Bill Connelly on College Football Chaos, Coaching Carousel, and Predicting the Future of the Game
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Bill Connelly breaks down why college football chaos isn’t luck — it’s probability at work. He explains how multiple “sure-thing” games can still produce weekly upsets, why programs may be smarter to invest NIL money in players instead of huge coaching contracts, and how the new playoff era and conference realignment will reward depth over brand power. The conversation shows how data and uncertainty actually drive who wins in modern college football.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? The Moneyball podcast explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#CollegeFootball #SportsAnalytics #NIL #CollegeFootballPlayoff #FootballStrategy #GameTheory ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Brief Summary
Bill Connley discusses college football analytics, chaos superfectas, coaching changes, and playoff performances in baseball and the NFL.
Key points
- The Sports Equinox. A rare moment when all four major North American sports are playing simultaneously.
- Chaos Superfectas Explained. Bill Connley introduces his concept of chaos superfectas in college football predictions.
- The New Coaching Landscape. Discussion on the evolving strategies in college football coaching hires and salaries.
- Texas Tech's Bold Moves. Texas Tech is shaking up college football by investing heavily in talent and facilities.
- Bill Connley on College Football. Bill discusses the upcoming game and the strong performance of Kate's team.
- Epic 18-Inning Game. A thrilling 18-inning game caught the attention of the hosts, leading to a late-night watch.
Episode highlights
- The Sports EquinoxA rare moment when all four major North American sports are playing simultaneously.“There’s only like one or two days where this is true.”0:55Oct 31, 2025
- Chaos Superfectas ExplainedBill Connley introduces his concept of chaos superfectas in college football predictions.“There’s only like a 43% chance that all four of these teams win.”4:32Oct 31, 2025
- The New Coaching LandscapeDiscussion on the evolving strategies in college football coaching hires and salaries.“It’s going to be really interesting with all these coaching hires.”10:38Oct 31, 2025
- Texas Tech's Bold MovesTexas Tech is shaking up college football by investing heavily in talent and facilities.“I like that they’re trying it.”33:16Oct 31, 2025
- Bill Connley on College FootballBill discusses the upcoming game and the strong performance of Kate's team.“They’re really really really good and fast this year.”33:19Oct 31, 2025
- Epic 18-Inning GameA thrilling 18-inning game caught the attention of the hosts, leading to a late-night watch.“Dad, you’re never going to believe it.”34:56Oct 31, 2025
- Yamamoto's Unique SituationDiscussion on Yamamoto's pitching performance and its implications for the playoffs.“He had pitched two days ago.”36:37Oct 31, 2025
- Freddie Freeman's Historic AchievementFreeman becomes the only player in MLB history with two walk-off home runs in the World Series.“He’s the only player in Major League Baseball history with two walk-off home runs in the World Series.”45:06Oct 31, 2025
Transcript
Welcome, welcome to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to a full hour of sports analytics here on the Wharton podcast network. This is Kade Massie hosting with three quarters of the co-hosts here. Two of my three co-hosts. Shane Jensen is in here and Eric Bradlo is also Shane from home and Eric from a couple floors above me. Eric and I are both in the office at the moment. Audi Winer is out doing Audi things which I believe are classroom related right now. He's down doing his job teaching Wharton students. He'll be back. Some combination of us are here almost every week of the year. Have been for more than 11 years now. Delighted to be here. We're recording on a Tuesday afternoon
as we usually do. I believe we're right in that kind of narrow window of what Matty Dats used to call the sports equinox. All sports. Was it last night? Was it tonight? There's some day here where all four major North American sports are playing and there's only like one or two days where this is true. So, >> plus two baseball games for the price of one. >> Exactly. Well, for those of us who decided to spend our evening watching it perhaps, but we're going to leave a little baseball to the second half. God knows we can spend the whole half or even the whole show talking baseball with all that's going on with the
Dodgers and Otani and that world. In the first half, we're going to do our usual thing, which is bring a guest in here. And it's been a little while. It's been a couple weeks anyway since we've talked football on the show. Um, so we grabbed one of our favorites to talk football with. We're going to talk college football this half hour with Bill Connley. Bill C is with us in the house from Columbia, Missouri. Bill Connley, good to see you. Thank you, man. >> Absolutely. We're uh what 2/ird of the way or so uh through the regular season here, but you know, there's still another six-month playoff after that. >> Well, happily, it's not six months, but
it is a little bit of a stretch. And it'll go fast in the beginning, then kind of get slow at the end. But yeah, right. Four regular season games left for most teams, and that just seems absurd. I mean, that's that's really surprising. Um and we want to get caught up. I I have to admit a couple things. Um, I've had my head deeply into teaching the last few weeks, which has corresponded nicely with a particular team from Austin, Texas, not performing especially well. So, between the two, I'm less out of touch than I usually am on football. But, I got some questions for you, Bill. I want to start though with some praise. I' I've come to praise you, not to question you to to begin
with. Bill, we've talked about this on the show. I think we should talk about it like every week. when when you're in our business, you understand that uncertainty is really important and it's hard to communicate and moreover, people don't want to hear about it. And so the whole question of how do you communicate the importance of uncertainty, the the the the impact of uncertainty, the underappreciated consequences of uncertainty. I think you're just trying to be a clever writer, but you've come up with this method this year, which I think is absolutely inspired. You in your preview
columns every week. So, Bill C, y'all know this, Bill Connley writes for ESPN. He's got a brand new book out, we should say, Forward Progress come out this this fall on the future of college football. Bill's um we know a college football historian, but he's also apparently a college football futurist. He's going to merge these things and tell us where we're going. College Football: Forward Progress. Bill's a author of multiple books. Anyway, weekly columns previewing college football. In this column, he does this thing. I think he calls them chaos superfectas. Chaos superfect. Bill, if you haven't made t-shirts yet, please do and send me one. I want a Bill
Connley Chaos superfecta t-shirt. This is the concept, guys. This is the concept. Get this. Every week, >> is it different than the concept that I've been talking about and dreaming, as you know, for 11 and a half years in college football? Like if only Boise State could win out and then there'd be a conf between [laughter] this is not the chaos super effective you're talking about. >> Each each Saturday has its specific chaos super. >> So Bill, I should shut up and tell us about your chaos super effective. >> This is actually so this is the second year I've been doing it and I should
have quit after last year because it killed last year. But um the idea is basically you know take four games and mash them into what like four games where the spread is you know probably 7 10 14 points um and win probabilities generally end up being between about 72 and 95 with my SP plus ratings. Uh mash them together and basically say hey there's only like a 43% chance that all four of these teams win. Um that way just I I I enjoyed it. I I basically replaced the picks section in my column each Friday with this which is so much better. Um, you know, I was agonizing over late late in the week uh spreads. All the good ones were gone. I was
spending way too much time just to try to hit like 52% and the world didn't need a 9 millionth best bets section or column. So, I did something that was way that was very me instead. And yeah, basically said this I think this coming week is going to be Georgia Tech against Maryland, Texas Tech against Kansas State, Louisville against Virginia Tech, and Pit against Stanford. there's only a 43% chance that all four of those teams win, which basically means we're getting an upset somewhere. Uh, somebody on is going to lose on the road and it's going to be fun. And that's my little way of reminding everybody that we're never that far away. We never completely know
what's going on and we're never that far away from something chaotic happening. >> Exactly. He's reminding everybody that we don't know that even though each one of these by themselves, here's the thing. Each one of these feel by themselves like a more or less locked. In this case, it doesn't quite feel that way, but there these things are designed so that each one feels kind of like a lock, but people have a hard time understanding, but it's technically 75%. It's not a lock. It's 75 or it's 85% on the if you only give them one, it's hard for them to understand. But if you give them a portfolio and say, "Okay, guys, fine. Each one of them feels like a
lock." But I'm telling you, there's a 50-50 chance, and this is how Bill does it every week. Roughly 5050 chance that one of these favorites is going to go down because we put together a bundle of four. Now we can start understanding uncertainty better. So I just think it's freaking brilliant. >> Well, and last year I I overachieved big time. It got like 60 70% of the weeks where I hit at least one. >> Hold on. No, you're not supposed to do that. No, no, now you you that's not what you want. You want 50. You want exactly on the number or whatever. >> We're we're regressing to the mean this year. We started three and one this year, too. I'm like, "Oh my god, I am a
genius." And now we've lost four out of five. So now we're at four and five for the season, which is basically where we should be. >> Right. Right. All right. So, does anybody else love this as much as we do? This is such a Wharton Munville concept. I mean, we I'm telling you, I want a t-shirt badly. But have you received any accolades or any appreciation for this thing at all? >> I I have definitely noticed that like two people asked where the pics went. Nobody's That's it in in a year and a half. Nobody's saying, "I really miss your pics." But they enjoy the chaos idea. >> Bill, I have a comment on this and then
a question. The comment is I think people don't understand um you know I'll call it the probability of a and b and c and d is the product of those probabilities. So even if it was 75 75 to the 4th is about a quarter right. So that means the probability that all of those favorites are going to win is that um people don't understand what I call the probability of at least one upset is one minus the probability of no upsets. And so you do that math and you end up with typically not a very small number. There's a high probability of at least one upset. You know, the kind of what I call a group set probabilities. That was my comment, but
then I was going to ask you a question. I always have a belief, but you're going to tell me I'm nuts. Like you listed four games. Let's assume they're not all being played at the same time. How nuts am I to think that upsets like this are independent are not independent? of each other. Like for all right, so Kate says I'm nuts. I always say that, you know what, I'll make it up. I'm the nine o'clock at 10:00 p.m. West Coast game, which is 7:00. I've se I'll make it up. I've seen someone beat Georgia Tech. This team beats this. Why aren't we next? Is there any evidence that there's not independence? Cade's saying no. Good. I I just have to ask
push. My general push back would be that the game days are so hilariously involved. You know, we're on the bus at this time. Like, I mean, guys are going to have their phones here and there or whatever. Um, if if like there's a huge upset in the noon game and you're playing at 9:30, you probably know about the noon upset. >> Is that worth anything, Bill? Well, I think the very specific instance where I could see it maybe being where something would be like in a conference title race situation where um you need so and so to win at noon um for you to have a chance
at 3:30 and now you know they're they were ahead when you went in there and maybe there's a little extra juice going on like okay we've got the chance in like in a specific scenario like that. Yes. But if it's like Georgia >> Technos let's listen to Bill here. Let's keep going. He's being he's being kind >> in a situation where it's like Georgia Tech lost at noon so we're playing Texas Tech at 7. We have a chance like that probably isn't the case but specific one result we need this to happen. I could see >> it's it is it is endlessly entertaining how our rigorous basian AI vice dean
somehow periodically channels his inner I don't know 14year-old and decides that uh things like that >> we're all 14y olds. >> Well, we've got different varieties on that. That's true. Okay, Bill, let's talk one more question before we get to actual football. The coaching carousel is alive and well and as interesting as ever, if not more so, and I'm curious of of the many um open seats going around in this carousel or the various issues or connections or whatever, what most interests you, right? I I I was uh posting about this on social earlier um on Blue Sky actually
like I think the most interesting thing to me is well to use my hometown team as an example like right now Eli Drinkitz is making he has a top 10 or 15 salary here at Missouri. He's rumored like he's going to be on Florida's list. He's going to be on LSU's list if Texas comes open. If so and so comes open like this could be an absolute nuts. He was on Penn State's list supposedly at first. He's on all these lists. he's going to get a huge raise this year. But if you're Missouri and your options are well, if you're you're going to try to keep him, you'll offer him a pretty healthy raise and suddenly you'll be paying like a top
five, six, seven salary probably if he accepts it. But as a from a programmatic perspective, it's going to be really interesting with all these coaching hires. Some are going to go after the splash and and part of that is just, you know, that that athletic directors uh have to, you know, impress the big dumb money boosters by making a big dumb move. Like that's how you know you got to speak otherwise you'll get fired and you don't want to get fired. So, you're going to try to impress them uh by making a splash uh and paying a lot for a coach. Others are going to the idea is like would it be better for Missou's program if like if Drinkwis just if you if you're gonna have to pay
him like $12 million a year to keep him is it better to pay him $12 million a year when you're not you know Texas or Ohio State or would it be basically say like man thanks for thanks for having do for the job you did go enjoy yourself at Florida we're going to hire an upand cominging offensive coordinator we're going to pay him $4 million a year we're going to plug that extra $12 million a year into uh NIL money for better recruits and better transfers and we're going to you can probably get six eight 10 really solid transfers for $8 million. Does that help your team more than the bird inhand good coach that you already have? And so that's going to be,
you know, again, like every athletic director is going to try to keep their expensive coach, but you, you know, from from what we've seen, the teams that are at at the top of college football right now, most of them weren't hired as great successes elsewhere for a lot of money. Like, you know, maybe whether it's something you would aim to do or not, maybe it's better for a program to only pay $4 million a year and plug extra money into talent since you have to pay for talent now. >> Well, that's interesting. That's a it's a calculus that they haven't had in the
past. So, it's it's kind of a new world in that respect. Bill, um absurd question, but kind of a fun way to think about it. If you had to go work as the head coach of either LSU, Florida, or Penn State, um setting aside where you want to live, but considering but considering all all factors, which is like you've got the recruiting hot beds, but you've also got maybe some crazy fan bases. Um which would you which situation would you rather walk into? Yeah, I immediately like food-wise LSU, [laughter] but >> of course you're going to choose food. >> Well, I do think um what what one of the things J that kind
of blessed James Franklin ended up cursing him, but you know, being Big 10's a more topheavy conference. Um, and you know, we're seeing that this year, especially with Florida with Penn State kind of falling apart. Like Ohio State's going to get all the way to the end of the season without having played like a top 10 or 15 level team. >> Just note it's a 20point line this weekend. This was one of the biggest games of the year we look forward to. This was a top five on anybody's list game of the year, Ohio State, Penn State, and now it's a 20-point line. >> Yeah. and and obviously Indiana's better than expected in individual teams within
the Big 10 are better than expected. But overall, like the even with the SEC not having any of I think the top four teams in my SP plus ratings, it's still like on average four points better than any other conference because it has all the depth. You just have more possible losses in the SEC. And we might find out that, you know, once a couple nine and three SEC teams get in, maybe um we think about this a little different, but the one year of the 12 team playoff, we know that the teams with the better records got in. Uh, and just on that alone, you would think that maybe Penn State, considering they're going to pay as much as anybody,
you might have to travel further in your and add a little more travel into your recruiting budget, but I don't think, you know, James Franklin never really struggled to sign fourstar recruits. Feels like maybe that's the place to be. You're just more likely to have an extra win on the schedule and and get in. And of course, like I said, that ended up cursing James Franklin because he won all those games, but could never beat Ohio State. And the moment he started losing to to mortal teams, he was out the door. >> Well, you're naming another dynamic that's just new in college football. That is the between transfers, NIL, and
realignment. The SEC is just an entirely different animal to navigate from an expected losses perspective. And the you said topheavy and you said, you know, and then the SK the scheduling vagaries means you've only got a couple teams you'd worry about and you likely won't have to play all of them. you some years won't have to play any of them. And the thing is if you miss those guys, the rest of your schedule looks like the ACC that that they literally if you look at the way anybody who ensembles power rankings, you've got three or four, maybe just three Big 10 teams that up there competing maybe even higher than the SEC, but then it's a vast Gulf and a
bunch of those folks look they like the ACC. Okay, so you're going you're going to co to to um state college. Fine. Okay, now let's talk a little bit of football. Last weekend you had a big game. You had Vandy U Missouri and so you saw Vandy kind of up close in a way and they this week go to Texas. Texas has looked more or less wretched like they could they could just end up in the ditch any minute. They've been in the ditch and somehow miraculously come out of it a couple weeks in a row. They are one and a half point favorites. Eric, their fivestar supposed number one draft pick quarterback is in concussion protocol. Vandy's coming to town. They just knocked off Missouri and Longhorns
are one and a half point favorites. Please explain this to me. >> Um, well, number one, Texas defense is awesome. Uh, that's the reason game last weekend against Mississippi State and the 400 something yards that they gave up on. Did you see that? I also I also saw the game before that when the Kentucky didn't score and Oklahoma didn't score and you know the Ohio State scored 14. Those those it all they're still what seventh nationally in points per drive. Um which granted isn't quite as good as I would have expected since they've only played really one like top 30 offense, but still good. The defense is good. I'm really curious about Vanny's offense. Um, you know, my buddy
uh Bud Elliot and I used to talk a lot about co-variance within teams where like >> what huh? Are you flirting with us? Are you flirting with us, Bill? >> I knew this would be a good >> woke up. Are you kidding? Audi's going to be jealous. He missed the show. Covarian >> where basically some teams you have a Utah for example where they're going to crush teams with that have less talent than them. They just know like they're built their style is built around just absolutely devouring teams being more physical than them but they're less likely to you know they're they might
underachieve against top five or 10 teams against projections whereas other teams are the exact opposite and can craft a game plan and you know play great South Carolina almost beats Alabama um but then you know stinks against lesser teams. So, you know, with Vanderbilt, I kind of get the inklings of a design to destroy bad defenses offense. And um you know, basically like they they they did well against LSU's defense, although LSU's defense went from elite to like has been significantly worse over these last few weeks. They scored 14 points on Alabama. Uh they scored 17 on Missouri and and seven of that came from a short field at the end. and they gained like 250 yards
for the game, 260, something like that. Um, and Texas, like Texas and Missouri have pretty similar defenses, I think, but Texas has four and five star athletes everywhere you look and and Vanderbilt's not going to be able to really move them. So, I do kind of wonder about that aspect of things. Another thing is doesn't really matter if you play your backup quarterback if your first stringer stinks and you're not going to be punished much for that. I do think I think the line opened at three and a half. So maybe it came down a couple points to account for Arch Manning, but it is uh some amazing major Apple White uh potential situation here
where the the the you know, Sims gets hurt and Apple White comes in and is great. Uh Matthew Caldwell has the world just at his disposal right now. >> Well, that's going to be fun. For those who don't know, Caldwell was like a fourthyear transfer brought in just to have somebody who wasn't fresh out of high school as a backup. His latest stop was Troy, I think. The small the other stops were smaller than that. You he comes in last week and throws a game-winning touchdown in overtime. Beautiful and audible into it at that. So, you know, good good start. Maybe it's the other, you know, we'll take the he doesn't have to be a complete progyny
that Manning is. We'll take someone who, you know, can execute a few simple throws. Okay, fine. Eric's got his hand up there. >> So, I was going to talk about it since we're already on Vandy UT. I can make the same comment here as I would on the Ohio State Penn State game which you just talked about beforehand. You're someone, Bill, that cares as we all do about uncertainty. >> Is there any sim you think at the beginning of the season that would have had Ohio State as a 20point favorite on Penn State? Do you think there's any sim at the beginning of the season that would have had Vandy favored against Texas? I'm just trying to use this as a
general comment. Do we even massively underestimate uncertainty? Both these games make me think there's no sim where this would have been in in the distribution. It has been funny. I've been working with my buddy Justin Moore. He he runs a lot of the simulation stuff with me and um he like he'll he plugs so much uncertainty into when he's running like you conference title race, college football playoff forecast type of stuff. And so at the beginning of the year, I like I barely had any team in any conference with like a greater than 20% chance of winning the conference. And at first glance, I'm like, "Oh boy, I don't
know about that." Um, and but the way things have played out, it's it's really I, you know, it it did a great job, I think, of of forecasting that uncertainty. And we're still in a period where there are only a couple conferences with even like 50% uh title odds, I think. Um, yeah. I mean, I think that's absolutely the Penn State situation. I mean, they've only fallen to like tw 18th or something in SP plus. And honestly, like everybody's making fun of that at the moment on social, but the last game uh it they played was against a really solid Iowa team. Uh, and the projection was like 24 1.5 to 24.3 and the game was 2524 Iowa. Like,
so of course they didn't fall after that game. They had a a blocked field goal return in there which helped. But I mean I think they're still a top 20 or 30 team and uh you know if you're if you're I think you can account for that like if you're projected whatever Penn State was top three or so you've got to plug and they wouldn't have had as much uncertainty as other teams because they didn't hit the transfer portal as much. That was one of the ways we tried to bake it in like if you have 60 new guys then we're going to make up the huge error bar for you. Um, but they still I think you you you should be able to do that. We just ended up with some pretty wild outlier uh with between Clemson and
Penn State especially. We had some pretty big outliers at the top. >> So Eric, it's such a good question, Eric. This just it emphasizes how your sim has to have enough uncertainty into it. And I think the world's slowly catching up to this. Early on when people were running sims, they'd get their power rankings in the top of the season. and they say Penn State's a 22 and Florida State's an 18 and that's the number and all their sins would be based on that number and everything else is just a coin flip on who you know but that's just crazy. I I feel like the Texas Vandy outcome is utterly within the realm of normal Sims Penn State is I mean I'm hearing Bill give a little pep
talk here which is great but I mean that's a pretty big structural change to see those three losses. It would. Yeah, it ought to be in there because we've got 130 something teams and so you should see some extreme crops, but um it is extreme. Bill, another onfield question that I just continue to get a kick out of. I'm honestly curious. You watch more than me. You've been watching it more longer than I have, but I still can't get used to like the USC Nebraska mid-season games. Like USC going to Lincoln. One of my favorite football watching moments of this season so far was like a random afternoon I came in and popped down and watched USA in
Urbana Champagne. It was a great game, but it was just I got such a kick out of, you know, it's like a small stadium and here's USC playing in the middle of the Big 10. I I'm just not used to it. >> Yeah. At least with this one, we had the team of the 90s versus the team of the 2000s. >> It's a helmet game. It's a major helmet game in the middle of November, >> right? >> Um yeah, this is one of the ones I guess they sold when uh when they were convincing NBC to pay absurd amounts of money to air like Michigan State versus Purdue and prime time. Like they have a couple like it's been a pretty bad year for them. But um I I'm not there is a
novelty to a lot of it. I I remember for for my book I talked to my friend Nam. He's a C a Cal fan. Uh and of course Cal fans went nuts on the internet last year and a bunch of them traveled to Florida State and you know all the places across the country and Cal did pretty well for a while and they kind of tried to embrace the absolute absurdity of their schedule. Um and I think he went to Boston for Boston College this year. bunch of Florida State fans were go we're were going out to to Cal like it's all novelty stuff right now. >> Yeah. Right. >> But in 10 years when like h I'm not going back out to
Berkeley. I'm not going to this game. Like I I feel like the novelty is going to wear off and there's just not going to be unless you just play a ton of ridiculous close wild games against each other. That's kind of that's bonded Missouri and South Carolina to a certain degree. They played a bunch of nutty games and therefore they're kind of rivals even though they're 15 hours apart. Uh but even 15 hours isn't like 30 or whatever it would take to drive from uh you know the Midwest to to USC. So I just I hate that aspect. It's just it's a lot more fun when there are some road fans in the in and that aspect is going to get is going to hurt I think moving forward even if you know at least
we get a helmet game out of this. >> Yeah. Right, Eric. >> So but I want to ask a question. If we looked at the pre-season rankings or let's say FPI and now we're sitting here after whatever >> SP plus SP plus >> SP plus sorry SP plus and we're sitting there we're looking at SP plus at the beginning of the season and now or whatever 8 n whatever number of games in okay are there if if I had to ask you at the beginning of the season how many teams would it take for Bill Connley to cover 80% 90% % of the probability of winning the national title. Are there more teams or less teams in your set
right now? >> Um, >> I'm ask It's okay. I'm just to make sure my question again for our listener. Let's say at the beginning of the season, Bill thought there were 10 teams needed to cover 90% of the probability to win the national title. Is that number bigger or smaller than 10 right now? Has, in other words, has the season gone so anominously compared to the priors that it might actually, you might say, well, of course, the posterior has to be smaller because we've learned so much. But we might learn that we didn't actually know very much in our prior. So that's why I'm asking, is it more teams or less teams? >> My my initial instinct was to say less
just because I think Ohio State's just been cruising in second gear and they're going to hit the gas in the playoffs and destroy everybody. Um, and that'll get me most of the way to 90% right there. Um, but that aside, if I'm looking at the list, uh, just the current SB Plus rankings, like Georgia's 12th, and I could see them finding another gear. Uh, Texas is 13th. I could I I don't think I can see them finding another gear, but they have talent levels that could at least make it. So, I, you know, man, I don't know. Like, it it might actually My initial reflex was less, but it might be a couple more now. um >> you know I think just because >> I think it I think it might have gone
down for a while right like the certainty might have gone down in the first month of the season for sure >> right [clears throat] I don't know if it's it's rebounded all the way but >> either way I think if that's true by even if it's the same or or a little more I I don't know why I'm on a kick lately about studying I it's not really formally this in the statistical sense but most people would say you have a prior of course this is true you have a prior you collect data let's call that the likelihood the regular season and then by the end you have a posterior and most people think information reduces the posterior variance. So, we should have more certainty potentially on a
smaller number of teams. And I'm looking I'm actually studying problems like this in my home field of marketing now where actually information comes in and you're less certain, not more certain. And if this is true, I think this is great for sports. I don't think it's bad. I think it's good. >> Eric, the property you need is that the information coming in is disagreeing with the prior. >> That is correct. That is exactly correct. Well, speaking of priors, Bill, I I hadn't thought about this, but I had thought about it since I've talked with
you last. You are you getting sufficient victory laps on the season? And on what topics do you deserve victory laps? So, for example, I know you get them on Clemson. A lot of people lauded you early on as they burned they crashed and burned early. So, that's number one probably on the Bill Connelly victory lap for 2025 season. I think you should get one for Texas. You called out the uncertainty around both QB and offensive line. offensive line is the real issue, by the way. >> Yeah. >> Um and I and you were ear you were skeptical. You were longhorn skeptical based on exactly those issues which have proven true. So I'm giving you victory
props for those. And and look, we get things wrong all the time preseason. So we should at least note when we get them right. What else? What else is on the t-shirt? I'm making a t-shirt for you now. What's on the t-shirt for the 2025 victory lap for Connley? >> Well, I'm pretty sure having Ohio State projected number one is going to turn out pretty well, too. Um, >> I hope you're ahead of yourself. >> I I hope I am too. Like I want a I want a fun play out this year. Um, yeah, those are It is funny. One thing I've definitely learned this season is um, you know, as far as what you get credit for, it's all about closest to the pen because I still had Clemson projected
tenth. [laughter] I was just lower than everybody else. Therefore, I was closest to being therefore I I get a lot of credit for being skeptical. And and you're right. I mean, with Texas, um, my whole line in the offseason was if Arch is anything but the best player in the country, massive uncertainty on the O line and receiver and core sure could matter. And that it's mattered a massive amount, >> but uh, but I still had them projected fifth rank in the team now. >> So, um, th those were the big ones. Uh, just kind of looking through a lot of the top rankings. I mean, Michigan is was a whiff, I think, to a certain
degree. They weren't I didn't think they were going to be top 10, so I disagreed with SP plus and I had Notre Dame pretty high, which I think is still going to pay off pretty well. Um, you know, Penn State was a whiff obviously as well, but no, I think Ohio State, Texas, and Clemson are the ones that um that that make them that that I I feel pretty good about still. >> Brad, let's jump in here. >> Yeah. Yeah. No, I I was just going to ask you um do you think that um I I always like to ask these questions. So, you all you think Ohio State's obviously a very good team. maybe one maybe the best team and you let's say you have
some SP plus predicted championship win probability and now I say oh wait I forgot to tell you Ryan Duke finally got off the schneide and won the title last year is that worth anything to you >> um yeah I think so really um >> guys know I ask this question every time it's not going to call momentum I'm just going to call it I've I've got this additional piece of information that maybe you haven't factored into your model and I'm just asking you is that worth anything? >> Well, so in my head it's worth something. To a to my model it's not. Let's put it that way. Well, I mean >> it's baked in through their performance,
>> right? It's it's baked in through the fact that they played a bunch of good teams and beat them soundly at the end of the year. Therefore, they ranked higher and therefore it carries forward. But as far as just knowing that they won, in my head it means I can trust Ryan Day a little bit more. clear there is no co-variant in your model that has has the coach won a national championship has the coach won a national championship recently there could be and one could assess whether that's worth anything but at the moment there is no factor like that in the model >> right just pure pure mental model but not not S+ formula model >> but Bill's always been good um for years
at at running his model sharing his model results and then saying but I would judge it this way or that way like he recognizes that his if his if he was going to write down his actual predictions, it would be based on the model, but it would be permuted in some way. All right, Bill, we got to cut. >> Starts with the numbers and then >> Yeah, goes from there. Yeah, >> we got to cut you out here, but I want to ask you um to help us uh look beyond the obvious two conferences and maybe even beyond Well, let's beyond the obvious two conferences. Give us one of your favorite storylines, hopefully one that's ongoing so we can still enjoy it from outside of the SEC and Big 10. and
let me constrain you from not going all the way off the edge into FCS. I know you'd like to go into FCS, but let me constrain you to FBS for the time being and just give us give us an additional story line. >> I I did have an answer ready to go about Harvard there, but um [laughter] I my my model has been like third in the country right now. >> I I I realize I'm not telling that to the right audience, but um no, honestly, one of the most interesting stories both for the present and the future of the sport is Texas Tech, I think. Um, you know, they made a big deal. Cody
Campbell, Mr. Oil billionaire booster, um, you know, went out and got the best softball pitcher in the country and they immediately went to the national title game last year. Can't remember who they lost to in that national title game. >> I think it might have been one of my favorite Longhorn sports watching moments of all time. >> Um, but but they still went from nothing to national runner up. Then they went out and got a few more players this year. They're going to be dynamite this year. But um he's basically trying to kind of openly break the model of the sport right now um by just throwing millions of dollars of players. They
have tons of like fivestar commits moving forward. >> And facilities facilities, have you seen the hype video around those facilities? It's incredible. >> We're I'm I'm happy we haven't lost that just because we have to pay players. We're still going to make facilities that are 38 times too good uh for what they're needed. But they went out and he they made a big deal about getting the most expensive transfer class in the country. I wasn't completely sure how much it was going to fix their defense. Their defense is phenomenal. And basically, if they can keep their
quarterback healthy, which they haven't been able to do, their backups hurt now, but I think their starters back to being able to play. They're fourth in SP plus uh despite having missed their uh their starting quarterback the last two weeks. Like they have really really clicked. And I think if you know I am very much worried about the way the SEC and Big 10 have basically arranged to hoard all the money from the future of the sport uh and the playoff and all that and Texas Tech coming in here and just trying to break things and make people react is I I can't guarantee that'll produce a good
reaction or if it's something I like but I I like that they're trying it. I think and and they're really really really good and fast this year. >> Good good fun. They have a big game this weekend. Kate, one of the early um preseason Big 12 favorites or >> they're smoking hot too. So, I said all this and now they're going to lose to Kate State. >> Exactly. Bill I Bill said in this week's review that Kate was really on the come after having really had a early season bumps, but they they have a good program and it should be an interesting game this weekend. Bill, we've kept you longer than we meant to. Always
enjoyable to talk to you, Bill Connley. Y'all chasing down ESPN um ESPN Bill C on Twitter. It's probably looking pretty similar on Blue Sky, I'm guessing. But you can see Bill lots of places and buy his book, Forward Progress: The Future of College Football just out this fall. >> Absolutely. >> Thank you, Bill. >> Take care, guys. >> That's been the first half of Wharton Moneyball. Come back and join us after the break. >> Welcome back. Welcome back to the Wharton podcast network and Wharton Moneyball. This is Eric Bradlo, professor of marketing, statistics, and data science. and I'm here with my co-host, longtime friend, co-graduate
school classmate, although years apart, professor of statistics and data science, Shane Jensen. Uh this is the second half of the show. Uh we just had Kade Massie leading us with Bill Connley of ESPN and SP Plus talking about college football and what surprised him. But now, uh Shane, we have to move on to the open, if you'd like, line segment of the show. Of course, one of the topics I know we want to talk about is baseball. But before we get to what caught your eye in last night's game or baseball more generally, um I had turned off the game in the seventh inning. I was sound asleep and then my two West Coast sons,
the phone rings at 1:00 in the morning. Of course, I'm panicking like, "What is it? What is it?" Goes, "Dad, you're never going to believe it." In the 13th inning, you got to put on the game and watch the rest of it. >> So, I did watch innings 13 through 18, by the way, uh thanks to Ethan and Zack Bradlo. But, um what caught your eye in the game? There's lots of things, but I'd love to hear or just more broadly about what's happening in baseball. >> Well, what a couple things that caught my eye specifically about that game, and this is one thing for the game in general. It's pretty cool. Like there the in 2018, the World Series game three
also went 18 innings. They're the two longest games in World Series history. The one in 2018 took 7 hours and 20 minutes. The one last night was 6 hours and 40 minutes, basically. So the pitch cl we we've got kind of a a nice little like control experiment for the >> Let me ask a question. I know just to really control. Do you happen to know what was the score in that game? Like was there more scoring, less scoring? Was >> I don't I don't I'm not sure I have in front of it, but the No. Uh well the this game actually the one last night had 600 Here's here's one kind of proxy. The one last night had 609 pitches versus only 561 pitches in the one in 2018. So the one last night actually had
more pitches. >> All right. So now I love that because actually to me that might be an even greater proxy. Although I do agree number of pitches, hard to imagine more pitchers than last night's game because I think you know I was about to go in and pitch. My son was about to drive down who lives in LA was about to drive down to Dodger Stadium and see if they needed an arm. But >> well you I don't know and the one of the other things that I noticed about the game last night before we get to show is Yamamoto has pitched two complete games in this playoffs and was was warming up in the bullpen last night. two days after pitch. Let me ask your opinion
about that. As you know, if Yamamoto uh he had pitched two days ago. >> Yeah. A complete game, >> right? He would he would normally do some throwing today anyway. So, do you see it that different than let's imagine his throwing day is 40 50 pitches, whatever it is. So, why don't you just why can't he just come into the game and throw 40 or 50 pitches? >> I mean, you I mean, I guess I'm not a I'm not a pitcher, so I don't know. I would assume that whatever kind of bullpen regime he has, >> he's not throwing high 90s to let it rip. >> Not in the kind of intense environment where he's still facing like Guerrero
Jr. and stuff like that. So, no, I I I don't think I I don't think it would be an analogous simulated game. I mean, I think it's certainly the other the other situation is like, you know, he's got to if he comes in, he's got to get through three batters, right? It's not like you can kindly suddenly like, you know, >> let me ask you a question about that. Let me ask you a question. So, this is an interesting trade-off. Let's suppose that Yamamoto did have to come in. Okay? And let's imagine we believe he's a good pitcher. Not a bad thing to assume, right? Let's imagine it increases their win probability in this game by some
number, but it for some reason it also decreases their win probability in game five, let's say, which is which is what he would have pitched. How do you think about that mathematics? Like in other words, while you gain, you might also, we have no, by the way, we have no evidence that it would lower the probability for game five, but we could hypothesize it might. How would you think about that? I I don't know how I would >> as a manager. I think I'd go >> immediate benefit at all, you know, type of thing. Like I think you kind of have to go. I mean, because the hypothetical like game five or six, the world could change between now and then.
>> It might never happen. >> Yeah. It might never happen. You may not, you know, you never may get to realize that game six or seven benefit. No. And I And I think he it would be like game six or seven he'd be lined up. He would >> It's also a discreet outcome, as you're pointing out, which is they're now up two to one. I mean, that's a big difference than being down two to one. I mean, it's a big difference. >> Yeah. No, it was I mean, especially like after that. I mean, we'll see what happens tonight with Shi on the mound after going nine for like getting on base nine times last night. Well, let me ask you a
question about that record, by the way. >> Yeah, I know. Tied a record. Yep. Tied a record. >> Well, I mean, record in the postseason. >> No, I think it tied a record. I saw Antonio I mean the previous on the screen >> the previous times it's ever happened in a baseball game all in like the pre9 in the 1940s or earlier >> the previous like I think it the postseason record is eight I think the >> oh I thought it was nine I thought he had match >> and the uh World Series record prior to last night was six. >> Okay, but let me ask you another
question. >> Crazy. Is there any way in your mind that this 18 ining game yesterday affects his pitching ability? >> Yeah. No, I mean I I you'd think it would, right? I mean, I don't know. I mean, maybe he's again, he continues to exhibit superhuman powers. So, I I I I I can only project what me as a human would experience, but I feel like yes, having to play an 18 inning game and then go out and pitch the next day would definitely I feel like affect your performance. So, I mean, I think that that's an extra element of of course. I mean, they couldn't take him out
because he was an automatic on base. I I mean like you can't I can't you can't pull him out of the lineup when he's getting on base every time he goes up but you know they must have been I I yes I I think it does it could have a dramatic effect today that said he continues to defy expectations so question so now he's had I mean this game obviously extraordinary memorable nine times on base he obviously had the what was it three homer game three homer and 10 strikeout game >> right three homer and 10 strikeout game. How much does his level of, let's call it, three sigma, four sigma performances, I mean, these are some of the greatest performances in any baseball game ever.
How much does it change your view of him like where he ranks in kind of all time now? >> I actually do. I I think he might be the greatest baseball player of all time, which is kind of a crazy thing to say. Now, just to be clear, >> do not believe I think I agree. I think you're going to agree with what I'm about to say. >> We can have a debate. Let's take tennis just for one second or football for one second. We can debate maybe maybe whether NovakJokovic is the greatest tennis player of all time, but he's certainly the most accomplished tennis player of all time. Somebody might want
to debate whether there was some tiny stretch of their time that was um somebody was better than Tom Brady, but certainly Tom Brady by far is the most accomplished football player of all time. You're not saying that you think Show is the most accomplished baseball player of all time. You just I mean >> Yeah. Like I mean like you know on like some cumulative weather measure of overall performance. I mean, somebody like B, I I think it's got to still be Dave Ruth. I I just I think, you know, show is doing something that nobody in the sport has ever done before. And it's kind of reim I I mean, you sort of said it to me, it's kind of it is inspiring. It's reimagining the sport to me like
like like he is he really like an absolute unicorn? we'll never see it again. Or or or are we looking at like a situation where like a generation from now there's multiple like there's there there's two-way players like often on the field or something like that. What if he what if this is like you know he he he could actually end up inspiring like a change in the sport or maybe he's just that he's like six sigma or whatever it is off the chain and and uh we'll never see something like it again. But it's it is kind of um let me ask a question. I think kind of uniqueness is the kind of proxy or or or construct on which I think he's the greatest of all time. Cumulative achievement obviously.
>> In other words, there's a multi-dimensional you're now taking two dimensions by which you could make an argument. Well, let me ask you a question before I make my statement. I think you would agree, but tell me if I'm wrong, that he's farther in the tail as a hitter than he is as a pitcher. or you wouldn't agree to that? >> Yes. Yes, that's right. I mean, if you if you kind of kind of consider them two separate people. I mean, yeah, that's right. >> If you consider them two separate He's like uh he's like a top five hitter in baseball or maybe like a top 10 or 15 pitcher in baseball.
>> Yeah, that's what I was That's what I was asking or at least certainly how he's pitched the last year. >> Yeah. So am I to get to look and the other stat I saw which I know you saw in his last seven at bats remember walks don't count as official at bats he has five home runs and two doubles. I mean I've never seen I've never se I mean look he has to go down look as you know obviously everyone on the show knows I'm a Yankee fan. He has to be Mr. October. >> Yeah. Yeah. And I I mean it's kind of crazy. It's like, you know, it's and and then in the midst of all that, you somehow forget about what Freddy
Freeman's doing. >> I was going to ask you, I was like also like just like clutch home run after clutch. >> I don't know if you I actually went in this World Series cheering for the Blue Jays if you believe it. >> And I I was rooting for the Blue Jays while you're Canadian at some I understand you're not from Toronto. I got it that you know that might as well be the other part of the world for where you >> Yeah. I mean, normally in the AL East, I'm not I don't find myself cheering for him during the course of the season all that often. Anyway, fun story, but like I mean, you know what the Dodgers doing
and and again, it's hard not to kind of just get wrapped up in the drama of um Freeman. Anyway, I think I interrupted you with about Freddy. >> No, no, no, no, no. What I was going to say was I just saw I I'm sure you saw this stat about Freddy Freeman. I actually I was surprised by this. He's the only player in Major League Baseball history with two walk-off home runs in the World Series. >> Yeah, that's interesting. >> I'd never seen that. I mean, obviously >> I I'd heard I think like if you expand that to postseason, I like >> four or five like I then you've got like Ortiz and Pooh Holes and I think maybe
Jeter, too. I'm not sure. like there's a few others that have done it over the opposition. It is you give some weird cuts of the data when you restrict yourself specifically the World Series. But you you'd think even like in you know all those decades where the Yankees were destroying you know balls that that would have happened before as well. >> Yeah. Can you remind our listeners on here on uh Wharton Moneyball uh the Jensen stats for the Hall of Fame and how as cuz we're talking about Freddy Freeman. I just wanted to know remind me like roughly if you remember how many hits, how many home runs kind of what gets you into the Hall of Fame. You
remember to keep things as the same basic fraction of players as it is now. >> Yeah, I believe it's 350 home runs or 2500 hits I believe. >> Okay. Well, just to be clear, >> I'll check that as we're talking. knew it was 2500 hits. It could have been 350 home runs. So, you agree with me? >> He's a Hall of Famer now. And by the way, there's an outside chance he could join the Elite 500 home run, 30,000 hit club. He has 2400 and something hits, 369 home runs. He's 36. He plays four more seasons, which yeah, looks pretty good to me. I just I'm not saying he's going to. >> Yeah, that's right. Look, I think it's less likely he's
going to get the 500 home runs, but he may damn well get the 3,000 hits. I mean, he may go down in terms you go back to and he's got a 300 lifetime batting average and these days 3,000 hits. >> Yeah. I mean, >> in a year, 500 home runs. And I think I think just to give it perspective, I mean um I think kind of you know marginal hall of famers start kicking in around like a war of 50 or so. A cumulative career war 50. He's at already at like 65 >> really. >> Yeah. Yeah. He's already he's like at 65 war. I mean, you know, and so I I think he's I I think I'm and I haven't checked out like Jaffy's kind of specific hall of fame kind of predictions, but I I
have to think he's a shoe it. I mean I think whether he's like a first out Hall of Famer will when he goes up and who else is there, right? I mean, I think he's not, you know, he's >> he's not like an automatic first ballot kind of guy, I think, but like he's definitely a Hall of Famer and I mean, the postseason heroics, I mean, what if what if this is only the beginning? It's crazy. It could very well be. So, let me ask you um one last you put somewhere I think it was you probably you that put in the rundown. How is Max Scherzer? He's been on six different postseason teams. Yes. >> Isn't that worth something?
>> Yeah. No. No. I mean, I think so. I mean, and again, you I mean, he I think he pitched great last, you know, I mean, he he he gave a gutsy performance last night as well. No, I mean, I think that's that that is incredible, but yeah, he's a basically I mean, he's he's been on a several kind of like, you know, heroic trajectories like I mean, back on the nationals and, you know, >> did he win was he on the nationals team that won? >> Yes, he was. >> Was that his only World Series title? Uh, I'm trying to think if he was on the Dodgers in 2020 or not. I Let me Let me pull him up again here like just as we're talking, but I I I I think he it
might be Oh, and the Rangers. Was he on the Rangers when they won? >> Because I think that might have been that might have been also a a World >> He's a two-time World Series champion. 2023. >> Yep. Nationals and Rangers. So, yeah. Yeah. >> Wow. >> Yeah. Yeah. I mean, but it's three times Sai Young award winner. I mean, well, we we know Max Sh is a Hall of Famer. Yeah. Know that that that his first ballot unless there's something really wrong with with what's what's going on at the time. >> Let me ask a question. Why do you think I wouldn't have thought this about
baseball? So, it's been since 2000, I believe, where we've had a repeat champion in baseball. >> Yes. Okay. Remind me when's the last time it happened in the NFL? The Chiefs just recently, right? Yeah. The Chiefs. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. The Chiefs were two-time champs. The Eagles just beat them. They would have been three times. >> Yeah. Well, I mean that that they they they ended a streak that had been for like >> the NBA we've definitely had repeat champions. I mean, the Heat were repeat champions. The Warriors were repeat champions. All of that kind of stuff. >> We're in the middle of going in hockey.
>> In hockey, maybe we've had that recently. I'm joking. Of course, we have time repeat champion. the the the Panthers right now. Why do you think in baseball? I wouldn't have if you would asked me to guess which sport would be the hardest. Well, I don't want to say of the four major sports, forget what you know about the data, which sport and why would you have guessed that being a repeat champion is the hardest? Like on what is there a statistical basis of thinking about it? Could be based on randomness. It could be based on the coin flip model. I'm just >> Yeah. I mean, I guess the coin I I mean, you know, I I I feel like baseball has
always seemed the most kind of coin flippy in the I I think the structure of baseball is such that the playoffs selects heavily for good teams and which makes you know the the the like you know the the differences between the playoff teams you know minimizes their disparity and therefore is closest to the coin flip model and so under the coin flip model you should not coin flip model plus expanded playoffs. That's another factor right? So, one thing that has happened in baseball structurally over the last couple decades is they have continued to expand or increase the randomness of the the more coin
flippiness of the playoffs basically by just expanding the number of rounds. And so, um with with short series, uh so I I I think that's really what kind of leads to it in baseball. I mean, I think it's it's since you know the Yankees of 2000 some that there's been a repeat champion. I think it's been since ' 09 that there's this is even like a team's gone back to the World Series. The Dodgers are the first time to go back to the World Series. I think even >> was the Phillies, right? The Phillies were the back. Wow. >> Yeah, that's remarkable. Yeah. I I I guess it has to be. Let me ask a
question. Is is it is the reason you think it's because of the Dodgers? It it has to be their pitching, right? I understand how great show is as a hitter, but I mean they've got Yamamoto, Otani, Blake Snell, and I don't even know I apologize who their fourth pitcher is. >> Gas now is the one that pitched last yesterday. >> All right. Well, I mean Yeah. Yeah. No, I that's right. And I I mean, Suzaki, who is their big offseason signing, is suddenly like this crazy good closer. I do think outside, you know, outside of Suzaki, their bullpen is to the extent that they have a weakness, their weakness. And so I think they're kind of
they are very much leaning successfully on incredible starting pitcher. Again, I mean Yamamoto has made their bullpen moot that this last couple two two complete game like victories. I mean that's like that's like I is he he's doing stuff that like we haven't seen since like Madison Bumgardner or something. >> Before we move to the NFL, by the way, just one point. I know you know this. Um the total number of runs in the series, the Blue Jays have more runs and more hits by the way at this point in the series. So, let's not seem like, by the way, that the Blue Jays are getting overwhelmed here. The Blue Jays are not
getting overwhelmed. And by the way, >> I mean, Freddy Freeman doesn't hit that home run. Guerrero hits it instead. We We're probably talking I mean, we're still talking Guerrero. >> No, a totally totally different narrative. I agree with that. It'll be exciting. Look, if somehow someway the Blue Jays win tonight's game, >> 22. >> Yeah. No, I'm still I'm still full for I mean, obviously, I'm kind of a Otani fanboy, so I'd love to see him, you know, be special again tonight. But, uh, I'm still cheering for the Blue Jays in this series. I hope they make it a long one, and I hope it's, uh, >> yeah, I I I I I hope I mean, it's been
magical already, so I mean, I just hope we >> So, let's let's spend the last five minutes or so talking about the NFL. >> What's caught your eye in the NFL? >> Well, am I am I allowed to talk about the Patriots and the fact that there's >> talk about the Patriots? Let me ask you a question. They I want to talk about the Patriots specifically in the context of FBI. I think I put in the rundown. >> You know, I've been kind of looking at it and I mean, we don't have to focus on FBI specifically, but I have noticed that, you know, the ranking system certainly
FBI specifically have the Patriots like like in the still in the bottom half or near halfway point of the teams. >> As you pointed out, I'm looking at it right now. They have a lower FBI than the Giants. >> It's crazy. The only thing I can think of is is scroll across and this is certainly true and this is the mark against the Patriots that prevents me from getting too too excited is they have the most cream puff schedule that I've ever like I mean >> it's the easiest 32 and you know what the remaining strength of schedule is 29. >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean they I mean it it helps that they were one of the
worst teams in the NFL last year, right? So I guess um and so the Giants for example though also a bad schedule last team last year have one of the hardest schedules at least so far. So that's the only thing that kind of would argue but I mean I personally think I I I'd like to hear your take. I mean I I get waiting down waiting them because they have had kind of a cream puff schedule. Do you still feel like they like how would you describe the Patriots playoff team? Actual contending team >> what do you think? Good question. So, let me just focus, okay, on Oh, sorry. Let me focus on here. Let me just focus on uh their schedule and who they've played. Okay. So, hold on a second here.
>> Yeah. >> Bringing this up here. All right. So, well, there's some good and some bad here. >> Well, I mean, in terms of who they played, it's basically the Bills and >> No. Well, they lost to the Raiders to start the season. Not good. >> Yeah. >> They beat the Dolphins. Probably not worth much. They lost to the Steelers in a close game. That's on a horrible loss. Now, they beat the Panthers. Panthers lost last week, but that's not a horrible win. Obviously, winning at Buffalo is worth a lot. They lost. They beat the Saints. They stink. They beat the Titans. They stink. And they beat
the Browns. They stink. Well, the Browns defense doesn't stink, but whatever. No, I mean I mean it's true that again, the schedule has been and will continue. I mean, again, they they they they do play the Bills again and uh they play the Ravens and the Ravens may have >> and they play together. >> Obviously, I may go to I'm still deciding. They're at Buccaneers. >> Yeah. >> In two weeks. >> Yeah. Know that that So, those are going to be a few there's going to be a few losses coming up the schedule, but I feel like already at six and two, they're >> they'd have to really tank to not make
the playoffs at this. Look, they if they in quotes, they should beat the Jets. That's seven. They these are all home games. They should be the Giants, that's eight. They should beat the Jets again, that's nine. They should beat the Dolphins, that's 10. Then they're in the playoffs. So they're a So here's my view. They're a playoff team. I think come the playoffs. I do not think they can beat the Chiefs. I do not think they can beat the Bills. Other than that, nobody else in the AFC impresses me that much that >> you know who we haven't been talking about at all. The Colts are the number one team. You're
>> right. That's the other one I kind of want to get your beat on is that I you know it's it's kind of like the Colts right now are I mean they're they're shooting the moon. They're looking great. >> Do you remember that Steelers team that went like 10 and0 a couple a few years ago? Like absolutely >> you know it it was over from there type of thing. I I I feel like I can't that the Indianapolis Colts have turned it around too quickly and in kind of an improbable way that like I can't buy into them yet. And I I I I wonder whether you have at all bought into them yet. I mean, the Pats I haven't incentive to buy into. That's a different story.
>> You know, I can't believe yet. >> Just to be just so I'm reminding myself, Danny Dimes is their quarterback, right? >> Well, we call him Indiana Jones now. >> Sorry. Indiana Jones. Sorry. It was Danny Dimes. Um, no. I still find it hard to believe that a team led by Daniel Jones is going to beat a team led by Josh Allen or beat a team led by uh Patrick Mahomes. No. I don't I But but if you're asking me, are the Colts going to be a tough out? Yes. Are the Patriots going to be potentially a tough out? Yes. Cuz here's what you know also about the Patriots. Vable's teams, they're not beating themselves. They may be worse than the Chiefs. They may be worse than the Colts. They may be worse than the
the the Chiefs Colts Bills. They're not going to like turn the ball over four or five times. Drake May is not going to implode during the playoffs. None of that stuff is actually going to happen. So I No, I think the Patriots are a playoff team. And no, I don't think this is their year yet. >> Yeah. >> But it's amazing we're talking in this way, though, because it was I mean, it was a dark couple seasons, but it was only a dark couple seasons. >> No, no, no. I agree. Well, this has been an hour here on the Wharton Podcast Network. This has been an hour here on Wharton Moneyball. On behalf of myself,
Eric Bradley, I'd like to thank my co-host, Shane Jensen, who's been here for the entire hour. I'd like to thank Cade Massie, who was here, uh, and our guest, uh, Bill Connley. Like to thank our producer, Marissa Rena, I'd like to thank our associate producer, sound engineer, Dion Simkins. Between now and next week, enjoy your sports, enjoy your statistics. We'll see you next week here on Wharton Moneyball.





