00:00:00
real people real crimes real life drama [Music] Brian brimminger was a typical Marine
00:00:13
[Music] [Applause] that kind of an All-American kind of persona he was assigned to a color guard in
00:00:22
Washington DC [Music] there's pictures of him in the white house with President George W bush
00:00:29
from the outside looking in it seemed like Brian brimminger had everything going for him
00:00:36
in 2011 after having served seven years in the Marine Corps Brian brimminger leaves the Marines that he decides to go
00:00:43
to Panama and his plan is to decompress take some time off my sister was deeply in love with the
00:00:57
man the man Brian brimmager all she wanted was to be with him and love him they were so madly in love I
00:01:03
think she was very proud of him because he was a marine she used to say things like I'm with a Marine
00:01:10
Yvonne went down to Panama with Bryant to start a new life that's where Yvonne wanted to be
00:01:18
I am Michelle Valenzuela and my sister is Yvonne baldelli she likes a karaoke she likes to dance
00:01:25
did Yvonne like it here she loved it here just love it here places with cheap beers and happy hour
00:01:33
it's beautiful she's got the water right in front of her house where are we right
00:01:38
now okay we're on Isla carenero in Boca Del Toro this is the the house they were
00:01:43
renting in Brian bermanger and Yvonne baldelli Yvonne told her family members that
00:01:51
everything was good she painted a very happy picture through email she made it seem like everything was fine and well
00:01:58
the reality of it was that her and birminger were fighting constantly after I'd heard stories of the fights I
00:02:07
could understand why she would want to leave she fell off the radar screen she just
00:02:12
went away one day her email stopped her Communications stopped everybody lost contact with her there's no immigration
00:02:19
records it indicates that she left Panama there's no book for this there's no book for dummies on what to do when
00:02:24
your sister has gone missing Karen Arrow from the outside appears to be a Tropical Paradise but it's a swampy Hill
00:02:33
I call it Devil's Island because some Terrible Things took place on that island brand brimmager has done nothing
00:02:43
zero to help with the search for Yvonne we are in Central America in some jungle in
00:02:53
some swamp looking for Yvonne exactly the middle is really deep this is unbelievable
00:03:01
what no one knew is that Brian breminger had a secret he was living a double life
00:03:07
Brian brimminger moved to California hooked up with Christian workhoven and they got married Kristen worked at the
00:03:14
White House and that's where she and Brian met and his life is going on like normal
00:03:22
and her life will never be the same what did you do to her Brian we knew that there had been Foul Play we
00:03:30
knew he was the last one to see her alive Brian's coming out with his golf clubs let's go guys and this is what I
00:03:37
know okay you're rolling let's go my sister went down to Panama O'Brien Brian returned and my sister didn't Brian
00:03:44
brimage was exceptionally arrogant but what he didn't account for was this family's fervor to find what happened to
00:03:51
their daughter and their sister Brian Peter Van Sant with CBS News we'd like to ask a couple questions
00:04:00
it's an easy thing to tell the truth he told a lot of lies that's what led to his demise
00:04:17
Peter Van Sant tonight on 48 hours Devil's Island [Music] [Applause] 48 hours we'll be back in 90 seconds
00:04:44
[Music] in the spring of 2012 Brian bremager was living the high life in Southern
00:05:00
California just months removed from a decorated Marine Corps career breminger was happily married and living in the
00:05:08
suburbs when I look at the pictures of Brian and Kristen I just see a couple in love and and
00:05:16
super sincerely happy and just enjoying the day at the beach in La Jolla these joyful newlywed photos of Brian and
00:05:24
Kristen breminger were a shock to Yvonne baldelli's family they expected her to be in the picture it wasn't their
00:05:32
wedding day but they came in their wedding attire in a limousine and champagne flowing
00:05:37
photographer Jack English had no idea of the Intrigue Behind These happy images that Brian had proposed to Kristen just
00:05:47
days after Yvonne disappeared in Panama she looked very happy very in love as if
00:05:54
she found her prince charming Prince Charming a man who had just left Yvonne baldelli in Panama two weeks
00:06:01
earlier how could this happen we traveled to the remote islands of the Caribbean coast of Panama to find out
00:06:12
up ahead is the island of carinaro where Yvonne and Brian who the locals called brim came to live in September 2011.
00:06:21
it's a place where they could chase their dream [Music] why did they decide to go to Panama she
00:06:32
liked the fact that they could live on the beach you know you know it was pretty pretty reasonably priced down
00:06:36
there Yvonne's sister Michelle Valenzuela says Brian wanted to become a singer performing in bars and clubs
00:06:45
with her beloved dog Georgia May in hand Yvonne brought two sewing machines in hopes of starting a clothing business
00:06:54
stepmother Lillian fost she was going to make bathing suits and sell them to tourists I knew she was excited and she
00:07:02
she didn't have any reservations it sounded like she had a real plan for the future
00:07:07
she did and she thought that she found her Paradise her perfect place Michelle recalls how her younger sister
00:07:16
Yvonne recently divorced was smitten with Brian when they first started dating in 2009 in Southern California
00:07:24
and think she was physically attracted to him that was a big part of it and while Yvonne seemed to be falling in
00:07:31
love with Brian big sister Michelle wasn't so sure as far as emotionally from my Sister Yvonne would
00:07:40
put 100 into you and she would expect that back and I didn't get that impression that she was receiving that
00:07:46
that concerned me she deserved that after Yvonne was laid off from her management job with Procter and Gamble
00:07:54
and Brian ended his career in the Marines the two decided to make a fresh start and reinvent themselves in Panama
00:08:02
settling in this house they quickly fell in with the local expats did you think they were in love
00:08:11
apparently it seems so Joan and Stephen Crabtree own the cosmic crab a funky Resort and Waterfront Bar where Brian
00:08:20
would sing for his supper he played here at the cosmic crab um a couple of nights a week and they
00:08:27
were frequent visitors here they were very nice people Penny Tom owner of another Waterfront Bar also let Brian
00:08:35
play for food and free booze lots of booze they used to drink a lot so they were always happy what's a lot
00:08:44
a lot and Jim Merton says Brian's drinking may have gotten in the way of his singing
00:08:52
he played a guitar good but when he started to sing that's when it went away what was it like
00:08:58
um like a hound dog on a porch she looked very happy in the pictures and she was really enjoying herself
00:09:05
there and I knew it would be a place that she would like for Yvonne's Father Jim Faust the constant stream of Joyful
00:09:12
phone calls and emails describing the couple's Panama Adventures was reassuring Yvonne's emails were stories
00:09:20
of exactly what her life was like down there and I could picture it and I could close my eyes and it was like I was
00:09:25
there I couldn't imagine the whole thing emails like this one she says hi sis Brian already working at local
00:09:33
restaurants and bars we love it we wake up and go running then swim in the ocean
00:09:37
every morning and so Yvonne's family thought all was well in paradise and that Brian might be
00:09:46
the one for Yvonne I believed that they were going to get married that's what I thought was going to happen when they
00:09:51
got down there but then right around Thanksgiving 2011 three months after they arrived in
00:09:59
Panama the happy emails and calls from Yvonne started to drop off for Michelle a sisterly Instinct started
00:10:10
to kick in that's what set me off was the fact that they were coming less frequent the emails from her and then
00:10:17
they stopped completely two weeks passed then on December 14th Michelle finally got a text but it wasn't from Yvonne
00:10:28
there was a number I didn't recognize and a text message on there said this is Brian May I make arrangements to pick up
00:10:34
my truck Michelle was shocked Brian was back in the U.S I sat up called that number
00:10:43
for only thing on my office where's my sister he says didn't you get my email I said I
00:10:48
haven't received any emails from anybody it's been a few weeks I said I'll call you back so I went to my computer
00:10:54
Michelle discovered an email she had overlooked it was from Brian who had never written before
00:11:02
the one from him stated I'm sure you've heard by now that Bonnie and I are no longer together I called him right back
00:11:07
so I asked him like what happened and he said they had got in a fight because she had found out that he had a
00:11:14
child from somebody else that's somebody else Kristen werkhoven the two had a baby girl in 2010. since
00:11:24
Yvonne was unable to have a child because of a medical condition the discovery must have been
00:11:29
earth-shattering Brian then said Yvonne just up and left I said you should leave
00:11:35
a note no has she tried to call you since now do you know where she's at no and I said
00:11:41
I haven't heard from her Brian and he said well I'm sure she's fine but Michelle had her doubts about that story
00:11:50
and ten days later when Brian called and still wanted to pick up his truck Michelle said she had another plan
00:12:00
I said when you come to pick up the truck I'll be here that's no problem and I think it's a good idea that you go
00:12:04
with me to the police department since you're the last one to see her and we can fill out a missing person's
00:12:09
report because now we're already the mid-December and I haven't heard anything from her and that's not right
00:12:15
something's wrong in December of 2011 Michelle Valenzuela was still worried about her missing
00:12:37
sister so she went back to her computer where she found another overlooked message this one from Yvonne hi sis just
00:12:47
an update Brian and I are no longer together I should have trusted my instincts that he is a lying cheating
00:12:52
ass I'm headed to Costa Rica with a man I met when we first got to Bocas what you think when you read this email I
00:12:59
just wasn't sure there's some things in there that didn't feel right to me her head was spinning could Avon really
00:13:05
have run off with another man after learning that Brian had a love child all you've all never wanted to do was be a
00:13:12
mother that's all she ever wanted to do was be a mother to find out that Brian had a child and you know she said
00:13:18
everything she had to go the other ends of the world to be with his man and he didn't tell her about that I'm
00:13:22
questioning what her mental state is right now she's heartbroken in Upstate New York Jim and Lillian
00:13:29
Faust also felt the turn of events was just so out of character for their daughter for her life to change so
00:13:37
abruptly and she's like oh well I'm going with this guy and to Costa Rica Costa Rica that made absolutely
00:13:43
positively no sense to me also making no sense three weeks had passed since Yvonne had emailed from
00:13:51
Panama but then out of the blue she sent a new email it was strange miss you and everyone at
00:13:58
home starting to get a little homesick I'm working on plans to get home as early as the second week of January I've
00:14:04
been living with Cliffhangers for a while love you sis Yvonne while strange the email was also reassuring for her
00:14:12
family who was happy to learn Yvonne would soon return to California so I stopped worrying I figured okay she
00:14:20
knows that in January we're having a family get-together she's going to be there
00:14:24
do you feel she's safe at this at this point I was still worried but I was satisfied with it for the moment on the
00:14:31
same day that email arrived so too did Brian brimminger knocking on the front door of Michelle's La home to pick up
00:14:40
his truck what did you see on his face what was his demeanor like I was just in a hurry
00:14:45
he he's calm it's very brief all business yes get his stuff get his truck and leave
00:14:52
after Brian got his pickup truck Yvonne's emails stopped 16 long days passed until on January 6 2012 Michelle
00:15:04
wrote her sister the subject worried I just want to make sure you weren't kidnapped or someone pretending to be
00:15:12
you haha there's my paranoid Suspicious Mind or maybe too many 48 hours did you ever hear back from your sister
00:15:19
again no that's the last email Michelle was still hopeful that she would appear at that family reunion but
00:15:28
Yvonne never showed up well at that point when we met up with my dad and I told him we haven't heard
00:15:35
from her he said oh no something's wrong something's wrong and that's my dad she
00:15:39
did not leave Panama that's just my feeling by now Michelle was convinced her sister
00:15:46
never ran off to Costa Rica with another man so her Instinct was to learn where Yvonne's emails were really coming from
00:15:56
so I went to my cousin and asked them to please check it out because like I said
00:16:00
I haven't had I haven't got a clue the cousin a technology whiz said tracking Yvonne's emails would be easy all he
00:16:08
needed was their IP addresses so he searched the emails Yvonne had supposedly sent from Panama and Costa
00:16:16
Rica as well as that email Brian had sent from near Dana Point California the cousin made a startling discovery the
00:16:25
ones from Panama came from Panama and then the one that was supposed to be with her being in Costa Rica came from
00:16:31
the United States where in the United States one of them looked like they were coming from Dana Point that email
00:16:37
Michelle says originated from where Brian was now living near Dana Point California it was the evidence Michelle
00:16:45
had been looking for we were sharing the same IP address so Yvonne's email is coming from Brian's computer yes
00:16:55
the family's worst fear had come true it appeared Brian had hacked into Yvonne's
00:17:01
email account and was impersonating her but why that's when I knew that he did something to her
00:17:09
and it's not in the same person it's murder now it's murder I thought my sister's dead and I'm never going to see
00:17:15
her again but Michelle had no time to mourn she took that new evidence down to the FBI
00:17:23
where she met with special agent Andrew Masters Michelle Valenzuela she was a Spitfire
00:17:29
when they brought that to us we knew that there's absolutely Foul Play involved the FBI FB immediately launched
00:17:36
an investigation into Yvonne's disappearance with Masters taking charge Yvonne's family then contacted the state
00:17:45
department I called the embassy and the embassy tells us there is no record of her ever leaving Panama and no record of
00:17:52
her ever entering Costa Rica Yvonne's family couldn't wait any longer they traveled to Panama to find answers
00:18:01
the FBI made a move as well targeting Brian brimminger as a person of interest Brian didn't realize what exactly the
00:18:09
FBI is capable of foreign with the FBI investigation underway in the states Yvonne's family met up with legendary
00:18:36
investigator Don winter in Panama City why is it when something goes bad with an American citizen in Panama you get
00:18:43
the phone call I've already put away or helped to put away three serial killers so when bad things happen they know that
00:18:51
to come to me when when they don't know what else to do winner is an ex-us intelligence officer with an uncanny
00:18:58
ability to solve murders Jim and Lillian tell Don the story of their daughter's disappearance and Brian's claim that
00:19:07
she's run off with another man I think the chances that she's running around in Costa Rica somewhere with some other
00:19:13
dude are damn near zero here's a deal this is what happened this is what we think is going on it's not the first
00:19:19
time winner of CBS News consultant has worked on a case with 48 hours all right we're gonna go take a look at this uh
00:19:27
yellow trimaran the Intrepid investigator helped solve the murder of American sailor Don North as 48 Hours
00:19:35
reported in 2011. just on a personal side in all of this can you believe you and I are doing this again no absolutely
00:19:43
not I tell you what uh it's it's it's it's amazing winter is convinced Brian breminger is
00:19:51
involved his strategy put pressure on the Panamanian government to act because when Don winter speaks
00:19:59
the people listen yeah Winner's game plan also called for Jim and Michelle to give blood for DNA tests should any
00:20:07
remains be found and when Yvonne's family travels hundreds of miles from Panama City to
00:20:15
the tropical island where she disappeared the Panamanian police are persuaded to
00:20:22
hold a press conference to plead for information the family has been experienced a living nightmare for quite
00:20:29
a few months and we continue to appeal to anyone who knows absolutely anything about iman's disappearance to come
00:20:37
forward Panamanian police announced for the first time that Yvonne is the victim
00:20:43
of Foul Play and named Brian brimminger as the suspect this news conference reverberated around
00:20:52
the world police say within weeks of her disappearance brimager returned to the U.S got engaged and married another
00:20:59
woman tonight the FBI is calling him a person of interest riding the momentum of the press
00:21:06
conference they printed Flyers fanned out to neighborhoods and the village searching for their own Clues
00:21:21
it's a Bittersweet search for ivonne's niece Lauren Byer in a place that is no longer a paradox
00:21:30
there's nothing that's why we're here but the family's Quest is starting to get results Witnesses who knew the
00:21:42
couple come out of the woodwork describing Brian's verbal and physical abuse to me he was a scary person he was
00:21:50
not the kind of person I wanted to be around local bar owner Jeff Salzman saw it firsthand on Yvonne's face
00:21:59
as I recall it was black eyes and and Blackness around the face and bruises was she self-conscious about it she was
00:22:08
trying to hide it and and not speak of it it was very painful to learn that he had hit her that she had bruises that
00:22:16
she had black eyes those things were very difficult to learn the realization that Yvonne may have been murdered is
00:22:24
setting in where could Yvonne's body have been dumped we'll just feed in front of that house you've got thousands
00:22:30
of square miles of water well if you just go not 20 yards from the shoreline this impenetrable swamp
00:22:39
try to find something in there but that's exactly what Yvonne's family investigators
00:22:51
and volunteers set out to do entering what could be Yvonne's swampy graveyard describe this area that has to be
00:23:05
searched just how difficult a place is it okay it's jungle it's tropical so you have every kind of bug and Critter that
00:23:12
you can think of spiders and snakes and you know it's not a place to go slogging
00:23:16
around through okay struggling through the mug the spiders and the rancid water the smallest Discovery raises hope a
00:23:33
purse a medicine bottle a mysterious sinkhole kept asking myself I want to find Yvonne
00:23:45
but do I want to find Yvonne I mean I want to know where she is but do I want to see her in these swampy areas
00:23:53
then they find a passport you know we find a U.S passport uh the front page here
00:24:02
none of it is Yvonne's but back in the United States the FBI confronted Brian brimmager we went and knocked on his
00:24:12
door he answered and invited us in said that he was expecting us FBI special agent Andrew Masters
00:24:21
questioned Brian brimminger for more than four hours while he babysat his young daughter
00:24:28
to to special agent Andrew Masters along with special agent Gabriel Ramirez approaching apartment m in an attempt to
00:24:35
have a consensual monitored interview with Brian grimatur we weren't sure if he was going to break down and confess
00:24:43
to having a part in her Disappearance in murder or if he was going to become angry if he was going to kick us out
00:24:49
Brian stuck to his story Yvonne left him for another man I come back home and there was a note that said and I quote
00:24:59
going to Costa Rica with a man I've been talking to um f-u-m but when confronted with Michelle's
00:25:08
email evidence Brian began to stumble Brian I was kind of laid out there man the IP addresses are not coming back
00:25:16
from coast okay they're coming back from here okay so if she's not hanging out around
00:25:26
here then somebody sent those emails right out of those things all get sent you know anybody that would have her
00:25:33
email account vendor her account no yeah then something caught Master's eye as soon as I walk in I see a white Sony
00:25:45
Vaio which is a computer a laptop computer exactly and we knew that Yvonne owned a white Sony vial laptop that she
00:25:51
had taken with her to Panama what are you thinking I'm thinking we may very well have Yvonne's computer right here
00:25:57
Masters hunch was spot on it was Yvonne's computer but why was it in Brian's condo and would it help unravel
00:26:06
the mystery of Yvonne's disappearance take the journey with ivonne's family as they searched the jungles of Panama now
00:26:19
at 48hours.com even though he was under the FBI's microscope Brian bremager remained a
00:26:38
free man living with his family on the outskirts of San Diego Kristen worked for a defense contractor
00:26:45
while Brian unemployed spent much of his time golfing recognize that man yes I do
00:26:52
that's Brian in the summer of 2012 we showed Yvonne's sister Michelle video of Brian's New Life
00:27:01
what goes through your mind when you see him well honestly it's not surprising now that I
00:27:09
know what he's capable of he thinks he got away with murder so what you have here
00:27:16
is a person killed my sister and can walk away scot-free let's go guys just a few months after that FBI
00:27:29
interview we came face to face with the suspected killer Brian Peter Van Sant with CBS News we'd like
00:27:38
to ask a couple questions would you please talk to us did you murder Yvonne baldelli
00:27:47
you can speak to us you can answer that question Ryan why won't you speak with us
00:27:53
did you have anything to do with her disappearance well Brian heads off to enjoy another Carefree day on the greens
00:28:02
the FBI was turning his life upside down interviewing everyone he knew including
00:28:09
his wife Kristen what had Brian told her about why he was living in Panama he told Kristen that he is going down to
00:28:17
Panama to decompress from after leaving the Marine Corps and that he was going with some Marine Corps friends did
00:28:22
Christian urge Brian to leave Yvonne no Kristen didn't even know he wanted to existed so he lied to Kristen absolutely
00:28:30
apparently all those lies didn't matter to Kristen according to her Brian is the
00:28:36
greatest thing to ever happen to anybody but that's something she didn't want to
00:28:42
share with us when 48 Hours knocked on her door hi Kristin Kristen I'm Ryan with CBS News
00:28:58
so anyway we can talk [Music] meanwhile as special agent Masters took several investigative trips to Panama a
00:29:10
different portrait of Brian breminger emerged we talked to many people that would socialize with them at bars and we
00:29:18
learned about all the domestic violence uh that uh that he brought upon her uh the choking the the dragging uh the
00:29:25
berating after speaking with friends and neighbors of Yvonne and Brian special agent Masters became certain the couple
00:29:34
had a violent fight on November 26 2011. after Yvonne learned that Brian had fathered a child with Kristen argument
00:29:45
probably escalated and at some point Brian decided he was done with her and he was going to kill her crucial
00:29:51
evidence was also discovered on Yvonne's laptop the very computer Master saw when
00:29:57
he first questioned Brian about two weeks before her murder Yvonne took this disturbing selfie that photo shows a
00:30:07
massive black eye on her left eye and swelling in her left cheek in a way from the grave Yvonne helped you in this
00:30:15
investigation Yvonne helped us tell the story yes absolutely and there was more chilling
00:30:22
evidence we found the Yahoo searches in which he searches how to remove blood from a mattress when did he do that he
00:30:30
did that about 10 30 in the morning the night after Yvonne was murdered Stewarts discovered even more evidence
00:30:38
in Costa Rica where Brian is seen with drawing cash for me Vaughan's account we were able to obtain those ATM photos so
00:30:46
we have Brian using the Yvonne's debit card to extract money from her account and master says there is no doubt that
00:30:54
Brian used Yvonne's laptop to send those emails to her family so we went looking for Brian breminger
00:31:02
again to get answers hey Brian I need to talk to you how do you explain the fact that Yvonne's email that said
00:31:11
she was in Costa Rica that she sent to people was actually sent by you from here in California
00:31:18
can you answer that you knew she was dead when you sent that email didn't you Brianna we really want you to talk to us
00:31:27
answer some questions he's never said a word never said a word to us he will not answer any questions
00:31:42
and what about Yvonne's dog Georgia May which had not been seen since she disappeared Don winner has a theory he
00:31:51
knew that she loved that dog and that if the dog was running around he knew that
00:31:56
anything she said about her taken off with some guy to Costa Rica everybody would immediately know it was crap so he
00:32:01
had to get rid of the dog too in his investigation Don winner unwittingly found a key piece of
00:32:08
evidence on Brian's Facebook page where he had sold this machete after Yvonne disappear imager made a comment about
00:32:17
that knife he's like yeah that used to be mine I brought it down with me when I came down from the states and the
00:32:22
chilling part is he made a comment that said I've only used it to chop up one stripper that's just chilling
00:32:29
special agent Andrew Masters needs to get his hands on the machete to see if it was used in Yvonne's murder
00:32:38
incredibly he was able to track down the person who bought it from Brian in Panama this is the machete that's Brian
00:32:46
bought in the United States and took down with him to Panama can you pick it up for me sure
00:32:52
it's very heavy it's weighted and it would inflict a lot of damage investigators had the machete they had
00:33:02
the email and they had caught Brian in multiple lives soon someone would stumble upon the most
00:33:10
important evidence of all Don winter shares some of the details of his investigation now at 48hours.com
00:33:26
[Music] we seek answers Justice and help summer 2013. nearly two years have passed since
00:33:43
Yvonne baldelli's disappearance you feel like you're reading a book a terrible mystery or murder mystery and there's no
00:33:50
end to it on June 26 2013 the final chapter of this mystery began to unfold a former
00:34:00
Marine who family members say murdered his girlfriend before FBI special agent Andrew Masters slapped the cuffs on
00:34:08
Brian breminger what did you say to him you're under arrest I said turn around put your hands behind
00:34:15
your back he needed the answer for his crime how did you learn that Brian had been
00:34:19
arrested truth be told I received a text from my dad said they got the SOB I sat down and a sense of relief because
00:34:28
now they believed us Brian bremature was charged with 13 felonies relating to the
00:34:35
cover-up of Yvonne's death but not murder assistant U.S attorneys Shane Harrigan and Mark Conover were lead
00:34:43
prosecutors at that point without having found the body we didn't have quite enough to bring the murder charge
00:34:52
but that would soon change human remains have been found on a Panamanian Island a
00:34:58
local worker clearing some brush on the island where Brian and Yvonne lived Came
00:35:03
Upon This duffel bag and when he unbuckled the clasp he found Yvonne's skeletonized Remains by the time she was
00:35:11
found two years later she it was only bones a DNA test confirmed it was Yvonne her remains were found just a few
00:35:21
hundred yards from where the family had spent days searching I wanted to tell Michelle personally when I first heard
00:35:29
the possibility that they found Yvonne my first reaction was for me it's good news because I just feel good we can
00:35:34
nail this bastard while the family's prayers had been answered and autopsy confirmed the hellish fact that Yvonne
00:35:43
had been dismembered this is the actual device that was used to dismember Yvonne the most likely
00:35:51
cause of death was being stabbed in the back at least twice despite overwhelming evidence and proof
00:36:04
that premature had repeatedly lied his wife Kristen continued to stand by him Kristen may I ask do you still believe
00:36:13
in your husband's innocence can you just tell us that don't touch the camera then for Yvonne's family another cruel
00:36:25
tragedy struck in the spring of 2014. Michelle who had dedicated her life to finding Justice for her sister now faced
00:36:35
another deadly enemy she was diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer I'm still alive to fight
00:36:43
for my life and I'm still alive to fight for my sister this was Michelle in June of 2014.
00:36:52
and this was her just three months later today are going I'm going to be giving a dip position
00:37:04
we can buy cancer and given just weeks to live you saw me swear Michelle a crucial
00:37:12
witness agreed to tell her story while she still could Brian breminger would sit directly
00:37:20
across from her didn't I try to ignore him smooth best I can and who was Brian brimmager the defender
00:37:30
you see him in the courtroom here today yes I do would you please point to him and describe where he is seated for the
00:37:37
record he's sitting at the end tacky outfit then Michelle passed out after the exhausting testimony
00:37:48
it was a courageous Act of love for her sister this might be the last thing I get to do
00:37:55
for her over and over and over again because it'll be on camera forever days later
00:38:04
she died [Music] it took years of diplomatic and legal wrangling but in early 2015 the
00:38:17
government of Panama finally agreed to let Brian be tried for murder on American soil we came to the conclusion
00:38:24
that the only way that Brian brimager would face Justice for his murderous Act is if he was charged and convicted here
00:38:31
in the United States Brian pleaded not guilty the case was heading for trial in 2016 when investigators made another
00:38:40
dramatic discovery Yvonne's blood and DNA were found under the machete's handle so these three
00:38:51
screws were undone the handle opens up and inside they find blood right they remove these three and just pulled it
00:38:58
out here and conducted the testing on the blade and the interior portion of the handle and found blood whose blood
00:39:05
yvonnece Yvonne baldellas Yvonne baldelli this now is a slam dunk you know that this is the tool used to
00:39:13
dismember her it was that that made Brian finally realize he was not going to get out of the he was not going to
00:39:18
lie his way out it's over it's done he had cleaned the blade but he hadn't cleaned underneath the handle and it was
00:39:25
that additional evidence that I believe eventually LED Mr brimager to plead guilty
00:39:31
within a week brimager pleaded guilty to second-degree murder while the other charges were dropped and later at his
00:39:40
sentencing finally admitted after nearly five years of lies to killing Yvonne baldelli and I think if you look up on
00:39:49
the dictionary evil and you see Brian's picture in there he's the ultimate carnate of evil in my mind in open court
00:39:56
brimager apologized to Yvonne's family but his words rang Hollow Brian brimager is a con artist he had our daughter Khan
00:40:07
he had his new wife Khan he had her family conned he was able to live a double life sometimes a triple life and
00:40:14
people buy what he says but his actions show that he's not the person he says that he is
00:40:22
Brian was sentenced to 26 years in federal prison [Music] with the case over Yvonne's remains were
00:40:37
returned to her family foreign and laid to rest at sea [Music] to get her remains back and be able to
00:40:54
give her a dignified resting place I can sleep better at night knowing that she's
00:41:00
not rotting in some jungle or deep in the ocean somewhere knowing that she loved the ocean knowing that we were
00:41:06
able to put her in a place that she loved we brought her home and I know that that was thanks to a lot of work of
00:41:14
a lot of unsung heroes I know in a way two people were honored this day Yvonne and her beloved sister
00:41:30
Michelle who battled a marine to the end and won she's definitely a hero she never gave
00:41:38
up to her dying day she gave all she had [Music] Kristen and Brian brimmiger are still
00:41:49
married she continues to support and visit him in federal prison brimminger's prison term ends in
00:41:56
February 2037. [Music] help us solve this crime it was a Savage murder a stunning model she was quite the
00:42:16
trophy married to a multi-millionaire this is where the assailing got her from behind knocked her to the ground they
00:42:27
slid her throat eight years no arrest and there are no fingerprints no nothing at all there are Clues the sketch who is
00:42:37
this is this the guy that murdered my sister the letter I know that was a shock cut out in little bitty individual
00:42:44
different letters I mean why are you talking to me I want to find out who murdered my sister
00:42:53
cbsn CBS News always on