Finding, and Rewarding, Your Best Customers

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Delta Air Lines' recently announced decision to base frequent flyer rewards on dollars spent rather than miles traveled is a better, more customer-centric way to distribute product benefits, says Wharton marketing professor Peter Fader. When it comes to customer value, Fader notes, "one of the rubrics we celebrate is the notion of RMF — recency, frequency [and] monetary value. [It makes sense to] reward customers on that basis." With just 4% of Delta's customers accounting for 25% of revenues, the choice seems clear — if overdue — Fader explains.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I want to welcome Wharton marketing Professor Pete fader to join us today to talk about the recent move by Delta
  2. Airlines to change its frequent flyer Rewards program from one based on Miles flown to one based on how much money you
  3. spend with the Airlines and um that means Pete that those who spend more will get preferential treatment and just
  4. to give a little context from the airlines point of view the top 4% of Delta's customers are resp responsible
  5. uh in dollar spending for about 25% of the revenue so you can see why they wanted to do something for that group
  6. but but you have uh a book about customer centricity that is very much around this point so could you talk
  7. about how that relates to what the airlines in delta in particular is doing today the airlines are such an
  8. interesting industry because in many ways they brought many of the the aspects of customer centricity out uh
  9. earlier and better than any other industry you know on the heels of of being deregulated in the 1970s and right
  10. through the 1980s everything from Dynamic pricing to loyalty programs as we know them today we have to thank or
  11. or blame the airlines for that they they did some amazingly Progressive things a
  12. lot of people can't even imagine a time without the the plethora of loyalty programs that we have today but but they
  13. are a relatively recent Innovation and it was very risky on the part of the airlines to take gone all these
  14. liabilities and to build all this infrastructure and to come up with all these uh incentives for people to use
  15. these programs so so lots of credit to the airlines of course Delta included for making all this happen but then it
  16. all kind of stagnated they they started with some really amazing practices but then those practices haven't changed for
  17. the the 30 years since they first instituted them so the kind of move that Delta is making here makes total sense
  18. and it should have happened years earlier and it's a shame that it's taken so long for the major airlines to
  19. realize that it's dollars that matter More Than Miles uh briefly explain what customer
  20. centricity is and how it would relate to what they've done here so in my book literally a customer centricity is about
  21. a recognition of the differences across your customers there is no single average customer there's this wide
  22. variety of them and they vary not only in their their needs and what they want from a relationship but they vary in
  23. terms of their value to the firm and it's imperative for a firm to figure out who the most valuable customers are to
  24. start taking on tactics to create more value to extract some of that value for their shareholders and to find more
  25. customers who resemble those valuable ones to try to bend over backwards to bring them in to try to create and
  26. extract value from them as well so it's a celebration of differences as opposed to let's figure out what the average
  27. customer wants and loyalty programs are a great way for customers to self- select and to provide those kinds of
  28. rewards and that value extraction and again the airlines have been good about developing those programs but they
  29. haven't been really Progressive about changing them for the the the are changing understanding of customers and
  30. the changing needs for a company and its shareholders so it makes sense for an airline to want to reward its best
  31. customers best meaning the ones that give it the most money from whom they get the most revenues um that also means
  32. that some customers are going to be less well off right so there'll be some winners and losers could you talk about
  33. that I don't like to think that there' be losers I do like to think about Winners and I'm not saying this just to
  34. be politically correct I'm not I I don't want companies to be firing customers I
  35. don't want companies to go to customers and and and basically treat them badly the problem is today there are so many
  36. companies out there not including the airlines for the most part that are treating too many customers too well so
  37. no one should be treated badly but some customers deserve better treatment and that should be on the basis of what
  38. they're worth to the firm and so this is a step in the right direction I I I don't want to see that any customers
  39. going to be much worse off but I think that the the the incentives associated with an airline loyalty program have
  40. been a bit out of whack by rewarding people for Miles instead of dollars so it's not so much giving people less it's
  41. giving them more what they deserve so uh um it might be that under the new Delta
  42. program the ultimate beneficiary would be a frequent flyer who travels who's let's say takes a lot of short trips and
  43. does them on short notice because of business reasons or whatever so they're paying top dollar for the fairs they're
  44. not getting any discounts by reserving way in advance and they're not getting many miles because they're just flying
  45. you know maybe an hour or so away um and on the other hand there's the bargain shopper who's you know getting the
  46. cross-continental flights at bargain rates and maybe they do that you know a couple times a year and they're and
  47. they're getting lots of miles so they may not be losers but they're but they're are they they're going to not
  48. get quite the benefits that they've had in the past so it's a redistribution of the benefits and while it might be
  49. disappointing to those who are getting a little bit less than they uh got before
  50. it's hard for them to complain about it uh I mean they they will complain about it but uh but it's hard to feel a great
  51. deal of sympathy for them I think that the the structures of the programs the way that were set up were a little
  52. artificial a little bit out of whack so this is just uh recalibrating the programs in an appropriate way I don't
  53. see this as an example of a company chiseling away and and taking away from its customers I think it really is just
  54. a fairer distribution and and it really does make sense if you think about the the the principles or the the metrics
  55. that are associated with customer value uh one of the rubrics that we celebrate is the notion of rfm recency frequency
  56. monetary value uh and so let's Reward customer customers on that basis so someone who's flying infrequently and
  57. they're just taking that occasional big flight and often not paying a lot for it
  58. isn't worth as much as someone who's taking a lot of short flights very often and and indeed paying top dollar for
  59. them so it makes all the sense in the world and it's hard to make an argument to the contrary other than sheer
  60. inertia is there sometimes a conflict it seems like there would be between providing good customer service overall
  61. and and customer centricity so other it's very expensive to provide really good customer service to all your customers
  62. all companies want to do that they say they want to do it there's good reasons for wanting to do it whether they can
  63. afford it or whether it makes sense are the very items that you're talking about
  64. here how how do you balance that how companies balance that companies need to be more selective about who gets that
  65. red carpet treatment and this is actually one area where the airlines have been pretty good which is to say
  66. most people get treated eh but for but it's the it's those who get the upgrades it's those who get other kinds of
  67. benefits that the airline might offer that are getting that that special treatment and again uh that should be on
  68. the basis of what the customer is worth uh and when I'm talking about worth I'm not necessarily talking about past
  69. profitability I'm talking about a projection of what we think this customer will be worth in the future
  70. that's how we want to be giving the rewards out for the most part the airlines have been very backwards
  71. looking let's reward people on what they have done hoping that that's a Mir near
  72. to the Future in some cases it is but I think if we can look at people who are spending big dollars today as opposed to
  73. those who took a few long flights with us say six months ago I think it makes much more sense and and and not only
  74. will the the points be given out in in a in a better manner but the but the benefits uh that customers get will be
  75. distributed more appropriately as well could you talk about uh the tools that are available for making uh decisions
  76. about future spending you predictability how how do you do that you talked about
  77. some customers may have spent a lot with you recently but they may not be as valuable as ones where certain metrics
  78. show they're the ones that going to be spending more in the future what are those metrics how do you measure that it
  79. all comes down to the notion of customer lifetime value we're going to look at the the flow of transactions the size of
  80. transactions other interactions that we've had with each and every customer and we're going to make uh an educated
  81. guess about what we think that customer will be in the future a lot of people look at this as as rocket science some
  82. people find it kind of creepy that we're going to be uh basing our customer management strategies on a prediction of
  83. the future as opposed to the the certainty of the past but we've seen a number of Industries where these ideas
  84. of of using data valuing customers and making tactical decisions on the basis of their projected future value makes a
  85. whole lot of sense the airlines haven't been very good about it again it's ironic that they've put in place a lot
  86. of the tactics again Revenue management schemes loyalty programs that enable this kind of management but they just
  87. haven't had either the the analytic horsepower or the or or the guts or the the corporate culture that enables the
  88. use of clv as much as as other kinds of Industries like say Financial Services or telecommunications so this is I see
  89. as a step in the right direction I think in the long run it's going to be good for the customers for the right kinds of
  90. customers and good for the air L as well uh should the other airlines follow suit
  91. I think some actually have proceeded Delta but is it inevitable that the others will because the best customers
  92. May flock to where their rewards are better even though they have a stake in past miles in other airlines I really do
  93. believe it makes sense for for the other airlines to be doing the same kind of thing again it took way too long for
  94. Delta to step in this direction but I think all the other big ones should be doing the same thing of course when they
  95. do uh the public and policy makers will say oh it's just the airlines ganging up
  96. on the poor customer I don't think that's the case here certainly those kinds of things are true in in other
  97. settings when Airlines follow each other around but but this was a change that that should have happened long ago and
  98. and and better uh that it happened later than never and I think each of the other
  99. a lines will will do something like this I'm sure that they'll refine it in terms
  100. of the the specific ways that they they translate dollars into customer value and the kind the way that they they Dole
  101. out the benefits as a result so it's not going to be the same program for everybody but it's just a more sensible
  102. way overall for them to be managing the relationship with their customers so generally speaking these customer uh
  103. Centric ideas apply across most Industries if they followed them in your view they Industries would be better off
  104. are there some Industries where they are more valuable to impose than others first I want to disagree with the
  105. assertion I don't want to suggest that that this idea of customer centricity and and focusing on certain kinds of
  106. customers and treating them differently I don't think that is true for for all Industries or for all companies and even
  107. in an industry where it does make sense and I think Airlines would be included as well as retailing telecommunications
  108. Financial Services on others uh that doesn't mean that every firm needs to do it in fact a healthy ecosystem would
  109. consist of some firms that are doing the customer Centric thing other firms that
  110. are focusing on let's call it performance superiority where the best and others that are focusing on
  111. operational excellence so it's not a one-size fits-all strategy and in particular in Industries where it's
  112. really hard to observe what each customer is doing and really hard to Target them with individualized messages
  113. and treatment and so on then it's it's really hard to do the customer Centric thing so in an industry say consumer
  114. packaged Goods where it's it's hard for a Proctor and Gamble to know what each and every consumer is doing and and and
  115. while they they spend a lot of time trying to get General understandings of What kinds of customers like certain
  116. kinds of products and services it's hard for them to tailor their offerings uh quite as well as say a a a retailer can
  117. could you give some examples of other companies that uh or or industries that would be taking a different approach so
  118. uh we can just understand that a little more clearly many Industries are are formed
  119. around a blockbuster mentality let's come up with the next big thing let's produce it in Great quantities let's
  120. bring the cost down as we do so let's get it out there to our customers as efficiently as possible so so so many
  121. companies so many Industries are are born into that and it's hard for them to move away from it even if it might be
  122. the best thing for them to do so it's interesting to look at industries that again are are born into that block of
  123. Buster mentality but are but are kind of fighting against it these days such as Pharmaceuticals there's a really great
  124. example them it's clearly about Blockbusters but some firms in that industry are realizing that they need to
  125. go in a slightly different direction they need to focus a little bit more on doing this customer Centric thing
  126. instead of just trying to keep inventing Blockbuster new drugs and and then giving up on them when they go off
  127. patent so that would be just one example of an industry that that's struggling a
  128. bit that's kind of breaking away in in some ways from its traditional routs but not abandoning them completely so what
  129. about you personally will you be more likely to fly say Delta as a result of this kind of a program what's
  130. interesting about the airline industry is that there's so much uh uh local virtual monopolies taking place so
  131. living here in Philadelphia I'm largely locked into US Airways and that doesn't mean that I'm being held hostage by them
  132. I could switch but because I am uh at the highest tier for US Airways and I'm one of those customers who gets treated
  133. pretty well uh I don't really have a reason to switch away from them I'm one of the few people who will stand up and
  134. say I like the way that US Airways treats me now it could get even better if they uh restructure their loyalty
  135. program in the way that Delta has and and while there's no specific evidence of it I predict that they will do that
  136. as well so so I have no reason to to jump ship and and try other airlines out although of course on occasion uh for
  137. various reasons I I'm forced to do so and as a as a as a student of the marketing industry it it is very
  138. interesting for me to see the way these different programs play out the way different kinds of customer service
  139. policies play out I think I'm learning a lot from these different kinds of tactics and I'm encouraged by the fact
  140. that different airlines are trying different things I think uh the industry will be better as a whole and again in
  141. the long run I think it can can be okay for customers too all right P thank you very much for joining us today my
  142. pleasure [Music]

Brief Summary

Pete Fader discusses Delta's shift to a spending-based rewards program and its implications for customer value and loyalty.

Key points

  • Delta's New Rewards Program. Delta Airlines shifts its frequent flyer program to prioritize spending over miles flown.
  • Customer Centricity Explained. Professor Pete Fader discusses the importance of recognizing customer differences.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes