invited Jimmy down to Florida for the weekend all expenses paid
00:23:36
but he told his pregnant girlfriend Taylor's showmaker another story he was going out of town for a few days to work
00:23:44
with Wayne he had told her that he was going down to Florida to make some money weeks after Jimmy and Wayne returned
00:23:51
detectives from Florida showed up in Hillsboro Missouri they confronted Wayne about that tip placing him in Florida
00:23:59
but he refused to talk he didn't need to a rental car GPS gave the cops what they
00:24:06
needed to know on the morning of June 27 2015 Wainwright got into a rental car here in
00:24:16
Hillsboro Missouri and then went to pick up Jimmy Ray Rogers at some point this address was put into the GPS and then
00:24:23
the two men took off for the 1100 mile ride to Bonita Springs Florida after driving all day and all night on
00:24:33
Sunday June 28th Wayne and Jimmy arrived at the Sievers home the Bonita Springs address it's all right there in the GPS
00:24:42
a digital footprint for investigators when Jimmy and Wayne arrived around 6 a.m authorities believe they turned off
00:24:53
the house alarm that may explain why Mark's mother Bonnie was so confused about the alarm system
00:25:01
I was not there at 609 in the morning he was 10 for 609 that's what we're trying to work oh my
00:25:08
God then according to the GPS Jimmy and Wayne left the Sievers home and typed in
00:25:15
another address for a Walmart to do some shopping obviously looking at that security
00:25:22
footage from the Walmart they're able to pretty quickly determine that that's who
00:25:25
who was with Wayne they made no effort to cover their faces disguise themselves they just Waltz
00:25:32
through like they were anyone else they bought among other things trash bags flushable wet wipes black towels
00:25:40
black shoes and a lock picking kit they paid cash for their purchase with a hundred dollar bill after shopping at
00:25:49
Walmart Jimmy and Wayne continued using the navigation system even to find the beach and soak up some sun
00:25:58
does it make any sense that this guy who was so good with computers would have left such a trail it does but it doesn't
00:26:07
uh to a lot of people looking at it it kind of makes it look like you know these guys were just dumb and dumber but
00:26:17
that's a lot of how he operated after their beach trip according to police affidavits Wayne and Jimmy returned to
00:26:25
the Sievers home where they hung out for hours in the garage waiting for an unsuspecting Dr sivers to
00:26:33
arrive in the early morning hours of Monday June 29th the GPS again shows Jimmy and
00:26:40
Wayne on the highway headed Northbound for the 17-hour drive back to Missouri the electronic Trail would eventually
00:26:49
lead detectives to Jimmy Ray Rogers door but like Wayne he denied he had anything
00:26:55
to do with the murder but when police brought in Jimmy's girlfriend Taylor's showmaker during the sort of told truth
00:27:02
the whole truth and nothing but the truth correct yes what a story she had to tell
00:27:09
Jimmy Ray Rogers took his girlfriend Taylor for a ride right along here Route 47 in rural Missouri
00:27:15
[Applause] and along this road he asked her to throw out parts of his cell phone which
00:27:21
he had smashed earlier some gloves and a jumpsuit he said throw this in the river and it
00:27:31
took me a minute to cook in and then I threw a little gloves out and then I threw out the toes
00:27:39
did you ask why or you just did it well I just did it I was scared Taylor told police that's when she
00:27:46
pushed Jimmy to tell her exactly what happened in Florida and he told me about using a hammer on her
00:27:56
okay and he said that he killed Teresa Seaver Mark's wife yes with a hammer yes Florida detectives now thought they knew
00:28:06
who killed Teresa Sievers but they still didn't know the why why would Wayne Wright want to kill his best friend's
00:28:14
wife did everyone then say oh my gosh Mark had to be involved definitely I mean there was really no putting Wayne in
00:28:25
Florida in Bonita Springs inside their house without Mark knowing about it did it occur to either one of you that
00:28:35
Mark might be involved no not even a thought in the back of your mind no no absolutely not
00:28:43
but when investigators downloaded Mark's cell phone they discovered the Sievers marriage was more troubled than anyone
00:28:51
guessed despite having forty thousand dollars in cash around the house they had serious financial problems and when
00:28:59
investigators discovered five insurance policies on Teresa totally more than four million dollars it was a big red
00:29:08
flag foreign had told police that Teresa's death was a murder for hire and that Jimmy was
00:29:20
supposed to be paid ten thousand dollars and then asked him how to make money and
00:29:27
it was murdering Mark's life he said that Mark hired Wayne yes and Wayne hired him Mark didn't know anything
00:29:36
about Jimmy being hired where's the money supposed to come from insurance from her death okay and did you ever get
00:29:43
paid no then almost eight months after Teresa siever's murder Wayne Wright Marx look-alike best friend suddenly turned
00:29:54
on him and took a deal Mr Wright why are you pleading guilty today to second-degree murder
00:30:06
Wainwright admitted killing Teresa I'm I'm pleading guilty because of my role in the planning and participating of the
00:30:15
murders tree receivers he said the murder was all Mark's idea and that's what police needed
00:30:25
Mark did you hire Wayne Wright to kill your wife Mark Sievers was charged with the murder of his wife did you hire
00:30:32
anyone to kill your wife but siever's stepsister says he would never risk losing his children she believes Wayne
00:30:40
Wright had long envied his best friend's life and he's the one who killed Teresa
00:30:45
on his own why would Wayne kill Teresa because he's a sick man do you think Wayne was jealous of Mark
00:30:54
I think it's possible whether he's jealous of Mark or wanted to be Mark I don't I don't have any clue family and
00:31:02
friends point to how Wayne Wright began to model himself after Sievers even shaving his own head when Sievers
00:31:10
started to go bald Greg Bolin they didn't look alike when we were younger how much they they morphed into each
00:31:19
other over the years thank you if it was by chance or by their plan I don't know
00:31:27
[Music] more than four years after Curtis Wainwright cut that deal to testify against Mark sivers and ex-con Jimmy
00:31:37
Rogers the two men go on trial but separately Roger's case went first October 2019.
00:31:47
Teresa siever's mother and siblings were in the courtroom this case was about the perfect marriage
00:31:56
the perfect friendship the perfect alibi the perfect murder assistant State Attorney Hameed Hunter
00:32:06
told the jury that Teresa siever's death was a classic case of murder For Hire Mark Sievers was miles away while Curtis
00:32:16
Wayne Wright and Jimmy Ray Rogers killed his wife Mr Wright hit her with the hammer
00:32:23
hit her again [Music] Mr Rogers came out of nowhere Mr Rogers engages with his hammer and he starts
00:32:33
hitting her hitting her hitting her Rogers defense attorney Kathleen fitzgeorge what you heard from the state
00:32:41
attorney is what they believe or expect or hope the evidence will show but it's a bumpy road because they
00:32:51
haven't told you everything foreign [Music] [Music] State actually believes Teresa Sievers
00:33:16
was killed with two hammers but only one was discovered on the siever's kitchen floor they showed the jury that weapon
00:33:24
and the damaging video evidence of the two men near the crime scene is this how you found this jumpsuit when
00:33:35
you took it into your custody on the side of the road in Cadet Missouri yes a fiber from the jumpsuit worn by Rogers
00:33:43
was found on Teresa's body [Music] this time the state calls Taylor showmaker Roger's former girlfriend Taylor
00:33:56
showmaker appeared shaken when she entered the courtroom she identified that blue jumpsuit
00:34:04
says jumpsuit and told the jury Rogers confessed to her and then asked them how well how and
00:34:13
he said with a hammer then the state called their star Witness State calls Curtis right in exchange for
00:34:24
his testimony at both trials Wright was allowed to plead guilty to second-degree
00:34:30
murder and will spend 25 years in prison Mr Wright who killed Dr Teresa Sievers uh
00:34:39
I did Jimmy Rogers how many times did you hit Dr Seavers with that hammer and three Mr Rogers came from somewhere and
00:34:48
he started hitting her what did he do just just started hitting her over and over how would you describe how I was
00:34:56
hitting her and a frenzy [Music] Rogers did not testify and his attorney Donald McFarland called No Witnesses but
00:35:08
told jurors they should not believe Curtis Wayne Wright Curtis Wright's the only one who ever hit that woman
00:35:16
and he's lying to you to save his own worthless skin Jimmy didn't have a hammer the jury was out nearly two days and
00:35:26
then I've been told we have a verdict is the state ready the defendant is guilty of second-degree
00:35:33
murder Rogers showed no emotion he was sentenced to life in prison and then in November 2019 Mark Sievers
00:35:47
went on trial for the murder of his wife he spent much of the prior three years in jail still denying he had any
00:35:55
involvement and his family was still behind him just haven't seen any evidence that makes any sense as far as Mark
00:36:05
being involved both his stepmother Jenny and stepsister Connie vowed to support him through the
00:36:12
trial I will do everything that I can to be there are you nervous about it yeah yeah please be seated Mark Sievers
00:36:25
charged with first-degree murder of his wife appeared unfazed even though he faced the death penalty the same
00:36:33
prosecutors who tried Jimmy Rogers will use much of the same evidence in front of a different jury this is in case case
00:36:41
in which 21st century technology became vital cell towers cell tower dumps call detail records that allowed massive
00:36:51
amounts of data to be sorted organized and searched but siever's defense attorney Michael Mummert says
00:37:01
all that evidence only points to Curtis Wright and Jimmy Rogers as The Killers heard of swings that hammer
00:37:11
right on the side of the head followed by another one across the bridge of the nose
00:37:19
Curtis says I struck Teresa three times in the head with a hammer but Jimmy did the rest
00:37:31
testifying again is Jimmy Rogers former girlfriend Taylor showmaker now with a new look she says her ex was promised a
00:37:40
Payday but she can't connect Sievers to it and did he tell you how much money he
00:37:46
expected to be making from this yes and what did he tell you I think it was ten thousand
00:37:54
the case again comes down to that star witness Curtis Wayne Wright who will now come face to face with his mirror image
00:38:03
and once closest friend [Music] Mr Wright who killed Dr Teresa Sievers hi Jimmy Rogers and I physically did it
00:38:17
at uh Mark Sievers was also involved in the planning for several hours Wright testified against Sievers the man he
00:38:25
affectionately called his brother from another mother why did you do it [Music] um I was asked to do it
00:38:35
bye home Mr Sievers Wright told the jury that Sievers and his wife were having marital and money
00:38:45
problems and that Sievers believe Teresa was planning to leave him and take the kids
00:38:51
the only option that he had was for her to die and he said that he needed to have her
00:38:57
killed when the judge asked Mark Sievers if he wanted to testify okay foreign this time the jury was out just four
00:39:11
hours the families gathered in the court for the verdict the jury find as follows as to the
00:39:18
defendant in this case count one first degree murder the defendant is guilty of first-degree murder
00:39:26
first began to cry in addition to the guilty verdict the jury asked the judge to sentence Sievers to death
00:39:37
[Music] this is how former employee Frank pays felt before the trial what should happen
00:39:45
to Mark sivers he's facing the death penalty I I think the death penalty is the easy way out
00:39:53
think the the pain and torture that he deserves is to sit in jail to the rest of his life
00:40:03
thinking about his true pride and joy daughters that should be his punishment [Music]
00:40:13
on January 3rd 2020 Mark Sievers now a convicted killer returned to court to find out if he will get life in prison
00:40:22
or be sentenced to death is it okay if I refer to my notes yes sir absolutely this time he agreed to speak to plead
00:40:33
for his life although a jury found me guilty and innocent of all charges as I've
00:40:39
maintained since his heinous crime took place our girls have tragically lost their
00:40:49
mommy and now they're about to lose their daddy as well it didn't long for the judge to rule I judge uh
00:40:59
people's actions I don't judge people's Souls that's for somebody else to do sir I'm going to go ahead and adjudicate
00:41:06
to guilty on each count on the first count first degree murder and it's the order of the court that you be sentenced
00:41:12
to death sir [Music] for Teresa's family it's the end of an agonizing nearly five-year wait for
00:41:23
justice this has been an incredible nightmare from the beginning Teresa took down three guys
00:41:34
it took her from us he was my Modern Day Mother Teresa I always call her that [Music]
00:41:45
because she always was trying to help people our Focus now you should go on to take care take care
00:41:56
of the girls and uh give them the love and support that they need and we're glad
00:42:04
that it's over justice has been served [Music] the Sievers children are being raised by
00:42:20
Teresa's family [Music] the judge denied Mark siever's request for a new trial there's some questions that have to be
00:42:31
asked and need to be answered you're rolling okay this is the building let's move quickly Peter Van Sant with CBS
00:42:36
News here we go do it you flunked a polygraph test I'm innocent do you still believe in your husband's innocence did
00:42:43
you murder Yvonne bald eagle what do you have to say to that do you believe that
00:42:47
no I don't why didn't you help the police why did you buy that Sledgehammer we're going to
00:42:52
do some Home Improvement or were you buying a murder weapon foreign [Music]

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 85
    Biggest twist
  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 80
    Most unpredictable
  • 75
    Most heartbreaking

Episode Highlights

  • The Murder of Dr. Teresa Sievers
    Dr. Teresa Sievers was found brutally murdered in her home, shocking the community.
    “This beloved woman in our community had been brutally killed inside her own house.”
    @ 01m 25s
    January 03, 2023
  • A Shocking Arrest
    Investigators made a shocking arrest more than a thousand miles away from the crime scene.
    “To solve this murder, investigators would travel more than a thousand miles.”
    @ 16m 08s
    January 03, 2023
  • The Connection to Missouri
    The suspects in Dr. Sievers' murder were linked to Missouri, raising questions about their motives.
    “The mug shot of the other suspect struck everyone; he had an uncanny resemblance to Mark Sievers.”
    @ 17m 19s
    January 03, 2023
  • The Perfect Murder
    The case revolves around the perfect marriage, friendship, and ultimately, the perfect murder.
    “This case was about the perfect marriage, the perfect friendship, the perfect murder.”
    @ 31m 56s
    January 03, 2023
  • Mark Sievers Found Guilty
    Mark Sievers was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death.
    “The defendant is guilty of first-degree murder.”
    @ 39m 24s
    January 03, 2023
  • Justice Served
    After a long wait, Teresa's family finally sees justice as Mark Sievers is sentenced.
    “Justice has been served.”
    @ 42m 08s
    January 03, 2023

Episode Quotes

  • Who would possibly want this feisty Florida doctor dead?
    The Plot to Kill Dr. Sievers | Full Episode
  • She wouldn't take no for an answer.
    The Plot to Kill Dr. Sievers | Full Episode
  • It just didn't make any sense who would want the vibrant Dr. Theresa Sievers dead?
    The Plot to Kill Dr. Sievers | Full Episode
  • I just did it, I was scared.
    The Plot to Kill Dr. Sievers | Full Episode
  • This has been an incredible nightmare from the beginning.
    The Plot to Kill Dr. Sievers | Full Episode
  • He was my Modern Day Mother Teresa.
    The Plot to Kill Dr. Sievers | Full Episode

Key Moments

  • Community Shock01:25
  • Protective Mode11:41
  • Digital Footprint24:47
  • Shopping Spree25:40
  • Confession27:41
  • Trial Begins31:41
  • Guilty Verdict35:33
  • Sentencing41:12

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown