
This episode covers the 1984 disappearance of Janelle Matthews in Greeley, Colorado, featuring family accounts and details of the investigation.
Janelle Matthews went missing just five days before Christmas. Family members recount the events leading up to her disappearance, including her father's routine of ensuring she made it home safely after a choir concert.
Her father discovered she was missing when he returned home after a basketball game. He recalls calling out for her and finding no response. The family had a note from Janelle, but it was only a phone message she had taken for her father.
Footprints in the snow outside the home were the only physical evidence found, with indications that someone attempted to cover their tracks using a garden rake.
Janelle's mother was out of town during the incident and received the shocking news from her husband about their daughter's disappearance, leading to widespread concern and searches for Janelle.
The episode recounts the mysterious 1984 disappearance of Janelle Matthews in Greeley, Colorado, and the family's search for answers.

This episode stands out for the following:
She just loves the whole festivities of Christmas.What happened the night 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews disappeared?
I just had a sick feeling to my stomach.What happened the night 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews disappeared?