Beugoms, Jean Pierre

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Brief Summary

The episode covers forecasting methods in military and political contexts, emphasizing historical analysis and critical thinking.

Key points

  • Forecasting Elections. The speaker shares their journey into political forecasting after Clinton's defeat.
  • The Importance of Historical Context. Understanding history can provide insights into future events, as shown by the Gulf War predictions.

Transcript

that goes back to when I was a younger man during the first Gulf War in 1991 uh I was I'm interested in the military military history and a lot of people and pundits were making predictions about the outcome the manner in which the war would be waged and decided as well as casualty counts and how long it would take and basically everyone was wrong on the duration and the and the destructiveness well the number of casualties suffered by coalition forces and that was interesting to me because there was one historian I'd like to say Trevor Dupree you got it right and I was interested in and how he got it right like and evidently he had a system in just a few years later during the

nineteen ninety-four midterm elections when Bill Clinton lost in a landslide to the Republicans the Republicans took the Congress for the first time in 40 years after that defeat basically every pundit on earth was saying that Bill Clinton is a one-term president and being a staunch Democrat in a Clinton supporter I was traumatized by that possibility and wondered whether they knew they whether they knew what they were talking about and at about that time I found a book written by another historian Alan Jay Lippman um about predicting you know who would become the next president and evidently he had a system where you

didn't need to use poles you just look at history and using his method I realized that actually Bill Clinton was in a pretty good shape his his chances weren't guaranteed but you know even a year before the election um I had a pretty good inkling that he had a good chance of winning re-election and this was against what all the pundits were saying so based on those two events there were probably other events as well that's why I became interested in forecasting basically the fact that everyone you know got thing big thing was wrong and I want to know why and some people got big things right and I wanted to know why and whether I could do as well as I could so ever since then

I was I started you know I'm my own forecasting you know the outcomes of wars and elections and with mixed results but you know so but over 20 years so so that's how that's how I became interested I don't trust my gut so usually my first impression is right about half the time so in order to do well in a forecasting tournament you have to dig deeper into the sources if you're predicting elections for example you know I'm find out you know what happened in the past you know which parties were likely to win and under what circumstances do your research about the electoral system sometimes you know the electoral system

could lead to a counterintuitive result you know a party could do very well in the polls and still lose the election so it's just really a matter of doing your homework trying to understand the situation the history behind the event and and really working hard at it and I would say a second reason would be mmm my sense of history so I think that comes in very handy because most people when they would forecast whatever event it is would really look to the recent past draw on their own memories as well as maybe you know Google search of of you know the recent news events but I think having a sense of history that stretches back far arm can give one a sense of em possibilities which you know

the recent past might not indicate okay well along with not trusting my own gut feelings my first impressions I don't trust the gut feelings and of experts and pundits I try to when ever possible to discover understand what assumptions underlie their forecasts sometimes they're explicit about this and other times they aren't they don't really they'll say you know this event is likely but not really explain and if I keep doing my research and find other pundits you say a certain event is likely without you know much explanation at all then that's a signal for me to really do some deep research and and try to even if I agree with that assumption

you know sometimes I'll just try to play the devil's advocate and say well let's pretend that this silly outcome that's unlikely to happen you know actually could happen and kind of play that out and sometimes you know I'll go back to my original estimate yeah that's silly it's not going to happen but you know often is the case that the silly outcome is becomes the more likely one so that's that's one thing I do and others I try to discover or to find out you know who has the power in a certain situation who who is the decider in the words of george w bush and that's one that keeps coming back all the time and also you

know in every forecast you want to write down a list or in your head you know of all the constraints that would pretend prevent a certain event from occurring or slow it down you know make an event you know an a likely event take longer to occur then you know what was expected before so they're just a few things well one of the things i would recommend would be to write down a list of all the things that would that you should be on the lookout for that might cause you to change your mind so after you've done your homework you thought deeply about you know the event and the likelihood of of it occurring write down a list of of

things that you know would happen leading up to the event or signals markers whatever that would cause you to change your mind and I'm the reason why I say write it down is because it's because you know it's very hard to change your mind and if you write it down it might be helped you you know not try to to fudge things well you know if it's if it's just in the back of your head you know mm it becomes a little bit more difficult to to go against you know your original original conclusion because I mean you put a lot of work into this and you don't want to go back on it and if there's a natural tendency not to want to you know waffle or be too

wishy-washy but you know having it down on paper will just show you well I'm not being wishy-washy you know events have changed things have changed and maybe my initial conclusion was wrong I would say the third thing would be to play devil's advocate after immediately after you've you know come to a conclusion and made a forecast seek out information that would prove you wrong you know if anything you know just to cover all your bases I'd say my fourth piece of advice would be to seek a wide variety of sources even weak and biased sources because sometimes you can find interest in

information in very flawed sources but that'll take some work on your part to determine you know which part of these you know particular reports are worth you know holding on to and which part should be discarded it's not an easy task but don't just you know casually disregard even even bad sources because you never know from four years as a as a forecaster in the gjp tournament I can say that another piece of advice I would give is to assume that things would take longer than your initial impression that's a rule of thumb because it happens consistently time and time again that whatever it is a diplomatic initiative or or or what have you events

often will take a lot longer than then what what you think you know they will take or what officials you know the timetable of officials and and and that's just been my experience from doing this for a long time final piece of advice would be a embrace uncertainty don't get too hung up on getting things correct you're never going to get everything correct you're going to get a lot of things wrong I would focus more on assigning viable or realistic probabilities to events just think of it in terms of you know if I assignment seventy percent probability to a particular event you know I'm going to be wrong three out of ten times you know

for so if you if you work on being well calibrated instead of trying to get everything right I think that's probably a more fruitful endeavor I'm not sure that they have all they probably should having practice at forecasting geopolitical events maybe I should start practicing forecasting events related to my own personal life maybe that would help me avoid being unpleasantly surprised by my things but so I'm not really sure how it's affected my personal life other than having nice dinner time conversations with families and friends you

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes